IPD_ReedCappleman_2011

W
Shared by: g77S2r
Categories
Tags
-
Stats
views:
1
posted:
11/10/2011
language:
English
pages:
88
Document Sample
scope of work template
							The Therapeutic Community Model
 in a Low Secure Setting for People
  With Learning Disabilities and its
 Effect on Emotional Development
           Reed Cappleman
                 Background
• Study looks at first TC to be used in treatment for
  people with LD
• Low secure unit for people sectioned under
  Mental Health Act (2003)
• Twice daily community meetings, focussed
  therapy groups, individual therapy, intensive staff
  training, support and supervision
• Emphasis on empowering patients, joint decision
  making, transparency, reflection
• Unit closed in summer 2010 due to financial
  circumstances
           Outline of the Study
• Case series of four men I worked with in the
  hospital
• Utilising data from:
     • Object Relations Technique (ORT)
     • House-Tree-Person (HTP)
     • Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI)
• Caution: Limited data, so conclusions to be
  drawn are limited- guide future research
                       David
• Man sectioned due to sexual offences
• Previously underwent cognitive-behavioural
  treatment: limited success
• Assessments showed
  – Lack of integration, wish to disown responsibility
  – Severe disturbance of object relations- strong themes
    of violence and abuse on ORT, impaired sense of self
    as separate due to very early traumatisation
  – High score on Psychoticism dimension on BSI
                         David
• Re-tested following TC treatment, including
  individual therapy
  – Less violent/sexual content in ORT responses (though
    still marked disturbance)- sense of acceptance of need
    for others to keep boundaries
  – HTP: Still difficulties taking responsibility, but clearer
    sense of self, less omnipotent, more awareness of
    issues around sexuality
  – BSI: Decrease in psychoticism, but increase in
    depression and hostility
• Behavioural changes- spoke in community
  meetings about why detained- major shift
           Other participants
• Martin- diagnosed with psychosis. Period of
  being completely cut off, but then developed
  more secure sense of self, more able to relate
  to others
• Andrew- psychosis and violent behaviour.
  Feeling safer, taking more responsibility,
  decrease in apparent distress
• Dean- increase in openness, acknowledging
  emotions more, but some increased
  disturbance
             Common Themes
• No universal improvements- treatment difficult
  process
• For 3 of the 4, more positive changes than
  negative
• Different aspects of TC all came in to play-
  challenging, silent acceptance, belonging, place
  to ‘speak the unspeakable’
• Projective tests useful for measuring progress,
  but also for guiding formulation and intervention
                  Further Work
• Data here suggests approach worthy of more
  detailed investigation- especially in light of
  scandal in Bristol
   – May be awhile before such a project comes along
     again in current climate
   – May need more evidence as to effectiveness of
     psychotherapy and LD first
   – Need to look at different areas of outcome-
     quantitative and qualitative data, cost-offset studies
• Use of projective tests in shaping and measuring
  intervention also promising- need further work
  on validation
Welcome to the IPD Conference

   New Ways Forward for Disability
         Psychotherapy
         Dr Pat Frankish
 Individual case study - How does
      the provision of disability
    psychotherapy training to an
individual with physical disabilities
   and mental health issues and
   social care staff impact on the
  individual’s social care support
              package.
           Amanda Jacques
               Frankish Training
                  Case Study
•   Alice
•   42 years old living as tenant in own home
•   Lived at home until dad died
•   Residential services
•   Supported living
•   Direct payments
•   Independent Living Fund
•   Social services
                      Frankish Training
    Assessments used and type of
             analysis
• Interviews
• Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI)
• General Health Questionnaire (GHQ).
• House Tree Person (HTP)
• Object Relations Technique (ORT)
• Maslach Burnout Inventory (MBI) Human Services Survey
  Manual
• Fortnightly notes and three monthly interpretation
• Disability Psychotherapy joint individual and staff Training
• Extra intervention – telephone on-call

