VINTAGES
CLASSICS
COLLECTION
FINE WINE &
PREMIUM SPIRITS
MAY 2010
May 2010
CLASSICS
COLLECTION
IN THIS ISSUE
In the May 2010 Classics Collection we take you
first to the right bank—the right bank of Chablis’
Serein River, that is. With its precious kimmeridgian
soil and southwest-facing slopes, the right bank
is responsible for some of the most extraordinary
expressions of Chablis’ unique terroir. Inside
you’ll find a select group of top-flight Chablis.
Beyond Chablis, our European portfolio is wall to wall
gems: there is an impressive selection of power-
house Bordeaux from the 2005 and 2006 vintages,
including some large-format bottlings; a rare
Hermitage Blanc from Guigal; lovely Champagnes
from the houses of Deutz, Guy Charlemagne and
others; top-scoring Châteauneuf-du-Papes; formidable
The VINTAGES Classics Collection offers the highest Barolos and Barbarescos from 2004 and 2005; the
quality in fine wines and premium spirits from the latest from Veneto’s Quintarelli; plus so much more.
best producers and regions in the world. For each
edition, VINTAGES’ buyers seek out products that meet Our New World selections feature big names from
our rigorous standards of excellence. Be they Grand California like Shafer, Rubicon, and Chappellet.
Crus from Burgundy or stellar vintages from the top Australian royalty is on the bill, too, with wines from
châteaux of Bordeaux, Italian masterpieces or the Clarendon Hills, Henschke, and Mitolo. Leading
finest wines of California and Australia, you will find Argentine producer Catena Zapata supplies a trio of
variety, quality and excellence in the Classics Collection. stunning Malbecs, and one of the brightest stars
in Chile’s wine firmament—Altaïr—is also on offer.
Front Cover: Precious fruit from an old vine
in the much-celebrated Les Clos grand VINTAGES invites you to read on as there are
cru of Chablis. surprises at every turn of the page.
Inside Front Cover: The vineyards of Chablis’
Montée de Tonnerre form a lush backdrop
for the church of Saint-Pierre.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
FEATURE
4 CHABLIS
TASTING NOTES
FEATURE PRODUCTS
7 FRANCE:
Burgundy – Chablis
10 FRANCE:
Bordeaux, Burgundy, Rhône, Alsace,
Champagne, Midi
24 ITALY:
Abruzzo, Campania, Friuli, Piedmont,
Sicily, Tuscany, Veneto
33 PORTUGAL FAX AND MAIL ORDERING DEADLINE –
6:00 pm, Tuesday, May 11, 2010
34 SPAIN
VINTAGE CHART
35 AUSTRALIA The Vintage Chart is available on our website at:
37 SOUTH AFRICA www.vintages.com/circular/vintage-chart.html
37 ARGENTINA VINTAGES LOCATIONS
For a complete list of VINTAGES locations visit our
38 CHILE website: www.vintages.com/frame_stores.html
38 USA: IMPORTANT
California For each Classics Collection, we do our best to
secure enough stock to satisfy all customer orders.
40 FORTIFIED WINE: We regret that sometimes customer demand
Port may exceed supply. For opening quantities of
Classics Collection products, go to page 41 or
www.vintages.com/classics/1/201005_
41 PRODUCT SUMMARY ProductSummary_EN.pdf
ORDERING INFORMATION
51 HOW TO ORDER
52 ORDER FORM
2 VINTAGES
A local vineyard worker brings in the
harvest. Opposite: The vineyards of
Chablis are riddled with fossilized oyster
shells—little reminders that this
land was a seabed eons ago.
ON THE RIGHT BANK
WITH CHABLIS
Chablis is one of the world’s most original, distinctive, and electrifying
expressions of the Chardonnay grape. For all who know le vrai Chablis, there is nothing
quite like it. With its arrestingly pure chalky-minerality—as if mined from the
depths of the earth—vivid acidity, hallmark gunflint flavours, lovely richness, and profound
cellarability, Chablis is a wonder. If you have never tasted one of Chablis’ finest, then
you may not fully appreciate why collectors and connoisseurs hunt down these wines
with such passion and zeal.
