Mother Jones on Bottled Water

Document Sample
Mother Jones on Bottled Water Powered By Docstoc
					Mother Jones
Fiji Water: Spin the Bottle
By Anna Lenzer | Wed August 12, 2009 1:00 AM PST

THE INTERNET CAFÉ in the Fijian capital, Suva, was usually open all night long. Dimly lit, with rows
of sleek, modern terminals, the place was packed at all hours with teenage boys playing boisterous
rounds of video games. But one day soon after I arrived, the staff told me they now had to shut down
by 5 p.m. Police orders, they shrugged: The country's military junta had declared martial law a few
days before, and things were a bit tense.

I sat down and sent out a few emails—filling friends in on my visit to the Fiji Water bottling plant,
forwarding a story about foreign journalists being kicked off the island. Then my connection died. "It
will just be a few minutes," one of the clerks said.

Moments later, a pair of police officers walked in. They headed for a woman at another terminal; I
turned to my screen to compose a note about how cops were even showing up in the Internet cafés.
Then I saw them coming toward me. "We're going to take you in for questioning about the emails
you've been writing," they said.

What followed, in a windowless room at the main police station, felt like a bad cop movie. "Who are
you really?" the bespectacled inspector wearing a khaki uniform and a smug grin asked me over and
over, as if my passport, press credentials, and stacks of notes about Fiji Water weren't sufficient clues
to my identity. (My iPod, he surmised tensely, was "good for transmitting information.") I asked him
to call my editors, even a UN official who could vouch for me. "Shut up!" he snapped. He rifled
through my bags, read my notebooks and emails. "I'd hate to see a young lady like you go into a jail
full of men," he averred, smiling grimly. "You know what happened to women during the 2000 coup,
don't you?"

Eventually, it dawned on me that his concern wasn't just with my potentially seditious emails; he was
worried that my reporting would taint the Fiji Water brand. "Who do you work for, another water
company? It would be good to come here and try to take away Fiji Water's business, wouldn't it?"
Then he switched tacks and offered to protect me—from other Fijian officials, who he said would
soon be after me—by letting me go so I could leave the country. I walked out into the muggy
morning, hid in a stairwell, and called a Fijian friend. Within minutes, a US Embassy van was
speeding toward me on the seawall.

Until that day, I hadn't fully appreciated the paranoia of Fiji's military regime. The junta had been
declared unconstitutional the previous week by the country's second highest court; in response it
had abolished the judiciary, banned unauthorized public gatherings, delayed elections until 2014,
and clamped down on the media. (Only the "journalism of hope" is now permitted.) The prime
minister, Commodore Frank Bainimarama, promised to root out corruption and bring democracy to a
country that has seen four coups in the past 25 years; the government said it will start working on a
new constitution in 2012.

The slogan on Fiji Water's website—"And remember this—we saved you a trip to Fiji"—suddenly felt
like a dark joke. Every day, more soldiers showed up on the streets. When I called the courthouse, not
a single official would give me his name. Even tour guides were running scared—one told me that
one of his colleagues had been picked up and beaten for talking politics with tourists. When I later
asked Fiji Water spokesman Rob Six what the company thought of all this, he said the policy was not
to comment on the government "unless something really affects us."
Barack Obama

The Audacity of Branding
Seizing on the bottles' ubiquity, Tourism Fiji has taken to circulating a photo of President Obama at
an event featuring Fiji Water.
If you drink bottled water, you've probably drunk Fiji. Or wanted to. Even though it's shipped from
the opposite end of the globe, even though it retails for nearly three times as much as your basic
supermarket water, Fiji is now America's leading imported water, beating out Evian. It has spent
millions pushing not only the seemingly life-changing properties of the product itself, but also the
company's green cred and its charity work. Put all that together in an iconic bottle emblazoned with a
cheerful hibiscus, and everybody, from the Obamas to Paris and Nicole to Diddy and Kimora, is seen
sipping Fiji.