                            Frankish Training
              Interventions
      Alice                            Staff
– BSI                         • Maslach Burnout
– HTP                           Inventory (MBI)
– ORT                           Human Services
                                Survey Manual
– GHQ
– Therapy
  fortnightly
– my visit fortnightly
– Telephone        Frankish Training
       Joint Intervention Disability
         Psychotherapy Training
•   Week 1 – Winnicott         • Week 9 – Frankish Model
•   Week 2 – Bowlby              observation
                                 differentiation, practicing
•   Week 3 – Mahler
                                 stages
•   Week 4 – Sinason
                               • Week 10 - Frankish Model
•   Week 5 – Freud               observation early/ late
•   Week 6 – Klein               rapprochement
•   Week 7 – Bion              • Week 11 - Frankish Model
•   Week 8 – Malan               observation Scoring
                               • Week 12 – Evaluation
                         Frankish Training
         Results and Analysis Brief
           Symptom Inventory
Remained         Increased in        Decreased in    Reduced from
above criteria   symptoms            symptoms        clinical to non
for case                                             clinical
1. Interpersonal 1. Obsessive        1. Depression   1. Somatization
   Sensitivity      Compulsive                       2. Anxiety
2. Paranoid                                          3. Hostility
   Ideation
                                                     4. Phobic
3. Psychoticism
                                                        Anxiety
4. Global
   Severity
   Index


                            Frankish Training
Symptoms Above Criteria for Case




             Frankish Training
Increase




 Frankish Training
Decreased




  Frankish Training
Reduced from Clinical to Non Clinical




               Frankish Training
Above Clinical Case As Out Patient




              Frankish Training
House




Frankish Training
Tree




Frankish Training
Person




Frankish Training
  ORT Blank Card December 2009
• Picture 13 -Sad and lonely because of hamster
  and had cruel remarks about its death. Feeling
  low and down on boxing day going to ring
  somebody and will ring back. Feel broken
  hearted and staff moaning about their
  problems. Nobody takes any notice of me. Get
  telephone number and ring them and wait for
  them to speak.

                     Frankish Training
  ORT Blank Card December 2010
• Picture 13 –I would like to meet somebody
  maybe not get married, do more courses,
  have a happier life and hope my health will
  improve and just go from there. Can see a
  future.




                     Frankish Training
       General Health Questionnaire
Date            A=Somatic   B=Anxiety &       C=Social      D=Severe     Total
                symptoms    Insomnia          Dysfunction   Depression




11th December   2           7                 2             1            12
2009




24th December   2           4                 2             0            8
2010




The recommended cut-off point for a positive result is 6 to 7 for each subscale.
A total score of 13 or more almost always indicates a positive psychiatric
condition

                                     Frankish Training
                                                  Telephone calls

                                                             Total Calls to location
                  80


                  70


                  60


                  50
number of calls




                                                                                                                                total
                                                                                                                                A/H office
                  40
                                                                                                                                A/Coffice
                                                                                                                                Mobile week
                  30
                                                                                                                                mobile W/E

                  20


                  10


                  0
                       Dec-09   Jan-10   Feb-10 Mar-10 Apr-10 May-10 Jun-10   Jul-10   Aug-10 Sep-10   Oct-10   Nov-10 Dec-10




                                                                     Frankish Training
              Maslach Burnout Inventory
                                         Table 1 Jan 10

                  Emotional                                             Personal                risk to
Month     staff   Exhaustion   cat       Depersonalization        cat   Accomplishment   cat    burn out



Jan-10    1       6            low       0                        low   26               high   low



Jan-10    2       28           high      0                        low   31               high   average



Jan-10    3       8            low       2                        low   29               high   low



Jan-10    4       22           average   6                        low   26               high   average



Total     4       64                     8                              112



average   1       16           low       2                        low   28               high   low


                                              Frankish Training
   Maslach Burnout Inventory Jan
               2010
From the individual sheets Jan 2010 the highest individual score in January
2010 for emotional exhaustion was 5 equating to a few times a week. This
was for the question-
• I feel used up at the end of the workday
The highest score for depersonalization was 5 equating to a few times a week.
This was for the question-
• I worry that this job is hardening me emotionally
The highest score for personal accomplishment was 6 equating to everyday.
This was for questions-
• I can easily understand how my recipient feel about things
• I deal very effectively with the problems of my recipients
• I have accomplished many worthwhile things in this job
• I feel exhilarated after working closely with my recipients
                                 Frankish Training
          Maslach Burnout Inventory
                Table 2 Jan 11
                                                                           risk to
Month     staff   EE   cat         DP                cat       PA   cat    burn out