One must journey to the heartland of Chablis to grasp its allure. It is on the right bank
of the gently flowing Serein River that the best of Chablis is born. (Much like the
Bordelais, local winemakers speak of vineyards on the left and right bank of their river.)
Here, in the northernmost reaches of Burgundy—where sunlight is at a premium
and long winters and spring frosts put viticulture on a knife edge—location is everything.
Richly laden with kimmeridgian soil (a mix of limestone, clay, and countless tiny
marine fossils) and blessed with ideal southwest exposure, the vineyards here yield the
most stunning and authentic expressions of Chablis’ unique terroir.
The kings of the right bank—the region’s seven grand crus— sit elbow to elbow on one
hillside, just north of the sleepy village that gives its name to the wine and region.
They are the gold standard. Two of the top premier crus—Fourchaume and Montée de
Tonnerre —bookend the grand crus to the north and south. They, too, lie on southwest-
facing slopes, basking in every ounce of available sunlight. Not surprisingly, Fourchaume
and Tonnerre produce the highest quality and, in blind tastings, are often mistaken
for grand crus.
We invite you to join us on the right bank to explore a very select group of wines from
leading producers and classic vintages.
4 VINTAGES
The seven grand crus of Chablis cling
to one prized hill on the right bank of the
Serein River; they are the cream of
the crop, representing a mere 2% of
total Chablis production.
Cosmos grow wild all over the Chablis
region. Clockwise: Harvest time in
the Fourchaume vineyard; A bounty of
Chardonnay grapes; Smudge pots
(a.k.a. chaufferettes) are a traditional
tool used to combat spring frosts;
by warming the vines when temperatures
plummet, the vulnerable first shoots
of the growing season are protected.
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
FEATURE PRODUCTS
FRANCE – BURGUNDY DOMAINE CHRISTIAN MOREAU JEAN-CLAUDE BESSIN
PÈRE & FILS VALMUR CHABLIS LA FOURCHAUME CHABLIS
GRAND CRU 2007 1er CRU 2007
WHITE WINE AC AC
TASTING NOTE: The expressive nose TASTING NOTE: This is also cool and
DOMAINE CHRISTIAN MOREAU screams Chablis and blind, it would reticent with beautiful green fruit, salt
PÈRE & FILS LES CLOS CHABLIS be virtually impossible to mistake this water, iodine and algae notes that are
GRAND CRU 2007 for anything else as the aromas are followed by flavors that are rich, full
AC spot on classic with the green fruit, and more powerful than usual as the
TASTING NOTE: This is perhaps the tidal pool, iodine and salty character, taut muscularity of the very dry finish
most aromatically elegant wine in all of which are also reflected by the accentuates this impression. There is
the range today with its airy, pure and extremely fresh and at this point, also excellent focus and cut and this is
layered nose of white flower, lemon still completely primary flavors that are the best wine to this point. Outstanding.
peel, hint of wood spice, white peach nicely rich and full yet retain a fine Drink [from] 2013+. Score: 91. (Allen
and oyster shell nuances that seem sense of underlying detail that is sup- Meadows, www.burghound.com,
even stronger on the impressively scaled ported by a firm acid spine on the Oct. 2009)
broad-shouldered flavors that possess understated, driving and impeccably
a beguiling texture as well as an almost balanced finish. Don’t miss! Drink 43497 [XD] 750 mL $32
painfully intense, palate staining finish [from] 2013+. Score: 91-94. (Allen
that is bone dry. In a word, gorgeous. Meadows, www.burghound.com,
Don’t miss! Drink [from] 2013+. Oct. 2008) JEAN-CLAUDE BESSIN
Score: 93. (Allen Meadows, www.bur- LA FOURCHAUME LA PIÈCE AU
ghound.com, Oct. 2008) 641944 [XD] 750 mL $59 COMTE CHABLIS 1er CRU 2007
AC
168658 [XD] 750 mL $65 TASTING NOTE: Here the wood is
DOMAINE LOUIS MICHEL & FILS subtle if not invisible and highlights
VAUDÉSIR CHABLIS GRAND CRU an elegant nose with more overall
2007 aromatic depth as well as a lovely mix
AC of sea breeze, iodine and ripe green
TASTING NOTE: Fresh lemon, orange fruit that complements the minerally,
blossom, iris, and narcissus in the detailed and superbly intense flavors
nose of Michel’s 2007 Chablis Vaudesir that possess impressive vibrancy and
lead to an alluringly floral-tinged, the best length of any wine to this point.
