Slide 1 by yPsYn3x


									     International Federation of Accountants
   Delivering Services: Meeting Debt Obligations:
 Engaging Citizens and Businesses in the Long-Term
        Sustainability of the Public Finances
      John Stanford: Deputy Technical Director:
International Public Sector Accounting Standards Board

                     CIPFA in Europe
                     October 8th, 2009
                       (optional header) Standard Setting

• IPSASB project on social benefits (1)
     • Analysis of when present obligations & liabilities arise for social
       benefits distinguishing:
              • Collective goods and services (such as defense, policing)
              • Individual goods and services (such as education and
              • Cash transfers (such as entitlements for state pensions,
                unemployment benefit)

     • Analysis based on IPSAS 19, “Provisions, Contingent Liabilities
       and Contingent Assets” (equivalent of IAS 37)
     • Initial tentative view that present obligations and liabilities arise
       only for cash transfers on “due and payable” basis
•IPSASB project on social benefits (2)
     •Alternative view that approach over-restrictive?
     •Distinction between cash transfers & individual goods and services
     •ED 34, “Disclosure of Cash Transfers to Individuals and
      Households”: a compromise that proposed disclosure of cash flows-
      not recognition and measurement of liabilities
     •ED 34 not supported at consultation
     •Conclusion that traditional general purposes financial statements will
      not provide all information for accountability purposes regardless of
      approach to present obligations and liabilities
•Conceptual Framework: First phase of
 this project considered:
   – Objectives
   – Scope
   – Reporting Entity
   – Qualitative Characteristics
• Preliminary Views that:
        • Prospective information necessary to meet users needs esp.
          accountability and decision-making
        • Scope of reporting should extend beyond financial statements
• Some reservations from respondents about broader scope
• Likelihood that pronouncements on broad scope issues will be in form
  of guidance
Composition of Task Force overseeing
• Chaired by CIPFA Policy & Technical Director (Ian Carruthers)
• Includes Members from:
   – Eurostat
   – French Cour des Comptes
   – Swiss Federal Ministry of Finance
   – Swedish Audit Office
   – Australian Department of Finance and Deregulation
   – Canadian Public Sector Accounting Board
   – New Zealand Treasury
   – US Federal Accounting Standards Advisory Board
   – OECD
   – IMF
Background to current emphasis on long-
term fiscal sustainability?
• Fiscal pressure points for governments
        • Demographics
        • Technological advances
        • Infrastructure
        • Environmental factors

• Inter-generational equity
• Extent of global financial crisis has added further pressures incl:
        • Guarantees
        • Purchase of, and/or insurance of, toxic assets
        • Quantitative easing
        • Credit lines
        • Direct interests in entities
What is long-term fiscal sustainability and
how extensively is it reported?
• No globally accepted definition so working definition:
         –“The ability of government to meet its service delivery
          and financial commitments both now and in the future.”

• Recognizes ability to modify level of services and taxation
  levels (but constrained in global environment)
• Fiscal-sustainability reporting an increasing feature of
  public reporting over last 10-15 years
• Predominantly domain of economists, statisticians and
  policy makers-accountants generally peripheral
  Overview of Fiscal Future Reports at
  National and Supra-national Levels (1)
   Country          Legal Requirement                               Title                                      Source          Start
Australia        Charter of Budget          Intergenerational Report                                Treasury                   2002
Denmark                                     A Sustainable Future                                    Min of Finance             1997

Germany                                     Report on Sustainability of Public Finance              Min of Finance             2005

Korea                                       Vision 2030                                             Ministry of Planning and   2006
Netherlands      EC Stability Program       Aging and the Sustainability of Dutch Public Finances   Central Planning Bureau    2000
New Zealand      Public Finance Act         Long Term Fiscal Position                               Treasury                   1993
Norway                                      2006 White Paper                                        Min. of Finance            2004

Sweden                                      Sweden’s Economy (annex to budget)                      Min. of Finance            1999

Switzerland                                 Long-term Sustainability of Public Finance in           Federal Dept. of Finance   2008
United           Code of Fiscal Stability   Long Term Public Finance Report                         Treasury                   1999

   Source: OECD Fiscal Futures Project
     Overview of Fiscal Future Reports at
     National and Supra-national Levels (2)
   Country          Legal Requirement                                  Title                                  Source              Start

USA:                                        Long Term Budget Outlook                              Congressional Budget Office     1991-
Congressional                                                                                                                     2000
Budget Office
USA: General                                Long Term Fiscal Outlook                              General Accountability Office   1992-
Accountability                                                                                                                    97
Office (GAO)
USA: Office of                              Long Term Budget Outlook in Analytical Perspectives   Office of Management and        1979-
Management                                                                                        Budget                          97
and Budget
USA: Financial                              Statement of Social Insurance                         Department of Treasury          2004
Report of US
European Union   Stability & Convergence    Public Finances – EMU                                 Economic Policy Comm.           2005
Countries        Programming Surveillance
International                               Financial Transparency Reviews                        Fiscal Affairs Department       2001
Monetary Fund

     Source: OECD Fiscal Futures Project
  Information Needs of Users
              Information useful as Input to Assessments of Accountability and
                        for Resource Allocation and other Decisions

                           All Financial Reporting                                     Other
  General Purpose Financial Reports (includes        Special Purpose (and
   annual financial reports and other reports)       other) Financial Reports
                                                     outside scope of IPSASB