Jan-11    1       30   high        5                 low       24   high   average



          2       17   average     4                 low       26   high   average



          3       13   low         9                 average   32   high   average



Total     3       60               18                          82



average   1       20   average     6                 low       27   high   average




                                 Frankish Training
   Maslach Burnout Inventory Jan
               2011
From the individual sheets Jan 2011 the highest individual score for
emotional exhaustion was 5 equating to a few times a week. This was for the
questions-
• I feel emotionally drained from my work
The highest score for depersonalization was 4 equating to once a week. This
was for the question-
• I’ve become more callous toward people since I took this job
• I feel recipients blame me for some of their problems
The highest score for personal accomplishment was 5 equating to a few times
a week. This was for questions-
• I can easily create a relaxed atmosphere with my recipients
• In my work I deal with emotional problems very calmly

                                Frankish Training
                    My sessions

March 2010 the themes that emerged were;
• Needing a secure base environment and staff to understand
  her needs relating to all the
• Pain of difference really struggling with it
• Attacks on links -me yawning were very prominent
• Thoughts on pain of unspoken transference and counter
  transference
• Splitting staff group regarding me therapist manager
• As regards health the difference within the social model
  medical model support

                          Frankish Training
                    My sessions
June 2010 the themes that emerged were;
• Concerns very prominent related to anger and pain associated
  with disability and incompetence of professionals
• Taking part on the training course has highlighted the
  differences between her and staff group
• Understanding how seeing a therapist and myself helps
  indicate emotional development
• Able to accept others and the staff and the conflicts.
• Staff are not able to do everything for her but able to value
  what is done

                           Frankish Training
                My sessions
September 2010 the themes that emerged
  were;
• An awareness of being different
• Issues of not being good enough, particularly
  the staff not good enough for Alice
• Attachment issues and abandonment.
• Attacks on linking and difficulties associated
  with the pain of difference
                     Frankish Training
               My sessions
December 2010 the themes that emerged
  were;
• Ending is a problem
• Not being “good enough”
• Health issues and professionals not being
  good enough
• Some hope for the future
• A shift in view of relationships
                     Frankish Training
  Response to research question-

• Individual case study - How does the provision
  of disability psychotherapy training to an
  individual with physical disabilities and mental
  health issues and social care staff impact on
  the individual’s social care support package.




                     Frankish Training
Welcome to the IPD Conference

   New Ways Forward for Disability
         Psychotherapy
         Dr Pat Frankish
                   Age-related disability.
Therapeutic ‘holding’ of people with dementia. Analysis of
the impact of environmental change on the emotional well-
  being of people with dementia living at a rehabilitation-
                 focused private hospital.



                   Liz Trubshaw
            Pat Frankish Psychology &
           Psychotherapy Consultancy

                                                              38
  Links between early and later life


And so, from hour to hour, we ripe and ripe,

And then, from hour to hour, we rot and rot;

        And thereby hangs a tale…

         [Shakespeare, As You Like It, II, vii, 26-28]




                                                         39
                           Dementia
•   Dementia is a blanket term used to describe the
    symptoms that occur when the brain is effected by
    specific diseases and conditions (Malloy, 2009)
•   It is not a natural part of aging but is a disability that
    can occur in older age
•   Robs the person of memory, and, ultimately, their
    identity
•   Incidence on the increase. There is no cure
•   Majority of sufferers live in the community, at least in
    the early stages & majority of care given informally
    by family
•   Not enough formal care provision
                                                            40
                         Stages in the progression of AD
            1st (Early) stage = forgetfulness phase – anxiety & depression
Emotional
• Increased irritability, lowered frustration tolerance
• Depression, anxiety, wide mood swings
• Restlessness, fatigue, lack of initiative
• loss of interest
• High activity level with incessant wandering
• Attitude of unconcern
• Excuse making
Social
• Accentuation of previous personality traits
• Apathy or euphoria
Cognitive
• Memory disturbance: significant difficulty in forming new memories
• Misplacing objects, forgetting names
• Preservation of remote well learned memories
• Disturbance of problem-solving skills: inability to solve novel, complex problems in
   which old, well established skills & strategies cannot be used
• Difficulties with comprehension, expression of complex ideas, abstract thought,
   making critical judgements
• Deficit of constructional skills