glossy, and (for this collection) quite Very promising and recommended.
rich palate. Subtle but insistent chalky, Outstanding. Drink [from] 2013+.
alkaline, and saline notes add to the Score: 92. (Allen Meadows, www.bu-
already existing counterpoint of bright rghound.com, Oct. 2009)
citrus and rich texture, and inform a
finish of refined persistence and rapier 167452 [XD] 750 mL $35
penetration that one does not expect
from a grand cru. I suspect that this
will be worth holding for 10-12 years.
Score: (92-93). (David Schildknecht,
www.erobertparker.com, Dec. 2009)
172569 [XD] 750 mL $65
VINTAGES 7
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
FEATURE PRODUCTS
FRANCE – BURGUNDY LA CHABLISIENNE MONTÉE DE LA CHABLISIENNE BLANCHOT
TONNERRE CHABLIS 1er CRU 2007 CHABLIS GRAND CRU 2006
AC AC
WHITE WINE A Gold Medal winner at the 2009 A Gold Medal winner at the 2009
Concours Général Agricole in Paris. Concours Général Agricole in Paris.
JEAN-CLAUDE BESSIN VALMUR
CHABLIS GRAND CRU 2007 TASTING NOTE: A cool mix of citrus TASTING NOTE: Noticeable wood sets
AC and green fruit aromas is trimmed in off pure if exotic ripe and fresh fruit
TASTING NOTE: An equally discreet now relatively discreet wood though aromas that complement well the rich,
touch of wood sets off pure, refined here the flavors are more obviously powerful, full and naturally sweet
and airy sea weed, saline and green concentrated and powerful with a bit flavors that possess excellent concen-
fruit aromas that display background more size and weight as well while tration and fine minerality, all wrapped
hints of acacia that are also picked up culminating in an intense, minerally in a finish where a touch of wood
by the rich, full and classy medium- and energetic finish. Probably due resurfaces. This is not entirely typical
bodied flavors that offer the best depth to the hail that hit the vineyard, this is but there is enough saline and
and intensity of the entire range, all one of the densest ‘07s in the range if minerality on the finish to hint at the
wrapped in an explosive finish. Terrific far from the most elegant. Outstanding. Chablis origins but overall, this is
and as usual, this is worth searching Drink [from] 2013+. Score: 91. delicious white wine. Drink [from]
for as it’s a wine of finesse but with (Allen Meadows, www.burghound.com, 2012+. Score: 92. (Allen Meadows,
plenty of drive. Drink [from] 2014+. Oct. 2009) www.burghound.com, Oct. 2008)
Score: 93. (Allen Meadows, www.bu-
rghound.com, Oct. 2009) 163303 [XD] 750 mL $34 581686 [XD] 750 mL $59
43513 [XD] 750 mL $55
CAVES DUPLESSIS MONTÉE DE CAVES DUPLESSIS LES CLOS
TONNERRE CHABLIS 1er CRU 2006 CHABLIS GRAND CRU 2005
AC AC
(Gérard & Lilian Duplessis, Vitic.) (Gérard & Lilian Duplessis, Vitic.)
TASTING NOTE: A slightly troubled TASTING NOTE: Here the nose is
nose of lactic and reductive aromas reserved and tight and while glimpses
mostly block the nose though there are of how fine this really is can be dis-
background hints of pretty white flower cerned, it takes some real swirling to
notes with rich, powerful and intense coax much from it. By contrast, the
flavors that possess excellent size and flavors are big, powerful and intense
weight on the sappy and mouth coating yet refined with buckets of Chablis
finish that is impressively persistent. character, in particular oyster shell, all
This should offer 4 to 5 years of upside. wrapped in an austere and racy finish
Outstanding. Drink [from] 2010+. supported by a taut core of ripe acidity.
Score: 89-91. (Allen Meadows, Very impressive. Drink [from] 2010+.
www.burghound.com, Oct. 2007) Score: 90-92. (Allen Meadows,
www.burghound.com, Oct. 2006)
168120 [XD] 750 mL $33
168104 [XD] 750 mL $59
8 VINTAGES
A charming weather-worn townhouse on the Quai
Voltaire, in the heart of the village of Chablis,
hints at the climatic challenges faced here.
