Competitive Analysis Table
1 This table shows the technical specification comparison of different Video capture card and DVR
2 TME can use this table as a guide to evaluate and compare new products or other competitor produ
3 TME should highlight key factors or benefit of the product with evaluating and comparing.
4 TME can add in more criteria in evaluating or comparing onto the table and review it with RPM.
ferent Video capture card and DVR
new products or other competitor products.
h evaluating and comparing.
the table and review it with RPM.
S/No BRAND Huper Lab Huper Lab Huper Lab Dahua Dahua Dahua
SERIES PCI DVR Card(Plus PCI DVR Card(Plus PCI DVR Card(Plus F series, VCC F series, VCC F series, VCC
Series), VCC Series), VCC Series), VCC
1 MODEL NO 4404S+ 4408Y+ 4416S+ DH-VEC0404F DH-VEC0804F DH-VEC1604F
2 DESCRIPTION 4 Channel PCI DVR Card 8 Channel PCI DVR Card 16 Channel PCI DVR Card 4 Channel audio/video 8 Channel audio/video 16 Channel audio/video
compression board compression board compression board
3 OS Windows 2000/2003/XP, Windows 2000/2003/XP, Windows 2000/2003/XP, Windows Windows 2000/2003/XP, Windows
Linux Linux Linux 2000/2003/XP, Linux Linux 2000/2003/XP, Linux
4 CPU Intel Series Intel Series Intel Series Intel Series Intel Series Intel Series
5 Mother Board Based on Intel Based on Intel Based on Intel Based on Intel Based on Intel Based on Intel
845/865/915/925/945 845/865/915/925/945 845/865/915/925/945 845/865/915/925/945 845/865/915/925/945 845/865/915/925/945
Chipset Chipset Chipset Chipset Chipset Chipset
6 Memory 256MB and above 256MB and above 256MB and above 256MB and above 256MB and above 256MB and above
7 DSP model TBA TBA TBA TI DM642 TI DM642 TI DM642
8 Video Compression MPEG 4 MPEG 4 MPEG 4 H.264 H.264 H.264
9 Compress image file Ave size? Ave size? Ave size? 300-500kbps 300-500kbps 300-500kbps
size - CIF
10 Compress image file Ave size? Ave size? Ave size? 1000-1500kbps 1000-1500kbps 1000-1500kbps
size - D1
11 PCI standard PCI Express PCI Express PCI Express PCI 2.2, PCI-X PCI 2.2, PCI-X PCI 2.2, PCI-X
12 Max number of Stack 4 2 2 4 4 4
card
13 Frame Rate - Live 30fps(CIF), 25fps(D1) 25fps(CIF), 15fps(D1) 120fps(CIF), 55fps(D1) 30/25fps(D1) 30/25fps(D1) 30/25fps(D1)
view(NTSC/PAL)
14 Frame Rate - 30fps(CIF), 25fps(D1) 25fps(CIF), 15fps(D1) 120fps(CIF), 55fps(D1) 30/25fps(CIF), 30/25fps(CIF), 30/25fps(CIF),
recording (NTSC/PAL) 30/25fps(D1), per 30/25fps(D1), per 15/12.5fps(D1), per
channel channel channel
15 Video Input 4 BNC 1.0Vp-p, 75ohms 8 BNC 1.0Vp-p, 75ohms 16 BNC 1.0Vp-p, 75ohms 4 BNC 1.0Vp-p, 75ohms 8 BNC 1.0Vp-p, 75ohms 16 BNC 1.0Vp-p,
75ohms
16 Video Output 1 X VGA 1 X VGA 1 X VGA 1 X VGA 1 X VGA 1 X VGA
17 Audio input/output 1xRCA 1xRCA 4 x RCA 4ch, 200-2800mV, 30K 8ch, 200-2800mV, 30K 16ch, 200-2800mV, 30K
ohms ohms ohms
18 Audio Compression TBA TBA TBA PCM/ADPCM PCM/ADPCM PCM/ADPCM
19 Loop out video - - - - - -
20 Alarm input - - - Using Alarm Card Using Alarm Card Using Alarm Card
21 Alarm output - - - Using Alarm Card Using Alarm Card Using Alarm Card
22 Network Supported LAN、PSTN、ADSL、DD LAN、PSTN、ADSL、DD LAN、PSTN、ADSL、DD LAN、PSTN、ADSL、D LAN、PSTN、ADSL、DD LAN、PSTN、ADSL、D
N、GPRS、CDMA 1x N、GPRS、CDMA 1x N、GPRS、CDMA 1x DN、GPRS、CDMA 1x N、GPRS、CDMA 1x DN、GPRS、CDMA 1x
23 Network Protocol TCP/IP、UDP、PPPOE、 TCP/IP、UDP、PPPOE、 TCP/IP、UDP、PPPOE、 TCP/IP、UDP、PPPOE TCP/IP、UDP、PPPOE TCP/IP、UDP、PPPOE
HTTP、FTP、PPP、DHC HTTP、FTP、PPP、DHC HTTP、FTP、PPP、DHCP 、HTTP、FTP、PPP、D 、HTTP、FTP、PPP、D 、HTTP、FTP、PPP、D