                                                                                    41
              2nd (middle/intermediate) Stage = confusional phase
•  Accentuation of previous emotional, social & cognitive changes
•  Less able to manage personal or business affairs because of failing memory & lack
   initiative
Impairment of
• Orientation (initially for time, later for place)
• Memory (especially recent memory)
• Judgement, comprehension, calculation
• Inability to organise memories in proper time sequence
• Word-finding difficulties
• Language becomes tangential, circumlocutory & perseverative. Speech is fluent
   but features a lack of substantive words
• Memory for remote memories relatively intact, vocabulary largely spared
• Neurological examination still normal
Personality
• Changes become more apparent
• Heedless of personal dress & behaviour
• Unconcern for others, denial
• Wandering, restless, upset at night
• May have insight into cognitive losses, leading to secondary anxiety
• depression

                                                                                       42
           3rd (Late) stage = dementia phase – extreme dependency
Cognitively
• More generalised loss of intellectual skills
• Loss of insight
• Inattention, distractibility
• Severe disorientation
• Motor, speech perseveration
• More distinctly aphasic: loss of spontaneous speech; anomia; echolalia; relative
   preservation of repetition
• Agnosias: may mistake individuals or objects in the environment & respond
   accordingly
• Apraxias: loss of motor programmes (sugar in coffee, lighting match, combing hair,
   walking)
• Widespread neurological signs, abnormal reflexes
Behaviourally
• Prominent behavioural problems that challenge carers/families/peers
• Uncommunicative, apathetic, withdrawn
• Anxiety, agitation, motor restlessness, wandering
• Delusions, hallucinations, paranoid ideation
• Walking, mobility affected, eventual confinement to wheelchair & then bed
• Speech, swallowing impaired
• Incontinent
• Depression of consciousness leading to stupor, coma & then death
                                                                                   43
    Reaching people with dementia- the obstacles

• In 1953 Freud said

“near or above the age of 50 the elasticity of the
mental processes, on which the [psychoanalysis]
treatment depends, is a rule lacking – old people are no
longer educable – and, on the other hand, the mass of
material to be dealt with would probably prolong the
duration of the treatment indefinitely” (p.264; cited in
Bender, 1993).
                                                           44
 Some intra-psychic & institutional processes that give
                rise to discrimination
• Kitwood (1988) function of a person with dementia could be
  impeded further by poor or critical handling by family &
  carers

• ‘mirroring’ of the forgetting that occurs in patients with
  dementia in the organization of services, splitting off and
  evacuating uncomfortable areas (Klein, 1975)

• A denial of the need to think about people with dementia
  occurs – e.g. a tendency to assume that there is little or no
  activity remaining in the minds of people who are losing their
  memory
                                                                   45
    Staff defences: Horticultural approach to care
• Davenhill (2007) – the emotional meaning of tasks
  such as eating and washing are often forgotten -
  there is a lack of significance given to the body of an
  older person, other than in a purely functional way,
  yet physical care is a nonverbal form of
  communication

• Impatience with a sufferer’s slowness, by over-
  compensating for their perceived difficulties, may
  add humiliation to their already impaired thinking
  and doing (Evans, 2008)

                                                            46
             ‘Holding’ people with dementia


• A person with dementia is someone who becomes
  increasingly isolated yet increasingly dependent.
• Frankish’s (1992) adaptation of Mahler’s stages of
  emotional development, posits that (the once
  individuated) people with dementia traverse
  Mahler’s stages in reverse.
• As the disease progresses more losses are
  experienced. When in the advanced stage the person
  cannot bear to be with him/herself (Frankish, 2009).



                                                     47
    Justification for conducting the current study

• It is proposed that by providing regular and
  consistent contact to people with dementia
  living in a long-stay hospital, emotional
  deterioration will at least be static, and the
  person will be therapeutically ‘held’ and
  ‘present’ for longer.