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
FRANCE – BORDEAUX CHÂTEAU CLOS FOURTET 2006 CHÂTEAU DUHART-MILON-
AC St-Émilion, 1er Grand Cru ROTHSCHILD 2006
Classé (B) AC Pauillac, 4e Cru
RED WINE TASTING NOTE: A blend of 80% Merlot TASTING NOTE: It is no longer an
and the rest equally split between insider’s secret that the investments
CHÂTEAU BELLEVUE 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon and Cabernet made by the Rothschild family (of
AC St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé Franc, this wine has a dense purple Lafite) in Duhart Milon are paying big
TASTING NOTE: Dark but lively color and a beautifully sweet nose of dividends. A shrewd Pauillac lover’s
crimson. Enclave in Pavie Decesse. blackberry and blueberry fruits inter- delight, it possesses exceptional quality,
Just slight overripeness on the nose mixed with acacia flowers, charcoal, yet the price remains fair. This blend
but lovely texture – very supple and and some subtle oak. The wine is of 70% Cabernet Sauvignon and
with macerated mulberry character nicely textured, medium-bodied, and 30% Merlot, only 50% made it into the
Opulent texture. Tarmacadam – very very concentrated for a 2006 St.-Emilion, final blend, displays some of Lafite’s
exotic – some freshness this year – with a certain degree of opulence classic notes of lead pencil shavings,
much more approachable than most and sucrosite. This is a beauty, with cedar, and black currants along with
vintages because of the lift on the moderate tannins in the finish. more earthy, roasted herb, and spice
finish. Quite a hot finish. Drink 2017- Anticipated maturity: 2013-2027. box characteristics. Rich, full-bodied,
2030. Score: 17 (out of 20). (Jancis If you haven’t gotten on the Clos dense, and already approachable,
Robinson, MW, www.jancisrobins- Fourtet bandwagon, now is the time, it should evolve easily for two decades.
on.com, Aug. 7, 2007) as demand will certainly increase. Good value. Score: 92. (Robert
Score: 91. (Robert Parker Jr., www.ero- Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com,
564435 [XD] 750 mL $75 bertparker.com, Feb. 2009) Feb. 2009)
563775 [XD] 750 mL $85 564351 [XD] 750 mL $62
CHÂTEAU CLINET 2006
AC Pomerol
TASTING NOTE: Extremely backward, CHÂTEAU DE SALES 2006 CHÂTEAU FIGEAC 2006
firm, and virile, this macho wine AC Pomerol AC St-Émilion, 1er Grand Cru
exhibits full-bodied power, a dense TASTING NOTE: A medium-bodied Classé (B)
blackberry, smoky nose, huge tannins, red, with chocolate, coffee and berry TASTING NOTE: Blackberry, blueberry
but impressive stuffing and depth. character on the nose and palate. and plum aromas, with hints of sweet
This is not for the faint of heart, and also Medium and pretty. A little simple, but tobacco. Full-bodied, with chewy tannins
not for those who need immediate attractive. Best after 2010. Score: 87. and a mineral, currant and licorice
drinkability. Anticipated maturity: 2014- (James Suckling, www.winespecta- aftertaste. A little austere, but structured.
2027. Score: 90+. (Robert Parker Jr., tor.com, March 31, 2009) Dense. Impressive. Best after 2014.
www.erobertparker.com, Feb. 2009) Score: 91. (James Suckling, www.win-
565424 [XD] 750 mL $34 espectator.com, March 31, 2009)
564575 [XD] 750 mL $99
566257 [XD] 750 mL $129
10 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
CHÂTEAU GAZIN 2006 CHÂTEAU LA SERRE 2006 CHÂTEAU L’ÉVANGILE 2006
AC Pomerol AC St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé AC Pomerol
TASTING NOTE: Complex aromas of TASTING NOTE: Mid bright crimson. TASTING NOTE: The sexy, dark ruby/
green coffee bean, tarragon and black- Fresh quite simple redcurrant flavours purple-tinged 2006 l’Evangile achieved
berry, turning to licorice and violet. Full- on the nose. Relatively lightweight but 14% natural alcohol, as high as any
bodied, with ultrafine tannins and very fresh and balanced and juicy. Like of the great vintages at this estate.
