Copy of Lathe comparison by xiaoyounan

VIEWS: 36 PAGES: 4

									                                                                                                  Powermatic
General Specifications          Magma Titan 315       Magma Titan 400      Oneway 2436            3520B           Robust American Beauty      Wivamac DB 1200         Vicmarc VL300EVS long
Swing over Bed                  25"                   30.7"                24"                    20"             25"                         20.47"                  23.64"
Swing outboard                  90"                   90"                  48"                    38"             5'                          80"
Distance Between Centers        31.5"                 31.5"                36"                    34.5"           28"                         47.25"                  50"
Work height                     Adjustable option     Adjustable           43, 44, 46, 48"        44"             41 - 50"                    Adjustable              42-54"
Forward Reverse                 yes                   yes                  yes                    yes             yes
Speed Ranges                    0 - 3,000             0 - 3,000            70-3000                50-3200         50-2,800                    90-3000                 10-3000 rpm
speed pulleys                   2 @ 1:1, 1:3          2 @ 1:1, 1:3         3                      2               3                           5                       3 @ 1:1, 1:1.5, 1:3
Net Weight                      705                   838                  850                    630             628                         430                     875
Dimensions L x W x H                                                       60 x                   55 x 27 x 58    62 x 30 x 58                84.65 x 31.1 x 49.61"   78.4 x 31.1 x 58.3
Warranty                                                                   5 years                5 years         7 yrs. Bearings

Bed
Material                        High Alloyed Steel    High alloyed steel   cast iron              Cast Iron       welded steel                precision steel         Cast iron
Ways                            High Alloyed Steel    High alloyed steel   stainless $820         Cast Iron       304L Stainless              precision steel         Cast iron-machined

Headstock
Spindle                         #2 MT                 #2 MT                #2 MT                  #2 MT           #2 Mt                       #2 MT                   #2 MT
Spindle Bearings                                                           4 of them                              6300 Ball bearings                                  Taper Roller
Indexing                        48                    48                   48 optional 96 @ $35   24-36-48?       48                          24                      24
Thread inboard                  1 1/4 x 8 hardenned   1 1/4 x 8 hardened   M33x3.5 right          1 1/4 x 8       1 1/4 x 8 hardened          M33 x 3.5               1 1/4" x 8
Thread outboard                 N/A                   N/A                  M33x3.5 right          N/A             N/A                         N/A
Positioning                     Sliding and swivel    Sliding and swivel   Fixed                  Sliding         Sliding                     Slide and Swivel        Fixed
Vacuum chucking                 Yes 1/2" tread        Yes 1/2" tread       yes, adaptor $110      yes             Yes, adaptor is $89         yes

Tailstock
Quill hole                      #3 MT                 #3 MT                #3 MT                  #2 MT           #2 MT                       #2 MT                   #2 MT
Quill travel                    6"                    7.9 "                4"                     4.5"            4"                          4.33"                   3"
Self ejecting or Knockout bar                                              self ejecting          self ejecting   self ejecting                                       Knockout bar
ruler                           Laser etched          Laser etched                                Laser etched    milled slot w/t ruler $45

Motor
power                           220v 1 phase          220v 1 phase         220V 1 phase           220v 1 phase    220v 1 phase                220v 1 phase            220 single phase
horse power                     2 or 3 hp             3 hp                 1.5, 2, &3             2 or 3 hp       2 0r 3 hp                   2 or 3 hp               2 kw or 3 hp
location                        in head stock         in head stock        Below the bed          in head stock   in head stock               in head stock           Below the bed

Tool Rest
Post Diameter                   30 mm                 40 mm                1"                                     1"                                                  30 mm

Safety
Emergency shut off              on remote             on remote            yes                    yes             on remote                   on remote               knee stop bar
Magnetic remote switch          yes                   yes                  Accessory $88          accessory       yes                         yes                     yes
                                                                           No but 20 second
Power Lockout when indexing     yes                   yes                  motor shut off.        yes             yes

Cost
Lathe                              $7,700 or $8,250-3hp 3 hp $8,900       $5,890               $3,800              $5,995 or $6325 - 3hp     $4895 or $53,00 - 3hp $4,999
                                                                          $1517 includes bed                       Quick Release $295, out
Outboard turning                   $88.40               $88.40            and banjo            $400                board attachment $525                          $489
Face Plate                         no                   no                6" included          3" included         Included                  no                   5.91" Included
Live center                        no                   no                included             Included            Included                  included             Included
Tool rest                          12" included         12" included      14" included         14" included        12" included                                   12" Included
Knockout bar                       included             included                                                   Included
                                                                                               brass tipped included                         included             2 (headstock & tailstock)
Drive Center                       no                   no                4 prong inlcuded     Included            Included                  included             Included
Estimated shipping to Winchester   $1,400               $1,400            $500                                     $400                      250

                                                                                               Powermatic
Lathe                              Magma Titan 315      Magma Titan 400   Oneway 2436          3520B              Robust American Beauty Wivamac DB 1200          Vicmarc VL300EVS long
Serious SL2542
25"
44"
42"
42"
yes
25-900 and 100-3,650
2 @ 1:1, 1:4
1580
70 x 29 x 47




Cast iron
Cast iron


#3 MT
4 of them
48 digital display
1 1/2 x 8
1 1/2" x 8
Fixed




#3 MT
6"
Knockout bar




220v 1 phase 20 amp
3 hp
Below the bed


1 1/4"
SS reducing collet to 1" for $75

On remote
yes

yes
$6,975

$1,200
8" Included
Included
16" Included
1 Included
Included
$1,400


Serious SL2542

								
To top