                                                     48
                           Method
• Observational, repeated measures design across two time
  points (observations, HTP) of patients
• Contact with each person (tactile & verbal) for 5 minutes,
  twice a week
• Staff completed the Ward Atmosphere Scale at baseline and
  at twelve months

                           Measures
• House-Tree-Person (HTP) test – projective personality test
  (Buck 1948)
• Frankish’s (1992) adaptation of Mahler’s stages of emotional
  development (observation tool)
• Ward Atmosphere Scale (WAS) – Form R (Real)
                                                                 49
      Mahler’s (1975) phases of emotional development
• Differentiation – ability to recognise that there are parts of
  itself that are different.

• Practising – begins to practice behaviours that come with
  development – e.g. walking & talking. Repetitive.

• Rapprochement – experiments with increasing physical &
  emotional distance between self & primary carer but still with
  regular & consistent checking that the carer is vigilant.

• Individuation – the final stage – ability to be separate & away
  from the primary carer without obvious anxiety.

                                                                   50
 Measurement of Emotional Development – Frankish,
                      1992
• Observe for 20-seconds, code for 40-seconds coding, observe again
  for 20-seconds. Complete this procedure for 40-minutes.
• For each minute = three observations (Behaviour, Orientation,
  Interaction).
• Behaviour is allocated as:
   – P to represent passive
   – A to represent active behaviour
   – R to represent repetitive behaviour
   – V to represent varied behaviour
• Orientation is allocated as:
   – S for orientation to self
   – O for orientation to objects
   – P for orientation to person
   Interaction Y = present; N = absent
                                                                  51
                          Frankish’s   Mahler’s Phase
                            Code
Passive, Self, No             1        Differentiation
Active, Self, No              1
Active, Objects, No           2           Practising
Active, Person, Yes           3
Repetitive, Self, No          1
Repetitive, Objects, No       2
Repetitive, Person, No        2
Repetitive, Person, Yes       3        Rapprochement
Varied, Self, No              1
Varied, Object, No            2
Varied, Object, Yes           3
Varied, Person, Yes           4         Individuation

                                                         52
                             Ward Atmosphere Scale – Moos 1974
                                        Relationship Dimensions

1    Involvement               How active & energetic patients are in the program

2    Support                   How much patients help & support each other & how supportive the staff is
                               toward patients
3    Spontaneity               How much the program encourages the open expression of feelings by
                               patients & staff
                                      Personal Growth Dimensions

4    Autonomy                  How self-sufficient & independent patients are in making their own decisions

5    Practical Orientation     The extent to which the patients learn practical skills & are prepared for
                               release from the program
6    Personal Problems         The extent to which patients seek to understand their feelings & personal
     Orientation               problems
7    Anger & Aggression        The extent to which patients argue with other patients & staff, become
                               openly angry, & display other aggressive behaviour
                                   System Maintenance Dimensions

8    Order & Organization      How important order & organization are in the program

9    Program Clarity           The extent to which patients know what to expect in their day to day routine
                               & the explicitness of program rules & procedures
10   Staff Control             The extent to which the staff use measures to keep patients under necessary
                               controls                                                                 53
                           Procedure
• Spent 5-minutes twice a week with each patient on the unit.
• Baseline emotional level was recorded and assessed every
  four months, over a 12-month period.
• House-Tree-Person drawings were requested at Time1 and
  Time 4.
• Unit staff completed the Ward Atmosphere Scale (WAS) Form
  R, to describe their experience of working on the Unit.
• Inter-rater reliability = 1 service user and her carer who had
  both completed level 2 of the DDP course. They did not know
  the participants.




                                                               54
Results




          55
                         Time 1     Time 2     Time 3      Time 4     HTP           comment
                         Jan 2010   May 2010   Sept 2010   Jan 2011   1&
                                                                      2

Alan     Schizophrenia   2          2          2           2          No    No HTP


Brian    Korsakoff’s     3          3          3           3          Yes   Improvement on HTP –
                                                                            still disturbed but
                                                                            more presence

Gordon   Frontal Lobe    1          2          2           2-3 (20    Yes   Detero’tn on HTP
         Dementia                                          each)            Some practicing
                                                                            behvrs, some
                                                                            rapprochement
James    Frontal Lobe    2          2          2           2-3        1     Time 121 x 2, 19 x 3 at
         Dementia                                                           T4. Some
                                                                            rapprochement.
                                                                            HTP – helpless,
                                                                            vulnerable