P、DTP、SMTP、DNS P、DTP、SMTP、DNS 、DTP、SMTP、DNS HCP、DTP、SMTP、DN HCP、DTP、SMTP、DN HCP、DTP、SMTP、DN
S S S
24 PTZ control RS-422, RS-485 Interface RS-422, RS-485 Interface RS-422, RS-485 Interface RS-422, RS-485 RS-422, RS-485 Interface RS-422, RS-485 Interface
Interface
25 PTZ protocol available Pelco P,D Pelco P,D Pelco P,D YOULI YOULI YOULI
LILIN-1016 LILIN-1016 LILIN-1016
LILIN-820 LILIN-820 LILIN-820
PELCO-P PELCO-P PELCO-P
DM-QUICKBALL DM-QUICKBALL DM-QUICKBALL
HD600 HD600 HD600
JC4116 JC4116 JC4116
PELCO-DWX PELCO-DWX PELCO-DWX
PELCO-D PELCO-D PELCO-D
VCOM-VC-2000 VCOM-VC-2000 VCOM-VC-2000
NETSTREAMER NETSTREAMER NETSTREAMER
SAE SAE SAE
SAMSUNG SAMSUNG SAMSUNG
KALATEL-KTD KALATEL-KTD KALATEL-KTD
CELOTEX CELOTEX CELOTEX
TLPELCO-P TLPELCO-P TLPELCO-P
TL-HHX2000 TL-HHX2000 TL-HHX2000
BBV BBV BBV
RM110 RM110 RM110
KC3360S KC3360S KC3360S
ACES ACES ACES
ALSON ALSON ALSON
INV3609HD INV3609HD INV3609HD
HOWELL HOWELL HOWELL
TC-PELCO-P TC-PELCO-P TC-PELCO-P
TC-PELCO-D TC-PELCO-D TC-PELCO-D
AUTO-M AUTO-M AUTO-M
26 Recording option Continuous, Continuous, Continuous, AUTO-H
Continuous, AUTO-H
Continuous, AUTO-H
Continuous,
Event(Motion, Event(Motion, Event(Motion, Event(Motion, Event(Motion, Event(Motion,
Sensor),Pre/Post-Alarm, Sensor),Pre/Post-Alarm, Sensor),Pre/Post-Alarm, Sensor),Pre/Post-Alarm, Sensor),Pre/Post-Alarm, Sensor),Pre/Post-Alarm,
Schedule(time and Date) Schedule(time and Date) Schedule(time and Date) Schedule(time and Schedule(time and Date) Schedule(time and Date)
Date)
27 Playback Channel, 4 ch syn 4 ch syn 4 ch syn 4 ch syn 8 ch syn 16 ch syn
Asyn or Syn
28 Motion Detection YES YES YES YES YES YES
29 Privacy Masking TBA TBA TBA Self defined four sided Self defined four sided Self defined four sided
zone for privacy zone for privacy masking zone for privacy masking
masking
30 Working Temperature -10 to 55 degree celsius -10 to 55 degree celsius -10 to 55 degree celsius -10 to 55 degree celsius -10 to 55 degree celsius -10 to 55 degree celsius
31 Working Humidity 10%-90% 10%-90% 10%-90% 10%-90% 10%-90% 10%-90%
32 Dimension TBA TBA TBA 152mm(L) x 93mm(H) 182mm(L) x 106mm(H) 257mm(L) x 106mm(H)
33 Power Consumption Info Not Avail. Info Not Avail. Info Not Avail. 3.22W 7.08W 11.44W
Software Features
34 Instant Playback No No No No No No
35 Auto System Idle No No No Yes Yes Yes
Protection
36 Multi Level Password Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Protection
37 PTZ control by Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Directional Buttons
38 EMAP Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
39 Digital Watermark Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
40 Max Screen Divisions 32 32 32 64 64 64
41 Remote Viewing Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
GKB Dahua Geovision
DVR DVR Surveillance Card
w/software Multicam
DVR-1615RW DH-DVR1604GB-S GV-600
16 channel embedded 16 channel embedded 16 Channel
DVR with CD-RW DVR Surveillance Card
Embedd Linux Embedd Linux Windows 2000 /
Windows XP / Windows
Server 2003 / Windows
VISTA
High Performance High Performance Intel Series
Embedded Embedded
Microprocessor Microprocessor
High Performance High Performance Based on Intel
Embedded Embedded Pentium4 2.0 Ghz,
Microprocessor Microprocessor AMD Athlon, Sempron
2000+
TBA TBA 512MB
TBA TBA GV DSP
JPEG2000 H.264 Geo MPEG4, Geo MPEG4
(ASP), Geo H264, Geo
H264 V2
TBA TBA Variable, 300:1
Maximum
TBA TBA Variable, 300:1
Maximum
NA NA PCI
NA NA Info Not Avail.