That's by design. Ever since a Canadian mining and real estate mogul named David Gilmour launched
Fiji Water in 1995, the company has positioned itself squarely at the nexus of pop-culture glamour
and progressive politics. Fiji Water's chief marketing whiz and co-owner (with her husband, Stewart)
is Lynda Resnick, a well-known liberal donor who casually name-drops her friends Arianna
Huffington and Laurie David. ("Of course I know everyone in the world," Resnick told the UK's
Observer in 2005, "every mogul, every movie star.") Manhattan's trendy Carlyle hotel pours only Fiji
Water in its dog bowls, and this year's SXSW music festival featured a Fiji Water Detox Spa. "Each
piece of lobster sashimi," celebrity chef Nobu Matsuhisa declared in 2007, "should be dipped into Fiji
Water seven to ten times."
Lynda Resnick

Drinking Buds
Fiji Water owner Lynda Resnick, pictured with Arianna Huffington, has aimed her brand squarely at
the nexus of glamour and green.

And even as bottled water has come under attack as the embodiment of waste, Fiji seems immune.
Fiji Water took out a full-page ad in Vanity Fair's 2007 green issue, nestled among stories about the
death of the world's water. Two bottles sat on a table between Al Gore and Mos Def during a 2006
MySpace "Artist on Artist" discussion on climate change. Fiji was what panelists sipped at the "Life
After Capitalism" conference held in New York City during the 2004 RNC protests; Fiji reps were
even credentialed at last year's Democratic convention, where they handed out tens of thousands of

Nowhere in Fiji Water's glossy marketing materials will you find reference to the typhoid outbreaks
that plague Fijians because of the island's faulty water supplies; the corporate entities that Fiji Water
has—despite the owners' talk of financial transparency—set up in tax havens like the Cayman
Islands and Luxembourg; or the fact that its signature bottle is made from Chinese plastic in a diesel-
fueled plant and hauled thousands of miles to its ecoconscious consumers. And, of course, you won't
find mention of the military junta for which Fiji Water is a major source of global recognition and
legitimacy. (Gilmour has described the square bottles as "little ambassadors" for the poverty-stricken

"We are Fiji," declare Fiji Water posters across the island, and the slogan is almost eerily accurate:
The reality of Fiji, the country, has been eclipsed by the glistening brand of Fiji, the water.

ON THE MAP, Fiji looks as if someone dropped a fistful of confetti on the ocean. The country is made
up of more than 300 islands (100 inhabited) that have provided the setting for everything from The
Blue Lagoon to Survivor to Cast Away. Suva is a bustling multicultural hub with a mix of shopping
centers, colonial buildings, and curry houses; some 40 percent of the population is of Indian ancestry,
descendants of indentured sugarcane workers brought in by the British in the mid-19th century.
(The Indian-descended and native communities have been wrangling for power ever since.) The
primary industries are tourism and sugar. Fiji Water says its operations make up about 20 percent of
exports and 3 percent of GDP, which stands at $3,900 per capita.

Getting to the Fiji Water factory requires a bone-jarring four-hour trek into the volcanic foothills of
the Yaqara Valley. My bus' speakers blasted an earsplitting soundtrack of Fijian reggae, Bob Marley,
Tupac, and Big Daddy Kane as we swerved up unpaved mountain roads linked by rickety wooden
bridges. Cow pastures ringed by palm trees gave way to villages of corrugated-metal shacks and
wooden homes painted in Technicolor hues. Chickens scurried past stands selling cell phone minutes.
Sugarcane stalks burning in the fields sent a sweet smoke curling into the air.

Our last rest stop, half an hour from the bottling plant, was Rakiraki, a small town with a square of
dusty shops and a marketplace advertising "Coffin Box for Sale—Cheapest in Town." My Lonely
Planet guide warned that Rakiraki water "has been deemed unfit for human consumption," and
groceries were stocked with Fiji Water going for 90 cents a pint—almost as much as it costs in the

Rakiraki has experienced the full range of Fiji's water problems—crumbling pipes, a lack of adequate
wells, dysfunctional or flooded water treatment plants, and droughts that are expected to get worse
with climate change. Half the country has at times relied on emergency water supplies, with rations
as low as four gallons a week per family; dirty water has led to outbreaks of typhoid and parasitic
infections. Patients have reportedly had to cart their own water to hospitals, and schoolchildren
complain about their pipes spewing shells, leaves, and frogs. Some Fijians have taken to smashing
open fire hydrants and bribing water truck drivers for a regular supply.

