Docstoc

Rubric

Document Sample
Rubric Powered By Docstoc
					Rubric

Criterion          Excellent (4)             Proficient (3)            Poor(2)                   Unacceptable (1)
Prearranged        Bridge is built on        Bridge is built on        Bridge is built on        Bridge is built on
Location           prearranged location      prearranged location.     prearranged location.     material other than
                   and only touches the      Has 1-2 locations         Has 3 -4 locations        what was supplied. No
                   cardboard within the      where the bridge          where the bridge          square specifications
                   squares drawn             touches areas outside     touches areas outside     are drawn.
                                             of the pre-drawn          of the pre-drawn
                                             squares drawn             squares
Height             Bridge is built           Bridge is not built       Bridge is not built       Bridge is built
Surrounding        straight across. The      straight across.          straight across.          straight across but is
Location           extent of the bridge      There are 1-2 areas       There are 3-4 areas       not built at least 10
                   is a minimum of 10        that are not at least     where the bridge is       centimeters above
                   centimeters higher        10 centimeters            not at least 10           the surrounding land
                   than the surrounding      above the                 centimeters above         or is uneven and has
                   land                      surrounding land          the surrounding land      more than 4
                                                                                                 locations where the
                                                                                                 10 centimeter
                                                                                                 specification is not
                                                                                                 met.
Bridge Width       The bridge is at least    The bridge is at least    The bridge is at least    The bridge is not at
                   8 centimeters wide        8 centimeters across      8 centimeters across      least 8 centimeters
                   along the roadbed         the roadbed in all        the roadbed in all        across the roadbed in
                                             locations but 1           locations but 2-3         4 or more locations
Force Exerted      The force that the        The force that the        The force that the        The force that the
                   mass exerts on the        mass exerts on the        mass exerts on the        mass exerts on the
                   bridge is calculated      bridge is calculated      bridge is calculated      bridge is calculated
                   correctly. All            correctly. All            correctly. 1-2            incorrectly. 3 or
                   mathematical steps        mathematical steps        mathematical steps        more mathematical
                   are shown, a picture      are shown and a           are not shown and         steps are not shown
                   is drawn to indicate      picture is drawn to       the initial equation is   and the initial
                   forces, and the initial   indicate forces. The      not written down. A       equation is not
                   equation is written.      initial equation is not   picture is drawn to       written down. A
                                             written down.             indicate the initial      picture is drawn to
                                                                       forces.                   indicate the initial
                                                                                                 forces.
Bridge Capacity    The bridge                The bridge supports       The bridge supports       The bridge supports
                   adequately supports       1.50-1.99 times the       a mass 1.00-1.49          less than one times
                   a minimum of two          mass of the of bridge     times the mass of the     the mass of the
                   times the mass of the                               bridge                    bridge
                   of the bridge
Welding Material   Glue is used              Glue is used heavily      Glue is used              Glue is used in more
                   sparingly and only to     but only to join the      sparingly but is used     than one area other
                   join the members          members                   in one area beside        than the members.
                                                                       the members
Project Cost       Project cost analysis     Project cost analysis     Project cost analysis     Project cost analysis
Analysis           was correctly filled      was correctly filled      was correctly filled      was incorrectly filled
                   out (only materials       out (only materials       out (only materials       in (included more
                   used were written).       used were written).       used were written).       materials than were
                   The correct               The correct               The correct               used). The correct
                   percentage was            percentage was            percentage was            percentage was
                   calculated and all        calculated but no         calculated but not        calculated but the
                   calculations were         calculations were         calculations were         calculation steps
                   shown. A minimum          shown. Two ways           shown. One way to         were not shown. No
                   of three ways to          to reduce the cost of     reduce the cost of        methods of reducing
                     reduce the cost of       the bridge was           the bridge was           the cost of the bridge
                     the bridge was           mentioned                mentioned.               were mentioned.
                     mentioned.
Project Structural   The correct mass of      The correct mass of      The correct mass of      The incorrect mass
Analysis             the bridge as well as    the bridge as well as    the bridge as well as    of the bridge was
                     the correct structural   the correct structural   the correct structural   recorded. The
                     efficiency was           efficiency was           efficiency is            correct structural
                     calculated and all       calculated and all of    calculated but no        efficiency was
                     calculations were        the calculations were    calculations are         recorded but no
                     shown. A minimum         shown. Two               shown. Two               calculation steps
                     of three                 characteristics of the   characteristics of the   were provided. One
                     characteristics of the   bridge’s strength are    bridge’s strength are    characteristics of the
                     bridge’s strength are    addressed. One           addressed. One           bridge’s strength is
                     addressed. A             possible                 possible                 addressed. One
                     minimum of two           improvement is           improvement is           possible
                     possible                 mentioned and a          mentioned. A             improvement is
                     improvements were        description of why       description of why       mentioned. A
                     addressed and a          the areas the bridge     the particular areas     description of why
                     description of why       failed during testing    the bridge failed        particular areas
                     the areas the bridge     is recorded.             during testing is        failed during testing
                     failed during testing                             recorded.                was not recorded.
                     is recorded.
Financial Records    Financial records        Financial records        Financial records        Financial records
                     were neat, accurate,     were neat, stayed        were neat but            were messy and
                     and stayed within        within the specified     exceeded the budget      uneasy to follow.
                     the specified budget.    budget, and had          up to $10,000.00.        The financial records
                     Balance sheets were      minimal errors           Two checks were          exceeded the budget
                     up to date. All          recorded. With the       not recorded             by over $10,000.00.
                     check numbers, the       exception of one         properly in the          More than two
                     amount per check,        check, all check         balance sheet: All       checks were not
                     and the items            numbers, the amount      check numbers, the       recorded properly
                     purchased for each       per check, and the       amount, as well as       (check number,
                     check were               items purchased for      the items purchased      dollar amount, the
                     recorded. All            each check were          for each check were      items purchased).
                     cancelled checks (if     recorded. All            not written down         All checks (if any)
                     any) were recorded       cancelled checks (if     correctly. All           were recorded for
                     for documentation        any) were recorded       cancelled checks (if     documentation
                     purposes).               for documentation        any) were recorded       purposes.
                                              purposes.                for documentation
                                                                       purposes.
Balance check-up     The correct balance      The correct balance      The correct balance      The correct balance
                     was recorded and         was recorded and         was recorded and         was not stated or
                     stated at all three      stated at two of the     stated for one of the    recorded for any of
                     balance check-ups.       three balance check-     three balance check-     the three balance
                     No audits were           ups. One $2,000.00       ups. Two audits,         check-ups. Three
                     required.                audit was required.      costing a total of       audits, costing a total
                                                                       $4,000.00 was            of $6,000.00 was
                                                                       required.                required.
Fines                No fines were            One fine was             A total of two fines     Three or more fine
                     received. All checks     received: one for        were received for        were received. An
                     were written for the     writing a bad check      either writing bad       insufficient fund fine
                     appropriate amount,      or one for not           checks or for not        was received was
                     balance sheets were      keeping accurate and     keeping accurate and     one of the minimum
                     kept accurate and up     up to date balance       up to date balance       three fines received.
                     to date, and no          sheets. No               sheets. No               The other two or
                     insufficient fund        insufficient fund        insufficient fund        more could be any
               notices were             notices were            notices were            mixture of bad
               incurred.                incurred.               incurred.               checks or not
                                                                                        keeping balance
                                                                                        sheets accurate and
                                                                                        up to date.
Blueprints     Blueprints are neat      Blueprints are neat     Blueprints are not      Blueprints are not
               and legible. All         and legible. Most of    drawn using a ruler     drawn using a ruler
               lines are in pencil      the lines are drawn     or pencil. There are    or pencil. One or
               with a ruler.            using a pencil. All     blueprint drawings      more of the blueprint
               Blueprints are drawn     lines were drawn        for the end view and    views were not
               for the end view and     using a ruler.          side view. The scale    submitted. The scale
               side view. The           Blueprints are drawn    is off 3-4              is more than 4
               bridge matches the       for the end view and    centimeters from the    centimeters off of
               scale shown on the       side view. The          scale shown on the      the scale shown on
               blueprints.              bridge is off 1-2       blueprints.             the blueprints.
                                        centimeters from the
                                        scale shown on the
                                        blueprints
Load Test      Computerized load        Computerized load       Computerized load       Computerized load
               test was completed       test was completed      test was completed      test was completed
               and a certificate was    and a certificate was   and certificate was     and certificate was
               received on the first    received on the         received on the third   received on the forth
               attempt. The bridge      second attempt. The     attempt. The bridge     or greater attempt.
               was not required to      bridge required         required 3-4            The bridge required
               be altered.              minimal alterations.    alterations.            that more than four
                                                                                        adjustments be
                                                                                        made.