25fps(D1) 25fps(D1) 25fps (D1)
240fps(CIF), 60fps(D1) 25fps (D1) 25fps (D1)
16 BNC 1.0Vp-p, 16 BNC 1.0Vp-p, 16 BNC /D-Type 1.0Vp-
75ohms 75ohms p, 75ohms
1 x main monitor, 1 x 2ch BNC output, 1 x 1 X VGA
spot monitor, VGA and 1 x matrix
optional for VGA monitor ( optional)
2/2 RCA 16ch input, 1 ch BNC 1xRCA
talk inout for bi
directional talk, 1 ch
BNC audio output
TBA ADPCM ADPCM 8KHz 4 Bit
Mono
16 BNC Loop out 16 BNC Loop out -
optional
16 16 -
2 6 -
LAN、PSTN、ADSL、 LAN、PSTN、ADSL、 TCP/IP, LAN, WAN,
DDN、GPRS、CDMA DDN、GPRS、CDMA Internet, Modem, Dial-
1x 1x up, Modem-to-
Modem, ISDN
TCP/IP、UDP、PPPO LAN、PSTN、ADSL、 TCP/IP、UDP、PPPOE
E、HTTP、FTP、PPP DDN、GPRS、CDMA 、HTTP、FTP、PPP、
、DHCP、DTP、SMT 1x DHCP、DTP、SMTP、
P、DNS DNS
RS-422, RS-485 RS 485 RS-422,RS-485
Interface Interface
Pelco P,D YOULI Ademco Jupiter,
LILIN-1016 BOSCH TC700 &
LILIN-820 TC8560, Canon VC-C3 /
PELCO-P VC-C4, Chiper CPT-
DM-QUICKBALL V9KRV, Directed
HD600 Perception PTU-D46,
JC4116 Dong Yang DOH-240,
PELCO-DWX DynaColor D-7720 /
PELCO-D 7722, Elbex, GANZ ZC-
VCOM-VC-2000 S122, JEC, Kalatel
NETSTREAMER CyberDome, Kampro K-
SAE ZC23, Kenko
SAMSUNG DMP23H1, Lilin PIH,
KALATEL-KTD Minking Minking,
CELOTEX Minking Yaan,
TLPELCO-P Panasonic WV-CS850 /
TL-HHX2000 854, Pelco Spectra D-
BBV protocol / P-protocol,
RM110 Samsung SCC-641 /
KC3360S 643, Pelco Spectra 3,
ACES SAE DR-E588, Samsung
ALSON SPD-1600, Sensormatic
INV3609HD Ultra IV, Sony DVI-
HOWELL D100, TOA CC551
TC-PELCO-P
TC-PELCO-D
AUTO-M
Continuous, AUTO-H Continuous,
Event(Motion, Event(Motion,
Sensor),Pre/Post- Sensor),Pre/Post-
Alarm. Alarm, Schedule(time
and Date)
16 ch syn Info Not Avail.
YES YES YES
NO NO Yes
-10 to 55 degree -10 to 55 degree Info Not Avail.
celsius celsius
10%-90% 10%-90% Info Not Avail.
80mm(D) x 440mm x 460mm x 132mm(L) x 100mm
440mm(L)x 89mm (WxDxH) (H)
370mm(W)
12V 5A Max 40 W Info Not Avail.
Yes, playback Yes, playback Yes
neartime neartime
No No Yes
No, Single password No, Single password Yes
Yes Yes Yes
No No Yes
Yes Yes Yes
16 16 16
Yes Yes Yes