This document contains a compilation of the comments submitted to

Document Sample
This document contains a compilation of the comments submitted to Powered By Docstoc
					                                              NAESB Smart Grid Standards Task Force
                                               Compilation of Comments/Modifications
                                                Priority Action Plan 9 (Retail) Phase 2

                This document contains a compilation of the comments submitted in response to recommendation REQ
                2010 AP Item 9 and WEQ 2010 AP Item 6; Master Data Requirements List for Standards associated with
                NIST PAP 03 and PAP 09. The comments were individually posted and are available for download from
                the NAESB website at http://www.naesb.org/retail_request.asp and http://www.naesb.org/weq_request.asp.

    COMPANY        CATEGORY         CITE               SUGGESTED CHANGE                                              TASK FORCE RESPONSE

1   Trane –        Editorial        Control: The       The term, "End Device" was removed from the Defined           2010-12-07
    Ingersoll                       role associated    Terms document. As such, we should remove the                 This correction was made
    Rand                            with the           capitalization in this definition for the term "Control"      to the redlined Defined
                                    control of an                                                                    Terms document presented
                                    End Device.                                                                      for Phase 2. It is not part of
                                                                                                                     the Master Data
                                                                                                                     Requirements List.

2   Trane –        Editorial        Measurement:       The term, "End Device" was removed from the Defined           2010-12-07
    Ingersoll                       The role           Terms document. As such, we should remove the                 This correction was made
    Rand                            associated         capitalization in this definition for the term                to the redlined Defined
                                    with the device    "Measurement"                                                 Terms document presented
                                    or algorithm                                                                     for Phase 2. It is not part of
                                    that measures                                                                    the Master Data
                                    the                                                                              Requirements List.
                                    consumption
                                    or supply of an
                                    End Device.

5   Southern       Redline          Throughout         REQ:                                                          2010-12-07
    Company        Modificatio      REQ and            http://www.naesb.org/pdf4/smart_grid_ssd111810w26.d           6.223 - Questions about
                   ns               WEQ                oc                                                            meter elements defined for
                                    Recommendati                                                                     wholesale: Deleted the
                                                       WEQ:
                                    on (verify with                                                                  question. These are
                                                       http://www.naesb.org/pdf4/smart_grid_ssd111810w30.d
                                    Leonard)                                                                         confirmed requirements for
                                                       oc
                                                                                                                     wholesale. Retail may or
                                                                                                                     may not need these
                                                                                                                     elements – as specified.
                                                                                                                     5.44 - Questions about
                                                                                                                     retail rate elements defined
                                                                                                                     for wholesale: Deleted the
                                                                                                                     question. These are
                                                                                                                     confirmed requirements for
                                                                                                                     wholesale. Retail may or
                                                                                                                     may not need these
                                                                                                                     elements – as specified.
                                                                                                                     7.33 – Not a NAESB
                                                                                                                     defined term. Deleted the
                                                                                                                     question. As with other
                                                                                                                     data elements in this list,
                                                                                                                     capitalization as a NAESB
                                                                                                                     defined term does not
                                                                                                                     apply for data elements.
                                                                                                                     All other edits accepted.

6   Cox            Technical        All documents      It is not clear (except in one footnote) that these           Added to Executive
    Software                        in the public      requirements documents are not specification                  Summary during NAESB


                                 Compilation of Comments/Modifications to be reviewed by the Smart Grid Standards Task Force   1
                                                                                                         November 15, 2010
                                         NAESB Smart Grid Standards Task Force
                                          Compilation of Comments/Modifications
                                           Priority Action Plan 9 (Retail) Phase 2

    COMPANY      CATEGORY      CITE               SUGGESTED CHANGE                                              TASK FORCE RESPONSE
    Architects                 review starting    documents, i.e., that the structures, schemas, data           meeting of 11/18/2010.
    LLC                        October 15,        element names and types, are requirements stated in
                               2010               very specific form. Add the following to the Executive
                                                  Summary and the Introduction of each document: "All           2010-12-07
                                                  data element names, and implied or stated structures are
                                                  not intended to specify specific message payloads or          Revised as follows:
                                                  information object. The intent is to clearly specify the       "All data element names,
                                                  business information that is required to be exchanged to      and implied or stated
                                                  make effective and reasonable business decisions, and         structures are not intended
                                                  NAESB understands that standards that do not directly         to specify specific message
                                                  use such schemas and element names may conform to             payloads or information
                                                  these requirements."                                          object. The intent is to
                                                                                                                clearly specify the business
                                                                                                                information that is required
                                                                                                                to be exchanged to make
                                                                                                                effective and reasonable
                                                                                                                business decisions, and
                                                                                                                NAESB understands that
                                                                                                                standards or
                                                                                                                implementations that do
                                                                                                                not directly use such
                                                                                                                schemas and element
                                                                                                                names may conform to
                                                                                                                these requirements
                                                                                                                through clearly defined
                                                                                                                mapping documentation."