John     Alzheimer’s     2          2          2           2          Yes   Major Deterioration &
                                                                            shrinkage in cog
                                                                            ability.
Tom      Korsakoff’s     2          2          2           2          Yes   No person Time 2.
                                                                            Smaller not as detailed.
                                                                            Differentiation/practicing

Trevor   Alzheimer’s     -          1          2           2          1


                                                                                                      56
Brian - Time 1 (Korsakoff’s )
Brian – Time 2




                 58
• Brian - Time 2




                   59
• Brian – Time 2




                   60
Gordon – Time 1 (Frontal Lobe)
Gordon – Time 1
Gordon – Time 2
Gordon – Time 2
Gordon – Time 2
John – Time 1 (Alzheimer’s)
John – Time 1
John – Time 1
John – Time 2
John – Time 2
John – Time 2
Ward Atmosphere Scale Profile (Form R). Staff
experience of the Unit at 1 month & 12 months
                          Discussion
• Emotional level static for most patients using Frankish’s tool
• HTPs demonstrated
   – Improvement
   – Stability
   – Deterioration
• Ward Atmosphere Scale
   – Staff experience of the Unit had deteriorated over the 12
      months
• Some patients therapeutically held by contact despite
  instability of the Unit




                                                                   73
                           Limitations
• Confounders
   – My presence
   – Extraneous variables
   – Only twice a week for 5 minutes
   – Unconscious desire for the patients to continue to be
     psychically well, initially by me, but also by other raters




                                                                   74
                          Conclusion
• Enhancing the quality of care is much needed, particularly
  finding ways to understand the patient’s experience and to
  better communicate
• Real and ordinary contact with people right to the end is what
  is required.

                        Recommendations
• Unit & hospital wide training to Level 2 of the DDP
• Daily, regular, consistent, real and ordinary contact




                                                               75
                           References
• Davenhill, R. (2007). (Ed.). Looking into later life.
       London: Karnac Books.
• Evans, S. (2008). ‘Beyond forgetfulness’: How
       psychoanalytic ideas can help us to understand the
       experience of patients with dementia.
       Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy, 22(3), 155-176.
• Frankish, P. (1992). A psychodynamic approach to
       emotional difficulties within a social framework.
       Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 36, 559- 563.
• Malloy, L. (2009). Thinking about dementia – a
       psychodynamic understanding of links between           early
   infantile experience and dementia.          Psychoanalytic
   Psychotherapy, 23(2), 109-120.


                                                                  76
Welcome to the IPD Conference

   New Ways Forward for Disability
         Psychotherapy
         Dr Pat Frankish
Evaluation of the Impact of using a
Disability Psychotherapy Approach
     with Five Training Clients
         Amanda Shackleton
     Clinical Psychologist 2 days
  Tameside Learning Disability Service
                        Why
• From a behavioural background – previously rely
  on behavioural reduction as indicator of clinical
  success
• Training has been incredibly powerful
   • completely changed my thinking
   • have seen changes over and above reduction of
     referral issue
• Passionate about continuing and developing
  practice now training completed
   • Need data to support continuing to use approach
• To allow consolidation of training process for self
                               Method
• Examined impact on 5 clients with learning disabilities
   •   Range of length of therapy 12 month to 2 years – still ongoing
   •   3 mild LD, 1 moderate and one severe LD


• Retrospectively tried to establish data set for each client
   – File review looking for indictors of change over and above
     referral issue
   – Key informant interview based on file review
   – Behavioural incident reports
   – Projective tests used in assessment repeated
        – House Tree Person
        – Object Relations Test
            Therapeutic Approach
• Approach – radical change from previous working
   – Provision of safe base – dynamic administration
   – Using ideas of Winnicott, Klien and Bion re provision of a
     containing and facilitating experience that can help
     process of thinking development
   – Growing awareness of counter transference and
     projections as a therapeutic tool and guide
   – Helping person make links between past and present and
     defences.
   – Supervision by Linda Arkwright
                    Mr A
• 29 years old, lives with adoptive parents,
• Referred for agitation, aggression, anxiety
• Birth mother drug user, found alone at 6
  weeks in filthy, emaciated state. Thought
  cerebral palsy. Fostered until 13 months then
  adopted.
• 26 attempts to get service engagement since 9
  years old
                  Therapy Mr A
  – WAIS-3 –IQ 69 – presents as much more able.
  – BADS – significant frontal lobe difficulties identified
     • extremely poor initiation, planning and problem solving.
• Therapy work 21 months to date
  – 38 weekly sessions – lots of AWOL periods and DNA’s
  – Key themes –
     • anger at birth mother and also adoptive mother’s
       ‘invasiveness’ - missing attunement / false self
     • Cognitive assessment results – understanding self
     • Wanting to move on and progress in life – previously not
       able to think possible
                        Outcomes Mr A
•   File review key changes
     – Decrease in incidents – first 12 months= 9, last 9 months = 1
     – Thinking longer term consequences of actions on impact on others
     – Wants to work - referral to supported employment – been disappointed by
         loss of workers and poor service progress
•   Key informant – mother – issues re seeing - not been able to collect data from her
•   ORT
     – increased richness in answers and more emotional content
     – increase in ability to describe consequences
           • 8 Don’t Know to ‘what will happen next?’ vs 1 at repeat
     – themes re aggression / drinking / groups - currently going out with old
         friends / processing issues
•   HTP
     – Slight increases in detail of pictures but not size.
     – not as significant as seen in other clients
Client   age   Referral issue     Therapy Incident         ORT          HTP             File and key
                                  length  reports                                       informant
                                  to date
Ms L     58    Anxiety,           16 mths   n/a            Not          Much            Better
               depression, over                            repeated     richer          boundaries;
               dependence                                  due to       detail in all   assertive;
                                                           reaction     drawings        thinking of
                                                           to inital                    solutions
Ms D     43    Increase in        2 years   Staff report   Refused to Refused to Increased
               aggression                   decrease       repeat     repeat     empathy, sense
                                            but                                  of humour,
                                            unreliable                           seeking
                                            data                                 independence
Mr D     27    Acute anxiety,     18 mths   Self report    Richer,      Much            More
               agitation                    decrease       ‘complete’   developed       independence,
                                                           answers      then            sorting out
                                                                        declined        own problems,
                                                                                        more assertive
Mr P     31    Challenging        18 mths   Data           n/a          More            No key
               behaviour –                  incomplete                  developed       informant
               aggression,                  – repeated                  then            available –
               refusal                      staff                       declined        qualitative
                                            turnover                                    changes in
                                            and moves                                   sessions -
                                                                                        reverie
              Overall Conclusions
• All clients show indications of positive change in
  therapy
   – Difficulties with obtaining complete data sets

• Overall review massively helpful – goes beyond reviews
  for supervision

• Highlighted how vulnerable clients are to service and
  life changes,
   – Those supported by staff – longest time people worked
     with them 2 years
   – Everyone receiving services has had some service
     disruption or worker change
      • Indications of impact on measures used.
      Further Work on this Project
• To use present data set as base line and follow up after
  completion of therapy
   – especially useful to compare with those who have had previous
     behavioural approaches
       • Look at time/cost involved with previous approaches
• To routinely assess and evaluate therapy work
   – establish protocol with as wide a range of measures as possible.
   – To include outcome measures used by Beail and others
       • Brief Symptom Inventory; Inventory of Interpersonal Problems
   – To look at client thoughts on therapy work
• Continue to contribute to growing evidence for this approach
  as feel is far superior in terms of benefits and changes for
  people able to access.
• Thank you for listening and any questions or
  comments??

						
Related docs
Other docs by g77S2r
NIFinalReport
Views: 1  |  Downloads: 0
sbirsttr2001
Views: 1  |  Downloads: 0
Brian
Views: 8  |  Downloads: 0
cvMartinSchuele
Views: 4  |  Downloads: 0
server - Download Now DOC
Views: 14  |  Downloads: 0
Parnell_Arthur_F_2009 05 08
Views: 3  |  Downloads: 0
The 20Causes 20of 20War
Views: 0  |  Downloads: 0
orms friend or foe
Views: 0  |  Downloads: 0
IVI 3 1_Architecture_2011 05 26
Views: 1  |  Downloads: 0