Suva, Fiji - Photo by Anna LuzerSuva, Fiji - Photo by Anna Lenzer

The bus dropped me off at a deserted intersection, where a weather-beaten sign warning off would-
be trespassers in English, Fijian, and Hindi rattled in the tropical wind. Once I reached the plant, the
bucolic quiet gave way to the hum of machinery spitting out some 50,000 square bottles (made on
the spot with plastic imported from China) per hour. The production process spreads across two
factory floors, blowing, filling, capping, labeling, and shrink-wrapping 24 hours a day, five days a
week. The company won't disclose its total sales; Fiji Water's vice president of corporate
communications told me the estimate of 180 million bottles sold in 2006, given in a legal declaration
by his boss, was wrong, but declined to provide a more solid number.

From here, the bottles are shipped to the four corners of the globe; the company—which, unlike most
of its competitors, offers detailed carbon-footprint estimates on its website—insists that they travel
on ships that would be making the trip anyway, and that the Fiji payload only causes them to use 2
percent more fuel. In 2007, Fiji Water announced that it planned to go carbon negative by offsetting
120 percent of emissions via conservation and energy projects starting in 2008. It has also promised
to reduce its pre-offset carbon footprint by 25 percent next year and to use 50 percent renewable
energy, in part by installing a windmill at the plant.

The offsetting effort has been the centerpiece of Fiji Water's $5 million "Fiji Green" marketing blitz,
which brazenly urges consumers to drink imported water to fight climate change. The Fiji Green
website claims that because of the 120-percent carbon offset, buying a big bottle of Fiji Water creates
the same carbon reduction as walking five blocks instead of driving. Former Senior VP of Sustainable
Growth Thomas Mooney noted in a 2007 Huffington Post blog post that "we'd be happy if anyone
chose to drink nothing but Fiji Water as a means to keep the sea levels down." (Metaphorically
speaking, anyway: As the online trade journal ClimateBiz has reported, Fiji is using a "forward
crediting" model under which it takes credit now for carbon reductions that will actually happen
over a few decades.)

Fiji Water has also vowed to use at least 20 percent less packaging by 2010—which shouldn't be too
difficult, given its bottle's above-average heft. (See "Territorial Waters.") The company says the
square shape makes Fiji Water more efficient in transport, and, hey, it looks great: Back in 2000, a top
official told a trade magazine that "What Fiji Water's done is go out there with a package that clearly
looks like it's worth more money, and we've gotten people to pay more for us."
Selling long-distance water to green consumers may be a contradiction in terms. But that hasn't
stopped Fiji from positioning its product not just as an indulgence, but as an outright necessity for an
elite that can appreciate its purity. As former Fiji Water CEO Doug Carlson once put it, "If you like
Velveeta cheese, processed water is okay for you." ("All waters are not created equal" is another
long-standing Fiji Water slogan.) The company has gone aggressively after its main competitor—tap
water—by calling it "not a real or viable alternative" that can contain "4,000 contaminants," unlike
Fiji's "living water." "You can no longer trust public or private water supplies," co-owner Lynda
Resnick wrote in her book, Rubies in the Orchard.

A few years back, Fiji Water canned its waterfall logo and replaced it with a picture of palm fronds
and hibiscus: "Surface water!" Resnick wrote in Rubies. "Why would you want to suggest that Fiji
came from surface water? The waterfall absolutely had to go." One company newsletter featured the
findings of a salt-crystal purveyor who claimed that Fiji Water rivals the "known and significant
abilities of 'Holy Healing Waters' in Lourdes, France or Fatima, Portugal." Switching effortlessly from
Catholic mysticism to sci-fi, he added that the water's "electromagnetic field frequency enables Fiji
Water to stimulate our human self-regulation system."

In keeping with this rarefied vibe, Fiji Water's marketing has focused on product placement more
than standard advertising; from appearances on The Sopranos, 24, The View, and Desperate
Housewives to sponsorship of events like the Emmy Awards, the Avon Walk for Breast Cancer, and
Justin Timberlake's "Summer Love" tour, it's now "hard to find an event where our target market is
present and Fiji isn't," according to Resnick. As far back as 2001, Movieline anointed it one of the
"Top 10 Things Young Hollywood Can't Get Through the Day Without." At the Academy Awards, E!
has handed out Fiji bottles to the stars; as it happens, the complex where the Oscars is held was
owned until 2004 by Fiji Water founder David Gilmour's real estate empire, Trizec (which before its
acquisition by Brookfield Properties in 2006 was one of the largest real estate companies in North
America, with projects including everything from the Sears Tower to Enron HQ).

