Headquarters U.S. Air Force
Integrity - Service - Excellence
CY10
Air Force Reserve
Majors
Line and Health Professions
Promotion Selection Board
1 - 5 February 2010
Overview
• Results
•Overall Participating Board
•Participating Line
•Participating Health Professions
•Position Vacancy Board
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve
Results by Competitive Category
FY09 CY09 CY10
Comp Considered Selected
Select
Considered Selected
Select
Considered Selected
Select
Rate Rate Rate
Cat
Line 393 251 64% 486 336 69% 392 247 63%
Nurse 80 60 75% 88 31 35% 109 60 55%
Medical 22 13 59% 23 13 57% 24 17 71%
BSC 24 13 54% 22 18 82% 16 10 63%
MSC 17 14 82% 44 39 89% 24 19 79%
Dental 9 6 67% 11 7 64% 10 8 80%
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve
Minorities & Females
Minorities Females White Males
Comp Considered Selected
Select
Considered Selected
Select
Considered Selected Select
Rate Rate
Cat
Line 79 41 52% 93 59 63% 218 144 66%
Nurse 33 18 55% 59 33 56% 25 13 52%
Medical 6 4 67% 2 2 100% 12 9 75%
BSC 5 3 60% 2 1 50% 7 6 86%
MSC 11 9 82% 8 6 75% 10 8 80%
Dental 5 4 80% 1 1 100% 4 3 75%
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Top OPR Older than 15 Months
60%
CY10 % OPR CloseOut >15mths for Selects
50% CY10 % OPR CloseOut >15mths for Non-Selects
43%
40%
33%
30%
20% 16% 17%
13% 12%
10% 7%
5%
0% 0% 0% 0%
0%
Line Nurse MSC BSC Dental Medical
13Yr Trend AF Reserve Majors Boards
Participating Reserve Line Select Rates
90% 90%
Participating Line
Participating IPZ Line
80% 80%
Participating APZ Line
70% 70%
60% 60%
50% 50%
Select Rate
40% 40%
30% 30%
20% 20%
FY99 FY00 FY01 FY02 FY03 FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 CY09 CY10
Board Year
AF Reserve Majors Boards
13 Yr PR Line History & 4 Yr Projections
1500
1295
1238 Line Considered
1250 1186 Line IPZ Considered
1070
Line Selects to Major
1056 1076
1028
1000 912
924
Projections
776
946 886
750 712
788
755 601 592
548
550
# Captains
660 498
496
465 493 452
500 441 392 437
381 393 360
347 333 353 469 360
284 292 280 278 416
368 396
250 325 336 342
310
257 259 251 247
0
FY99 FY01 FY03 FY05 FY07 FY09 CY10 CY12 CY14
Board Year
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve Line - BDE
Select Rate BDE Completion Rate
100%
89%
83% 83% 81%
80%
69%
63% 63%
60% 52%
40%
20%
0%
Overall Females Minorities Rated
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve Line - BDE
Select Rate Select Rate BDE Completed Select Rate BDE not Complete
90%
75% 77% 76%
75% 69%
63% 63% 63%
60% 52%
45%
30%
15% 7% 8%
5%
0%
0%
Overall Females Minorities Rated
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve Line Results
Results by Reserve Category
FY09 CY09 CY10
Select Select Select
ARFID Considered Selected
Rate
Considered Selected
Rate
Considered Selected
Rate
Traditional 170 121 71% 238 180 76% 188 118 63%
ART 24 21 88% 30 26 87% 23 20 87%
UNIT 194 142 73% 268 206 77% 211 138 65%
IMA 151 80 53% 149 95 64% 137 85 62%
AGR 8 8 100% 3 2 67% 4 2 50%
LEAD 0 - - 0 - - 3 3 100%
SELSVS 11 2 18% 11 0 0% 7 4 57%
ALO 18 13 72% 26 15 58% 20 9 45%
CAPRAO 6 3 50% 7 1 14% 4 3 75%
RRPS 5 3 60% 22 17 77% 6 3 50%
Overall 393 251 64% 486 336 69% 392 247 63%
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve Line Results
Results by Major Commands
With 10 or more Considered
FY09 CY09 CY10
Select Select Select
MAJCOM Considered Selected
Rate
Considered Selected
Rate
Considered Selected
Rate
AMC 134 92 67% 196 147 75% 144 95 66%
AIA 41 20 49% 62 46 74% 25 14 56%
ACC 49 36 82% 45 30 67% 42 26 62%
SPACECOM 24 18 75% 23 19 83% 27 23 85%
AFMC 25 11 44% 16 6 38% 21 11 52%
AETC 13 11 85% 14 13 93% 17 11 65%
OSI 9 7 78% 12 5 42% 13 10 77%
OVERALL 393 251 64% 486 336 69% 392 247 63%
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve – IMA Line
Missing Line IMA Top OPRs & Effect on Select Rates
% Missing IMA Top OPRs
100%
Select Rate Top OPR Missing
Select Rate OPRs On-time 70%
75% 65% 66%
59%
56% 53% 56%
53%
Percent
44%
50% 33%
29% 30% 31%
29% 33% 15%
25% 21% 30% 5% 13%
11% 7% 12% 23% 11%
11%
1%
0%
FY03 FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 CY09 CY10
Fiscal Year
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve – Unit Line
Missing Unit Line Top OPRs & Effect on Select Rates
% Missing UNIT Top OPRs
100% Select Rate Top OPR Missing
Select Rate Top OPR on-time 78%
74%
75% 68% 67%
59% 61% 77%
75% 75%
Percent
43% 44% 50%
50%
31% 57% 33% 33%
20%
18%
25% 16%
5% 9% 9%
3% 3% 2% 6% 3%
0%
FY03 FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 CY09 CY10
Board Year
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve – CAT E
Missing PIRR Top OPRs and Effect on Select Rates
% Missing PIRR Top OPRs 2 of 3
100%
Select Rate Top OPR Missing
Select Rate Top OPR On-time
75% 67%
60% 62%
Percent
45% 71%
36% 43%
50% 40%
35%
27% 50% 48%
25% 27% 40%
33%
25% 17%
12% 15% 10%
22% 7% 7%
16% 2%
0%
0% 0%
FY03 FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 CY09 CY10
Board Year
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve
What about Pilots?