beautiful fruit. Very balanced and refined a fruit exploding in the mouth. Neat Abundant amounts of dark raspberry
for the vintage. Exceptional for this but quite pronounced acidity. Drink and black cherry fruit intertwined
estate. A real beauty. Best after 2014. 2011-2018. Score: 16+ (out of 20). with sweet plums and hints of figs as
Score: 93. (James Suckling, www.wi- (Jancis Robinson, MW, www.jancisro- well as spring flowers jump from the
nespectator.com, March 31, 2009) binson.com, Aug. 8, 2007) glass of this medium to full-bodied,
fleshy, supple-textured, silky wine.
565309 [XD] 750 mL $84 565325 [XD] 750 mL $52 Drink it now or cellar it for 15-20 years.
Score: 93. (Robert Parker Jr.,
www.erobertparker.com, Feb. 2009)
CHÂTEAU LA MISSION HAUT- CHÂTEAU LANGOA-BARTON 2006
BRION 2006 AC St-Julien, 3e Cru 564682 [XD] 750 mL $245
AC Pessac-Léognan, Cru Classé TASTING NOTE: Shows violet and
TASTING NOTE: One of the vintage’s blackberry, with hints of raisin. Full and
top wines is the 2006 La Mission- velvety, with lovely-textured tannins CHÂTEAU LUCIA 2006
Haut-Brion. From bottle, it reminds me and plenty of ripe fruit on the finish. AC St-Émilion Grand Cru
of the 1998, given its structure and Balanced and rich. Best after 2013. TASTING NOTE: Extraordinary
backward style. Dense ruby/purple- Score: 91. (James Suckling, www.wi- [Stéphane] Derenoncourt wine which
colored, it possesses a boatload of nespectator.com, March 31, 2009) tastes more like a burgundy than a
tannin, but with coaxing, tobacco leaf, bordeaux and therefore stands out in
sweet black currant, burning ember, 563726 [XD] 750 mL $79 the right bank crowd. Open topped
and blue fruit characteristics emerge. fermenters apparently and pretty much
While thick and full-bodied, the tannins made like a red burgundy. Very
seem more elevated than I remember rich, opulent, sweet perfumed nose.
from barrel. It is going to be a beauty, Charming floral notes. Pretty marked
but like many of the top 2006s, con- oak influence on the finish but great
siderable patience is required. Only charm on the front palate. Very distinc-
55% of the production made it into tive! Tempting to give it an even higher
the grand vin as Jean-Philippe Delmas mark for offering such novelty. Drink
made a severe selection. The final blend 2012-2018. Score: 17 (out of 20).
was 60% Merlot and 40% Cabernet (Jancis Robinson, MW, www.jancisro-
Sauvignon, and the 2006 has one binson.com, Aug. 8, 2007)
of the highest natural alcohols ever
achieved at La Mission, averaging 563742 [XD] 750 mL $68
around 14.3%, which is astonishingly
high for a Graves. Anticipated maturity:
2018-2035. Score: 95. (Robert
Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com,
Feb. 2009)
567164 [XD] 750 mL $799
VINTAGES 11
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
FRANCE – BORDEAUX CHÂTEAU ANGÉLUS 2005 CHÂTEAU BEAU-SÉJOUR BÉCOT
AC St-Émilion, 2005
1er Grand Cru Classé (B) AC St-Émilion,
RED WINE TASTING NOTE: This 7,000 case blend 1er Grand Cru Classé (B)
of 60% Merlot and 40% Cabernet TASTING NOTE: The bottled 2005
CHÂTEAU RAUZAN-SÉGLA 2006 Franc will rival or perhaps eclipse Beau Sejour Becot confirms that this
AC Margaux, 2e Cru vintages such as 2000, 1998, 1990, is the finest effort from this estate in
TASTING NOTE: On the same quali- and 1989. Its dense purple color is the thirty years I have been covering
tative level as this estate’s brilliant followed by an extraordinary perfume Bordeaux. A classic blend of
2005, but with slightly less sucrosite, of charcoal, espresso roast, black- 70% Merlot, 24% Cabernet Franc,
this blend of 53% Cabernet Sauvignon, berries, blueberries, and a hint of and 6% Cabernet Sauvignon, it