General Purpose         Additional Information –     For example, donor and        Economic,
Financial Statements    may include non-             other special purpose and     statistical,
(includes notes to      financial, prospective       compliance reports, and       demographic
financial statements)   financial, compliance        finance statistics and        and other
                        and additional               other financial reports and   data
                        explanatory material         forecasts outside GPFRs
Information not reported in an accruals
based statement of financial position
                  Past cash flows            Future cash flows
                                          Present economic benefits

                                            realized in the future
                Assets obtained and                (Assets)
                  realized to date
                                           Expected resources to be
                                            realized in the future

                                          Expected obligations to be

                                            settled in the future
               Liabilities incurred and
                   settled to date        Present economic sacrifices
                                               settled in future
How information on fiscal sustainability can
enhance information in statement of financial
                  Past cash flows            Future cash flows
                                          Present economic benefits

                                            realized in the future
                Assets obtained and                (Assets)
                  realized to date
                                           Expected resources to be
                                            realized in the future

                                          Expected obligations to be

                                            settled in the future
               Liabilities incurred and
                   settled to date        Present economic sacrifices
                                               settled in future
Models for reporting long-term fiscal
sustainability reporting in GPFRs
• Model One: Additional statements providing details of projections:
             • US Statement of Social Insurance
             • SFFAS 36, “Reporting Comprehensive Long-Term Fiscal
               Projections for the U.S. Government”.

• Model Two: Summarizing projections in narrative reporting
             •US Citizens Guide

• Model Three: Cross-references in GPFRs to other reports addressing
  long-term fiscal sustainability
• IPSASB Preliminary View that Models 1 & 2 appropriate
Long-term fiscal projections for the US
Federal Government
Reporting boundary

• Boundary for long-term fiscal sustainability reporting
  unlikely to be same as for financial statements:
   – Statistically based on statistical accounting- esp. Europe (SNA
     95) and GFSM 2001
   – Budget based

• Consolidated reports or individual entities?
• Relevance at sub-national levels but different focus and
   – Ability to generate revenue
   – Fiscal dependence on other tiers of government
Reporting indicators
• Gross debt: The sum of government securities (on consolidated basis), loans received
  and other borrowing, deposits held and advances received.
• Net debt: Gross debt minus the sum of investments, loans made, cash and deposits,
  and advances paid.
• Net Worth: Total assets (financial and non-financial) minus total liabilities (debt,
  superannuation and other) minus contributed capital.
• Net Financial Worth: Total financial assets minus total liabilities minus shares and
  other contributed capital.
• Fiscal gap: The size of the immediate and permanent increase in revenues or
  decrease in outlays, expressed as a percent of GDP, that would be necessary to keep
  debt at or below its current share of GDP for a future projection period.
• Inter-temporal budget gap: Derived from the inter-temporal budget constraint (IBC).
  The IBC calculates the primary balance (surplus or deficit exclusive of interest
  payment) required to stabilize (eliminate, in some versions) the debt burden. This is
  done by discounting to present value all projected future revenue and spending flows
  plus the current debt burden. An inter-temporal budget gap exists when the present
  discounted value of projected primary balances does not cover the current debt burden.
• Fiscal dependency: Extent to which an entity is dependent upon sources of funding
  outside its control.
Principles for selecting indicators: Allen
Schick’s Framework
• Solvency: the capacity of governments to finance existing
  and probable future liabilities/obligations;
• Growth: the capacity of government to sustain economic
  growth over an extended period;
• Fairness: the capacity of government to provide net
  financial benefits to future to future generations that are
  not less than the net benefits provided to current
  generations; and
• Stable taxes: the capacity of governments to finance
  future obligations without increasing the tax burden.
Basic principles

• Current versus future policy
• Revenue inflows
• Demographic and economic assumptions
• Approach to age-related and non age-related
• Impact of legal requirements and policy frameworks

Disclosure of approach
Specific methodology issues
• Time horizons for their projections and their rationale
• Discount rates
• Frequency of reporting
• Sensitivity of analysis
• Reliability of projections
   – Long-term fiscal sustainability reports not generally subject to
   – In USA the SOSI is subject to opinion from GAO
   – View in Consultation Paper is that assurance matter for preparers
     but that good practice to disclose approach to ensuring
     reasonableness of assumptions
Overview of Time Horizons in Long-Term
Fiscal Sustainability Reports
   Country                 Title                                                    Time Horizon

   Australia               Intergenerational Report                                       40
   Germany                 Rpt on Sustainability of Public Finance                        45
   Korea                   Vision 2030                                                    25
                                                                               Until 2100 (with separate
   Netherlands             Aging and Sustainability of Dutch Public Finances
                                                                                 discussion to 2040)
   New Zealand             LT Fiscal Position                                             40
   Norway                  2006 White Paper                                               55
   Sweden                  Sweden’s Economy (annex to budget)                             45
   United Kingdom          LT Public Finance Report                                       30
   USA: CBO                LT Budget Outlook                                              75
   USA: GAO                LT Fiscal Outlook                                              75
   US: OMB                 LT Budget Outlook in Analytical Perspectives                   75
   USA: Financial Report
                           Statement of Social Insurance                                  75
   of US Government
   European Union
                           Public Finances – EMU                                          55
                           Long-term sustainability of public finance in
   Switzerland                                                                            40
Next Steps
• Approval of Consultation Paper
• Publication of Consultation Paper: late 2009
• Consultation period around 5 months
• Analysis of responses
• Dependent upon response analysis possibility of a non-binding
  framework-principles rather than rules-based
• IASB approach to narrative reporting
• OECD Seminar in March 2010
• All IPSASB pronouncements and exposure drafts available at

To top