In a 2003 interview, Gilmour told the London Times that "the world's water is being trashed day by
day." He would know: Before launching Fiji Water, he cofounded Barrick Gold, now the largest gold
mining enterprise in the world, with operations in hot spots from Tanzania to Pakistan. Its mines,
often in parched places like Nevada and Western Australia, use billions of gallons of water to produce
gold via a toxic cyanide leaching process. Barrick's practices are so damaging that after an
environmental review of the company, the Norwegian government announced last year that it would
divest itself of some $200 million in Barrick stock.

Gilmour was a powerful presence in Fiji long before he got into the water business. Back in 1969, he
launched what would become—with help from a couple of Saudi princes—the region's biggest hotel
chain, the Southern Pacific Hotel Corporation, which built a massive resort complex in Fiji. His
investors and advisers have included everyone from notorious arms trader Adnan Khashoggi to
George H.W. Bush; in 2004, Colin Powell presented him with the Secretary of State's Award for
Corporate Excellence for his work in Fiji. Gilmour's Fijian holdings include the exclusive Wakaya
resort, which boasts six staffers to each guest and has hosted Bill Gates, Nicole Kidman, and Keith
Richards (who famously fell off a tree there); he also owns Zinio, an electronic publishing company
that produces the digital version of Mother Jones magazine. He declined to be interviewed for this

In the early 1990s, Gilmour got wind of a study done by the Fijian government and aid organizations
that indicated an enormous aquifer, estimated at more than 17 miles long, near the main island's
north coast. He obtained a 99-year lease on land atop the aquifer, brought a former Fijian
environment minister on board, and launched an international marketing blitz inviting consumers to
sample water preserved since "before the Industrial Revolution." To this day, Fiji Water has nearly
exclusive access to the aquifer; the notoriously corrupt and chronically broke government has not
been able to come up with the money or infrastructure to tap the water for its people.
BY THE TIME Gilmour put Fiji Water up for sale in 2004, it was the fourth most popular imported
bottled water in the United States. He found eager buyers in the Resnicks, who made their fortune
with the flower delivery service Teleflora and the collectibles company Franklin Mint. The Beverly
Hills-based couple are also agribusiness billionaires whose holdings include enough almond,
pistachio, and pomegranate acreage to make them the biggest growers of those crops in the entire
Western Hemisphere; a 2004 report by the Environmental Working Group calculated that in 2002
alone, their agricultural water subsidies totaled more than $1.5 million. They own a pesticide
company, Suterra, and Lynda Resnick almost single-handedly created the pomegranate fad via their
Pom Wonderful brand.

Fiji Water wasn't the Resnicks' first foray into the water industry: Years ago, they gained control of
one of the largest underground water reservoirs in the nation, the Kern Water Bank on the edge of
California's Central Valley. This vast holding system—built with public funds in 1999 to help buffer
the effects of droughts—stores water from California's aqueducts and the Kern River; it's estimated
to be worth more than $180 million on the open market and has allowed the Resnicks to double their
acreage of fruits and nuts since 1994, according to the Los Angeles Times.

With the profits from their enterprises, the Resnicks have been major players on the political scene,
giving more than $300,000 each over the past decade. They have supported mostly marquee
Democrats—Obama, John Edwards, Hillary Clinton, Al Franken—though both also donated to the
McCain campaign. They give millions to museums, environmental organizations, and other charities:
Lynda is a trustee of the Aspen Institute, and Stewart is on the board of Conservation International.
One of Britney Spears' recent meltdowns led to her stay at the Stewart and Lynda Resnick
Neuropsychiatric Hospital at UCLA. In June, the California Institute of Technology announced the
creation of the Resnick Sustainability Institute after receiving a $20 million donation from the couple.
Fiji Water also gives to a range of conservation groups, including the Waterkeeper Alliance, Oceana,
the Nature Conservancy, and Heal the Bay.