93% Overall Line
100%
83% Pilots - 87
80% 76%
63%
60%
40%
40%
20% 15%
8%
3%
0%
Select Rate BDE Rate MSM+ Rate Masters+
Rate
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve Health - BDE
Select Rate BDE Completion Rate
100%
79% 75% 80%
80% 71%
63%
60% 55%
38%
40% 33%
20%
10%
4%
0%
Nurse Medical BSC MSC Dental
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve Health - BDE
Select Rate Select Rate BDE Completed Select Rate BDE not Complete
100% 100% 100%
100% 97%
89%
79% 80% 78%
80% 71% 70%
63%
60% 55% 50%
34% 40%
40%
20%
0%
Nurse Medical BSC MSC Dental
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Participating Reserve Health Professions
Reserve Categories
IMA UNIT
Select Select
CompCat Considered Selected Rate
Considered Selected
Rate
NURSE 6 3 50% 102 57 56%
MEDICAL 3 1 33% 21 16 76%
BSC 3 1 33% 11 9 82%
MSC 2 2 100% 22 17 77%
DENTAL 0 - - 10 8 80%
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Nurse Corps - Notes
Select rate – 55%
• Flight Nurse, 46FX, select rate – 50%
• BDE completion rate – 50%
• IPZ select rate – 53%
• APZ select rate – 58%
• Select rate with Master’s degree – 74%
• Select rate with Bachelor’s as highest degree – 49%
• Select rate with BDE completed – 97%
• Select rate with BDE not completed – 34%
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Medical Corps - Notes
Select rate – 71%
• Only rated flight surgeon who met the board was selected
• Of 20 with a current OPR, 17 were selected, 85% select rate
• Select rate with AFAM or better – 100%
• Select rate with BDE completed – 100%
• 9 year trend -100% select rate with BDE completed
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Biomedical Sciences Corps - Notes
Select rate – 63%
• All 6 who completed BDE were selected
• Selects represent 5 BSC specialties
• All 6 42E’s selected – Optometrists
• PhD was selected
• Select rate with Master’s degree 75%
• Bachelors degree – 0%
• Professional degree – 100%
• Three records with no degree listed, 2 selected
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
MSC & Dental Corps – Notes
MSC – Select rate – 79%
• Select rate with BDE completed – 89%
• BDE completion rate – 75%
• Select Rate with Master’s 88%
• Bachelor’s as highest degree – select rate 80%
Dental Corps – Select Rate – 80%
• Only 1 completed BDE and was selected, 9 year trend
• All 6 with AFCM’s were selected
•All selects were General Dentists – 47G
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors
Position Vacancy Board
Results by Competitive Category
FY09 CY09 CY10
Comp Considered Selected
Select
Considered Selected
Select
Considered Selected
Select
Rate Rate Rate
Cat
Line 187 64 34% 114 84 74% 184 62 34%
Nurse 14 13 93% 11 11 100% 14 10 71%
Medical 1 1 100% 1 0 0% 1 1 100%
BSC 8 4 50% 5 5 100% 4 3 75%
MSC 26 4 22% 6 5 85% 8 5 63%
Dental 0 - - 0 - - 1 0 0%
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board PV
Top OPR Older than 15 Months
100% 100%
CY10 % OPR CloseOut >15 mths for Selects
75% CY10 % OPR CloseOut >15 mths for Non-Selects
50%
25%
25%
11%
3% 0% 0%
0% 0% 0% 0%
0%
Line Nurse MSC BSC Medical Dental
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
PV Line Results
Results by Reserve Categories
FY09 CY09 CY10
Select Select Select
ARFID Considered Selected
Rate
Considered Selected
Rate
Considered Selected
Rate
Traditional 91 25 27% 64 46 72% 81 22 27%
ART 26 8 31% 18 11 61% 29 13 45%
UNIT 117 33 28% 82 57 70% 110 35 32%
IMA 59 22 37% 28 23 82% 61 17 28%
AGR 11 9 82% 4 4 100% 13 10 77%
Overall 187 64 34% 114 84 74% 184 62 34%
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
PV Line – Rack & Stack
80% 74% #1 Ranking Category
Excludes 1 of 1’s
60%
Select Rate
40% 34% 33%
25%
20% 14%
7%
0% 0%
0%
Overall 1 2 3 4 5 6 to 8 1 of 1
Rank Category
#1 Ranking Category Excludes 1 of 1’s
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Position Vacancy Line Board - Notes
Select rate – 34%
• Select rate with Master’s degree completed – 39%
• Select rate with Bachelor’s only – 28%
• Select rate with MSM – 49%
• With MSM dated within one year of board – 77%
• 8 Nominated without BDE completed – none selected
One Air Force, Same Fight – An Unrivaled Wingman.
CY10 AF Reserve Majors Board
Information on Promotions:
Point your Browser to: http://www.arpc.afrc.af.mil
Click on Promotions
Information on this Briefing:
e-mail: david.sutherland@arpc.denver.af.mil
DSN: 926 – 6864
Commercial: 303 – 676 – 6864
Grab Some Air