7   California   General                          The ISOs/RTOs listed above support the formal                 California ISO, ERCOT,
    ISO,                                          comments submitted by the NAESB Standards Review              IESO, ISO New England,
    ERCOT,                                        Subcommittee                                                  Midwest ISO, New York
    IESO,                                                                                                       ISO, PJM, SPP
    ISO New
                                                                                                                2010-12-07
    England,
    Midwest                                                                                                     No action required.
    ISO, New
    York ISO,
    PJM, SPP

8   NAESB        General       General            The WEQ Standards Review Subcommittee has not                 2010-12-07
    WEQ                        Comments on        cross referenced the retail references to PAP-03 and
                                                                                                                The intent was to show
    Standards                  Data Elements      PAP-09 and question whether this cross reference is
                                                                                                                common data elements
    Review                     (no cites          required in the Wholesale Business Practice Standards.
                                                                                                                used by Retail and
    Subcomm                    given)
                                                                                                                Wholesale. Wholesale and
    ittee
                                                                                                                Retail subcommittee
                                                                                                                members have reviewed
                                                                                                                the Master Data Elements
                                                                                                                list and confirm the
                                                                                                                applicability as presented.

9   NAESB        General       General            Measurement Value Type is cross referenced to the             2010-12-07
    WEQ                        Comments on        Wholesale PAP-09 recommendation. The data element
                                                                                                                Error in transfer to Phase 2
    Standards                  Data Elements      is not included in the PAP-09 Data Requirements tables.
                                                                                                                recommendation.


                            Compilation of Comments/Modifications to be reviewed by the Smart Grid Standards Task Force   2
                                                                                                    November 15, 2010
                                           NAESB Smart Grid Standards Task Force
                                            Compilation of Comments/Modifications
                                             Priority Action Plan 9 (Retail) Phase 2

     COMPANY     CATEGORY      CITE               SUGGESTED CHANGE                                              TASK FORCE RESPONSE
     Review                    (no cites                                                                        Corrected.
     Subcomm                   given)
     ittee

10   NAESB       General       General            Suggest that the comment “*Listing by Category ID and         2010-12-07
     WEQ                       Comments on        Category Element ID begins on page 45” be changed to
                                                                                                                Added subsection WEQ-
     Standards                 Data Elements      “Listing by Category ID and Category Element ID can
                                                                                                                020.1.2 and changed
     Review                    (no cites          be found in Section WEQ-020.2” and adding a section
                                                                                                                reference below subsection
     Subcomm                   given)             number to “Listing by Category ID and Category
                                                                                                                020.1.1 header.
     ittee                                        Element ID”. This will make it easier to maintain since
                                                  the page number will change with each NAESB
                                                  publication.

11   NAESB       General       General            Source Location Identifier is cross referenced to the         2010-12-07
     WEQ                       Comments on        Wholesale PAP-03 recommendation but the data
                                                                                                                Source Location Identifier
     Standards                 Data Elements      element has been deleted in the PAP-03
                                                                                                                is still listed in the
     Review                    (no cites          recommendation.
                                                                                                                Wholesale PAP-03
     Subcomm                   given)
                                                                                                                recommendation – page 9
     ittee
                                                                                                                of the Phase 2 redline
                                                                                                                version.

12   NAESB       General       General            Source Location Identifier Type is cross referenced to        2010-12-07
     WEQ                       Comments on        the Wholesale PAP-03 recommendation but the data
                                                                                                                Duplicate comment
     Standards                 Data Elements      element has been deleted in the PAP-03
     Review                    (no cites          recommendation
     Subcomm                   given)
     ittee

13   NAESB       General       General            In the Listing by Category ID and Category Element ID         2010-12-07
     WEQ                       Comments on        sort, the Category Element ID sort appears as if the
                                                                                                                The expanded numbering
     Standards                 Data Elements      column is sorted as an alphabet sort rather than a
                                                                                                                within a section is
     Review                    (no cites          numeric sort? This results in data elements such as
                                                                                                                intentional. Data elements
     Subcomm                   given)             2291 through 2296 appearing before 23. Was this
                                                                                                                labeled as 2291 through
     ittee                                        intentional? If not and changes are made to the sorts in
                                                                                                                2296 belong to other data
                                                  this section, conforming changes will need to be made
                                                                                                                elements beginning with
                                                  to the PAP-09 Recommendation
                                                                                                                22. The numbering
                                                                                                                sequence is purely to
                                                                                                                facilitate reference of like
                                                                                                                data elements and is not
                                                                                                                intended to be used for
                                                                                                                sorting in numerical order.




                            Compilation of Comments/Modifications to be reviewed by the Smart Grid Standards Task Force   3
                                                                                                    November 15, 2010

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:2
posted:12/3/2011
language:English
pages:3