PowerPoint     PowerPoint               PowerPoint              PowerPoint              PowerPoint
Presentation   presentation was         presentation was        presentation was        presentation was not
               thorough and             somewhat                somewhat lacking.       well prepared.
               descriptive. It          descriptive and         The initial budge       Neither the initial
               provided the             thorough. It            was provided, but       nor the final budgets
               proposed initial         provided the initial    the final budget was    were provided. The
               budget and final         budget but not the      not. The maximum        maximum force able
               budget, the              final budget. The       force able to be        to be exerted on the
               maximum force that       maximum force that      exerted on the bridge   bridge was shown
               could be exerted on      could be exerted on     was shown but           but calculations were
               the bridge was           the bridge was          calculations were       not provided. One
               calculated out, a        calculated out,         not present. Photos     of the photos of the
               photo of the             photos of the           of the blueprints       blueprint was
               blueprints, as well as   blueprints, and         were provided, but      provided and more
               an explanation of        provides an             2-3 of the local        than three of the
               how the bridge           explanation of how      building codes were     local building codes
               meets all the local      the bridge meets all    not addressed in the    were not addressed
               building code.           but one of the local    explanation of the      in the explanation of
                                        building codes.         bridge.                 the bridge.

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:19
posted:12/5/2011
language:English
pages:3