The charitable works Fiji Water brags about most often, however, are its efforts in Fiji itself—from
preserving rainforests to helping fund water and sanitation projects to underwriting kindergartens.
This January, after catastrophic floods swept the main island of Viti Levu, the company also donated
$500,000 to the military regime for flood relief, and gave another $450,000 to various projects last
summer. True, some of Fiji Water's good works are more hope than reality: Though Lynda Resnick
insists that "we only use biofuels," the Fiji plant runs on diesel generators, and a project to protect
50,000 acres of rainforest—plugged on the actual bottle label—has yet to obtain a lease. Still, Resnick
told New York's WNYC last year, "We do so much for these sort of forgotten people. They live in
paradise, but they have a very, very hard life."

Fiji Water may be well advised to spread a bit of its wealth around locally. During the 2000 coup, a
small posse of villagers wielding spearguns and dynamite seized on the chaos to take over the
bottling plant and threaten to burn it down. "The land is sacred and central to our continued
existence and identity," a village spokesman told the Fiji Times, adding that "no Fijian should live off
the breadcrumbs of past colonial injustices." Two years later, the company created the Vatukaloko
Trust Fund, a charity targeting several villages surrounding its plant. It won't say how much it has
given to the trust, but court proceedings indicate that it has agreed to donate .15 percent of its Fijian
operation's net revenues; a company official testified that the total was about $100,000 in 2007. (For
perspective, the trade journal Brandweek put Fiji Water's marketing budget at $10 million in 2008; it
recently dropped $250,000 to become a founding partner of the new Salt Lake City soccer stadium.)

Perhaps mindful of the unpleasantness of 2000, today Fiji Water executives refer constantly to the
company's role in Fiji's economic life. "Our export revenue is paying for the expansion of water
access at a pace that Fiji's government has never achieved," the company told the BBC in 2008. "If we
did...cease to exist," sustainability VP Mooney told U.S. News & World Report the same year, "a big
chunk of the economy would be gone, the schools that we built would go away, and the water access
projects would go away."
What Mooney didn't say is that though Fiji Water may fill a void in the impoverished nation, it also
reaps a priceless benefit: tax-free status, granted when the company was founded in 1995. The
rationale at the time, according to the company: Bottled water was a risky business with uncertain
chances of success. In 2003, David Gilmour said that his ambition for Fiji Water was "to become the
biggest taxpayer in the country." Yet the tax break, originally scheduled to expire in 2008, remains in
effect, and neither the company nor the government will say whether or when it might end. And
when Fiji has tried to wring a bit of extra revenue from the company, the response has been less than
cooperative. Last year, when the government attempted to impose a new tax on water bottlers, Fiji
Water called it "draconian" (a term it's never used for the regime's human rights violations) and
temporarily shut down its plant in protest.

While Lynda Resnick has called for "very public conduct" by private companies, she seems to
appreciate that, as she wrote in her book, "transparency is a lot easier to talk about than it is to
realize." The closely held company won't disclose basic data about its business (such as total charity
expenditures), and it's gone to some length to shelter assets in secretive tax havens: The Fijian
operation, according to court documents filed last year, is owned by an entity in Luxembourg, while
its American trademarks are registered to an address in the Cayman Islands.

At the moment, Fiji's government certainly seems in no mood to confront Fiji Water—quite the
contrary. "Learning from the lessons of products, we must brand ourselves," Fiji's ambassador in
Washington told a news site for diplomats in 2006, adding that he was working with the Resnicks to
try to increase Fiji Water's US sales. A Fiji Water bottle sits at the top of the embassy's home page,
and the government has even created a Fiji Water postage-stamp series—the $3 stamp features
children clutching the trademark bottles.

Fiji Water, for its part, has trademarked the word "FIJI" (in capital letters) in numerous countries.
(Some rejected the application, but not the United States.) It has also gone after rival Fijian bottlers
daring to use their country's name for marketing. "It would have cost too much money for us to fight
in court," says Mohammed Altaaf, the owner of Aqua Pacific water, which ended up taking the word
"Fiji" out of its name. "It's just like branding a water America Water and denying anyone else the
right to use the name 'America.'"

When such practices are criticized, Fiji Water's response is simple: "They don't have a ton of options
for economic development," Mooney told U.S. News & World Report, "but bottled water is one of
them. When someone buys a bottle of Fiji, they're buying prosperity for the country." Without Fiji
Water, he said, "Fiji is kind of screwed."

Shared By: