Creating a Consistent Process for Setting and Reviewing
Goals, Objectives and Plans
Preamble
A metaphor for the planning process involves linguistics (vocabulary agreement), syntax
(the order in which things are done), and the cultural context of the organization. People
often assume that those who read something will have the same context as the author.
However, most of us realize we should not assume that to be true.
Main Causes of Failure in Planning
1. Staff not involved in planning
2. Objectives and vision are unclear
3. Process takes too long (things change before they can be implemented)
4. Lack the necessary information to make decisions
5. Lose sight of the real objective and get off track
6. Lack understanding of planning terms and meanings
7. Strategic planning process is confusing (lots of time spent but no results)
8. Planning jumps around (process gets out of sequence)
9. Process generally does not take a long term view
10. Often the right people are not involved
11. Lack processes or an interim plan during chaotic periods of change
12. Waiting for direction and decisions from senior management
13. Preconceived notions about how to “fix” issues (but not sustainable)
14. Lack commitment from top management
15. Lack commitment to establish a planning team
16. Lack knowledge about how the planning process works
17. Results are not measurable (a lot of process is measured instead)
18. Lack resources to plan and/or implement (or too many resources)
19. Lack balance throughout the steps in the process
Increasing visibility, better organization of infrastructure, decentralizing responsibilities,
and establishing a long term time frame can begin to address these issues.
Ecology of an Organization
1. Environmental Scanning / Forecasting
How are things going to look 5 years from now?
Forecast in areas you don’t have control, plan in the areas where you do
Cannot control the world, but you can control your response to it.
Firmly establish in people’s minds the mission, vision and values, and
from there develop the roles, responsibilities and reporting systems.
Focus on doing a better job with the planning process and be concerned
with the futurity of your decisions. Identify the longer term decisions that
would help your short term decision requirements because they relate.
Page 1 of 6
2. Mission and Vision
Mission defines the area in which goals must be set in terms of the results
In a results-oriented mission, emphasis is placed on defining the areas in
which it is critical to have acceptable results, not the processes or goals.
It might include a description of enabling conditions or other critical areas.
Conditions are things that have a downstream effect on the main focus.
Eg. the negative effects of urban lifestyles on the environment; the extent
of the damage; successes of alternative habits and practices.
Enabling conditions might involve an appeal to public morale and innate
consciousness; health and safety issues, condition of the environment,
public satisfaction, and financial conditions.
Vision creates an image of what it will be like in 5 years. A clear idea of
the mission is necessary, as the two complement each other.
3. Values
Guiding ethos of an organization; how people behave with one another;
management principles that guide specific actions that you live by. If they
are not adhered to, staff will become cynical.
Eg. trust, respect, honesty, openness, integrity and accountability
(fighting suggests differing values)
4. Policy Formulation
It is not procedures, regulations, guidelines or directions from above.
Policy is about process aimed at achieving goals(s), but is often unstated.
Eg. Privatization is not a goal, but a way to reduce costs, so it is a policy.
An issue becomes large enough that it changes the way you do things.
5. Roles and Responsibilities
Roles are not job descriptions.
Responsibilities typically list the areas that a person is responsible for,
written in results style.
Job descriptions help create a standard, and should simply state the
areas in which the individual needs to focus.
Roles and responsibilities for line staff often consist of the goals from the
Mission Statement being passed down to the wrong level.
Managers need to determine areas of responsibility to ensure staff have
adequate information to perform their jobs and know their responsibilities
Need to know the overall critical results that the organization wants to
achieve, and the critical results that each individual needs to achieve.
6. Reporting System
Organization chart simply that tells you who reports to whom.
Avoid dotted lines if at all possible – they cause confusion in terms of
reporting priorities and responsibilities.
7. Goal, Standard and Objective Setting
Defines the quality and quantity of your results
Goals are large, broad statements that have to do with results
Page 2 of 6
The acronym SMART may be known to many of you. It is a tool that
captures the key components of goal setting. The letters stand for
Specific Measurable Attainable Realistic and Timely, and are a handy
reference guide to use in checking goal statements.
Once a Mission is established, you can create goals by adding one of
these words to each statement: reduce, increase, improve, or maintain.
The goals in effect become the programs, ie. decrease negative effects of
urban lifestyles on the environment; reduce health and safety issues,
improve environmental consciousness; and improve public satisfaction
Once goals have been identified, staff can identify ideas and ways in
which the goals can be accomplished.
Goals will change over time as the organization’s actions are successful
in achieving current ones, and new goals are identified.
Monitor the plan and watch for policy changes - if your policy responses
change, adjustments have to be reflected in the Mission and Goals.
If you want to improve quality, it has to be defined, which may need public
input. To assess it, it has to be measured, and standards are needed
against which to assess it.
Managers can only manage or eliminate variances (sporadic departures
from the standard). The approach is to create a variance between the old
and the new, using numbers because they are more accurate than using
adjectives. It provides managers with direction on what to do.
The number of sales call made per day is a measure of process, whereas
the number of sales made per day measures results.
To be useful in measuring and monitoring results, objectives should have
numeric targets, eg. dollar value of sales, number of new members to
attract, calendar dates for completing tasks, etc.
8. Strategy Development
Strategies represent directions you’re going to take to reach your goals
Plans are the details that need to be done to reach next year’s goals.
9. Resource Allocation and Budgeting
Identifies the time and costs estimated to achieve the desired results.
10. Information Systems
Formal (15%) and informal (85%) ways of communicating information.
Monitoring systems target on client-focused results, and the key ones
need to provide repetitive critical feedback to those in charge.
11. Financial Management and Accounting Reporting Systems
Two critical areas that need to be monitored for management information
12. Evaluation Systems
Formative evaluation conducted in advance of the event is primarily
aimed at improving future performance.
Summative evaluation occurs after the event.
13. Trained and Qualified Personnel
Page 3 of 6
Building Blocks for Effective Planning
Often there is a failure to differentiate between results and process.
Attention is best focused on results, balance, measures, staff and
stakeholder involvement, and organizational context.
In a goal-oriented organization, what you do today is determined by what
you want to achieve in the future, not by what you achieved yesterday.
If you want to own the result, but set staff’s objectives in terms of process,
then all they can do is perform a task.
Start with the issues identified through surveys of staff and stakeholders.
Bring together the right people, including those that carry out strategy
Adapt planning cycles to the needs of each business
Implement a strategic performance management system. Put in place a
strategic system to measure and monitor progress in order to track the
execution of strategic initiatives. It’s not limited to financial tracking, but
includes other metrics such as the number of projects in various stages of
development, the number of skilled persons involved on a project, etc
Transparency is achieved through regular reviews.
The Planning Cycle
Planning is best done through a series of steps tied to an organization’s fiscal year:
Strategic review and analysis, including clarification and confirmation of
mission, vision and values
Development of a business plan
Development of an operational plan
Mid-year or quarterly review and evaluation
Year-end review and evaluation.
These steps, along with specific timeframes, form the basis of the Planning Cycle. To ensure
success, an effective planning cycle will include:
Pre-determined planning cycles and reviews as part of the process
Planning as an ongoing process rather than a one-time project
Monitoring and review as a key component of the planning cycle.
Page 4 of 6
The Sustainability Model - Definitions of Key Concepts
Sustainability Implementation of effective governance, operational,
financial, and knowledge management practices to achieve
short-term and long-term viability of an organization.
Sustainability is also defined by ongoing planning and review
to ensure best practices.
Vision Broad statement of the future an organization seeks
Mission Concise statement identifying an organization’s purpose,
activities and key stakeholders.
Values Fundamental beliefs underlying an organization’s mission
and vision that provide the context for day-to-day operations.
Governance Processes and structures that direct and manage an
organization’s operations and activities. Governance
establishes mechanisms to achieve accountability and fiscal
responsibility among stakeholders, the Board of Directors
and management.
Strategic Plan 3-5 year plan designed to lead, manage and change an
organization in a well-integrated fashion based on core
strategies. The strategic plan should drive and inform the
business plan.
Business Plan 1-3 year plan that serves as the principal operating tool for
an organization and outlines strategies for operational and
financial sustainability. The business plan should drive and
inform the operational plan. An effective business plan will
include plans and strategies for:
Governance
Marketing and communications
Human resources
Resource/fund development
Financial management
Administrative procedures, and
Technology supports.
Operational Plan A 1-year plan that provides details of annual operations
linked to the budget.
1070, 1202 Centre Street S.E., Calgary, AB T2G 5A5 (403) 517-8600
info@thecentrepoint.ca www.thecentrepoint.ca
Page 5 of 6
Evaluation of the Planning Process Checklist
Outstanding Issues and Conflicts
Are there any outstanding issues or challenges facing the organization that the
plan has not addressed? How critical are these?
What are the consequences of not responding to these issues in the near future?
Leadership is Engaged
Are formal and informal leaders involved in and supportive of the plan?
What have they done to show their support?
Realistic and Credible
Is the plan realistic and practical? Is there a balance between the dream and
reality?
Does the organization have access to the resources (time, talent and money) to
accomplish the plan?
Implementation
Has implementation been addressed?
Are individuals who will implement the plan involved and engaged?
Stakeholder Communication
Have stakeholders bought in to the plan?
Is there a communications plan to distribute information, share the plan and to
acknowledge successful implementation?
Management Reporting
Has a method been established to inform management of progress (monthly
meetings, reports, etc.)?
Ongoing Review
Is there a plan to update the plan as external and internal environments change?
Legal and Ethical
Are there any outstanding legal or ethical considerations?
Is there any aspect of the plan that may threaten or harm participants?
Process
What worked well during the business planning process?
What would we do differently next time?
What pitfalls would we identify for next year’s planners?
How should we celebrate our success?
Page 6 of 6