COST SCORING FOR RFP #262142
Proposer Cost Score (max. 300 pts.)
AMCAD $42.00 107.14
LAYTON $24.90 180.72
SHEL/DON $38.50 116.88
LORIEN $40.00 112.50
NBS $45.00 100.00
ANACOMP $37.90 118.73
RIVER CITY $15.00 300.00
TELA TECHNOLOGIES $35.00 128.57
EVALUATION SCORING FOR RFP #262142
AMCAD Evaluator
Description (Max. Pts.) #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 AVERAGE
Organization Capabilities(50) 45 32 38 50 43 45 42.17
Staff Qualifications(50) 44 47 48 50 43 40 45.33
Proposed Solutions (50) 41 47 35 50 45 20 39.67
Value-Added (50) 43 47 42 50 45 25 42.00
Image (500) 400 400 390 350 350 400 381.67
TOTAL 573 573 553 550 526 530 550.83
LAYTON Evaluator
Description (Max. Pts.) #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 AVERAGE
Organization Capabilities(50) 41 26 37 48 37 47 39.33
Staff Qualifications(50) 35 35 40 50 35 45 40.00
Proposed Solutions (50) 47 46 35 50 45 45 44.67
Value-Added (50) 47 42 0 50 40 40 36.50
Image (500) 500 500 450 450 400 450 458.33
TOTAL 670 649 562 648 557 627 618.83
SHEL/DON Evaluator
Description (Max. Pts.) #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 AVERAGE
Organization Capabilities(50) 10 0 9 0 0 5 4.00
Staff Qualifications(50) 10 12 5 3 20 11 10.17
Proposed Solutions (50) 0 11 0 0 0 10 3.50
Value-Added (50) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.00
Image (500) 250 350 150 150 200 300 233.33
TOTAL 270 373 164 153 220 326 251.00
LORIEN Evaluator
Description (Max. Pts.) #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 AVERAGE
Organization Capabilities(50) 35 38 26 45 34 45 37.17
Staff Qualifications(50) 30 38 25 43 29 40 34.17
Proposed Solutions (50) 38 45 27 41 30 42 37.17
Value-Added (50) 37 45 10 31 15 40 29.67
Image (500) 100 200 20 0 50 100 78.33
TOTAL 240 366 108 160 158 267 216.50
NBS Evaluator
Description (Max. Pts.) #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 AVERAGE
Organization Capabilities(50) 21 15 25 38 20 40 26.50
Staff Qualifications(50) 40 22 25 38 23 45 32.17
Proposed Solutions (50) 39 47 27 50 40 42 40.83
Value-Added (50) 40 47 40 50 40 41 43.00
Image (500) 0 100 20 0 0 100 36.67
TOTAL 140 231 137 176 123 268 179.17
ANACOMP Evaluator
Description (Max. Pts.) #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 AVERAGE
Organization Capabilities(50) 47 45 50 50 45 45 47.00
Staff Qualifications(50) 47 44 45 50 45 40 45.17
Proposed Solutions (50) 30 42 30 41 30 30 33.83
Value-Added (50) 41 48 40 50 45 40 44.00
Image (500) 350 380 350 250 250 350 321.67
TOTAL 515 559 515 441 415 505 491.67
RIVER CITY Evaluator
Description (Max. Pts.) #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 AVERAGE
Organization Capabilities(50) 15 0 0 0 0 10 4.17
Staff Qualifications(50) 5 10 9 0 0 0 4.00
Proposed Solutions (50) 0 12 0 0 0 0 2.00
Value-Added (50) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.00
Image (500) 450 450 400 400 400 500 433.33
TOTAL 470 472 409 400 400 510 443.50
TELA TECHNOLOGIES Evaluator
Description (Max. Pts.) #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 AVERAGE
Organization Capabilities(50) 31 12 29 46 34 45 32.83
Staff Qualifications(50) 40 32 40 47 32 42 38.83
Proposed Solutions (50) 20 27 10 32 30 30 24.83
Value-Added (50) 10 25 0 40 20 30 20.83
Image (500) 300 340 305 200 150 250 257.50
TOTAL 401 436 384 365 266 397 374.83
SCORING TOTAL FOR RFP #262142
PROPOSER COST POINTS EVALUATION POINTS TOTAL
LAYTON 180.72 618.83 799.55
RIVER CITY 300.00 443.50 743.50
AMCAD 107.14 550.83 657.97
ANACOMP 118.73 491.67 610.40
TELA TECHNOLOGIES 128.57 374.83 503.40
SHEL/DON 116.88 251.00 367.88
LORIEN 112.50 216.50 329.00
NBS 100.00 179.17 279.17
CSC GROUP NO IMAGE SAMPLES PROVIDED DISQUALIFIED
SOURCECORP UNABLE TO PRINT IMAGES DISQUALIFIED