CATEGORY 4 3 2 1
Stakeholders The positions of 4 The positions of 3 The positions of 2 The position of 1
different stakeholders stakeholders are stakeholders are stakeholder is
are presented. presented. Positions presented. Positions presented. The
Positions are are correctly are correctly position is
correctly summarized. Or 4 summarized. Or the summarized
summarized. Subject positions are covered positions of 3 correctly. Or the
knowledge is but summary on one stakeholders are positions of 2
excellent. position is unclear or covered with only stakeholders are
incorrect. Subject one position unclear covered with one
appears to be good. or incorrect OR 4 position unclear or
positions are covered incorrect. Or 3
but there are to 2 to 3 positions are covered
factual errors. but there are 2 to 3
factual errors.
Biodiversity 3 biodiversity issues 2 biodiversity issues 1 biodiversity issue is 1 biodiversity issues
are covered in detail are covered in detail covered in detail with is covered including
with examples. There with examples. There examples. There is only essential
is no incorrect is no incorrect no incorrect knowledge about the
information. Subject information. OR 3 information. OR topic, OR there are 1
knowledge is biodiversity issues 2 biodiversity issues or 2 factual errors,
excellent. are covered including are covered including OR 2 biodiversity
only essential only essential issues are covered
knowledge about the knowledge about the but there are 3 or 4
topic, or there are 1 topic, or there are 1 factual errors.
or 2 factual errors. or 2 factual errors,
OR 3 ways are
covered but there are
3 or 4 factual errors.
Humans and the 3 ways in which 2 ways in which 1 way in which 1 way in which
Ecosystem humans can impact humans can impact humans can impact humans can impact
the environment the environment are the environment is the environment is
(either positively or covered in detail. covered in detail. covered including
negatively) are There is no incorrect There is no incorrect only essential
covered in detail. information. OR 3 information. OR 2 knowledge about the
There is no incorrect ways are covered ways are covered topic, OR there are 1
information. Subject including only including only or 2 factual errors,
knowledge is essential knowledge essential knowledge OR 2 ways are
excellent. about the topic, or about the topic, or covered but there are
there are 1 or 2 there are 1 or 2 3 or 4 factual errors.
factual errors. factual errors, OR 3
ways are covered but
there are 3 or 4
factual errors.
To Drill or Not To Drill Position is Position is Position is Position is
summarized using 4 summarized using 3 summarized using 1 summarized. There is
to 5 pieces of pieces of supportive or 2 pieces of no evidence. Subject
supportive evidence. evidence. Subject evidence. Subject knowledge is seems
Subject knowledge is knowledge is good. knowledge is good. to be lacking.
excellent. Position is Position is somewhat Position is somewhat Position is not
convincing. convincing. condescending. convincing.
ANWR—Project Content Rubric