44% Merlot, and the rest Petit Verdot, wood. In spite of its thick texture, terrific is an intense, full-bodied St.-Emilion
exhibits a 1986-like personality, a very acidity, high tannins, and enormous revealing notes of espresso roast,
successful vintage at Rauzan Segla. intensity as well as richness, it is sur- chocolate, blackberries, licorice, and
Its deep ruby/purple hue is accompa- prisingly approachable, but given truffles. With sweet but noticeable
nied by sweet aromas of bay leaf, how slowly the 1989 and 1990 have tannins, good acidity, and a powerful,
black currants, licorice, truffles, and aged, I would recommend cellaring it long finish, this textbook St.-Emilion
a touch of toast, dazzling fruit, and for 8-10 years. It should keep for three cuts a swath between the modern
plenty of ripe, but not astringent tannin. decades. A brilliant wine. Score: 98. school of winemaking and the tradi-
This is a medium to full-bodied, (Robert Parker Jr., www.erobertpark- tionalists. Anticipated maturity: 2015-
classic, pure, surprisingly approach- er.com, April 2008) 2030+. Score: 94. (Robert Parker Jr.,
able Rauzan Segla that will be at its www.erobertparker.com, April 2008)
finest between 2012-2025+. Score: 93. 506071 [XD] 750 mL $450
(Robert Parker Jr., www.erobertpa- 510545 [XD] 1500 mL $950 689174 [XD] 1500 mL $279
rker.com, Feb. 2009)
564070 [XD] 750 mL $104 CHÂTEAU CERTAN-MARZELLE 2005
AC Pomerol
TASTING NOTE: This plump, fleshy,
seductive, 100% Merlot cuvee from
Christian Moueix exhibits herbal, sweet
plum, cherry, and mocha notes along
with supple tannin and decent acidity,
but little depth and richness. It is a
charming, sensual Pomerol to enjoy
over the next decade. Score: 89.
(Robert Parker Jr., www.erobertpark-
er.com, April 2008)
501239 [XD] 750 mL $79
12 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
CHÂTEAU CLARKE 2005 CHÂTEAU CROIX DE LABRIE 2005 CHÂTEAU DU TERTRE 2005
AC Listrac AC St-Émilion Grand Cru AC Margaux, 5e Cru
Robert Parker Jr. awarded this wine TASTING NOTE: As most vintages of TASTING NOTE: Even in the highly
a score of 90-92. Due to space limi- this small garagiste estate tend to be, acclaimed 2005 vintage, Du Tertre
tations, no tasting note was provided. the 2005 Croix de Labrie is truly sump- remains under most consumer’s
(www.erobertparker.com, April 2006) tuous stuff. Made from 100% Merlot radar. Made by essentially the same
(only 300 cases produced), it pos- winemaking team as Giscours, this
TASTING NOTE: Dark ruby in color, sesses an inky/purple color to the rim cuvee exhibits a dense purple color,
with licorice, black coffee and ripe as well as a nose that smells like followed by earthy, truffle, smoky
berry. Full-bodied, with velvety tannins blueberry and blackberry ice cream blackberry, floral, and cassis aromas.
and mineral and berry flavors. Has infused with floral, wood, and espresso It is a beautifully pure, medium to
a lovely texture and bright acidity. A scents. Superb intensity and purity as full-bodied wine with abundant but
little disjointed now, but lots going on. well as an exotic, ostentatious per- sweet tannin, fine opulence, a multi-
Best after 2011. Score: 89. (James sonality are impossible to resist. Not layered texture, and a long finish that
Suckling, www.winespectator.com, a classic claret, it is the antithesis is neither aggressive nor astringent.
March 31, 2008) of the aristocratic, noble Medocs, but Cellar it for another 3-4 years, and
what a ride it provides. Enjoy it over consume it over the following 20-25.
510529 [XD] 1500 mL $79 the next 10-15 years. Score: 94. (Robert Score: 90. (Robert Parker Jr., www.ero-
Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com, bertparker.com, April 2008)
April 2008)
CHÂTEAU CÔTE DE BALEAU 2005 502831 [XD] 750 mL $83
AC St-Émilion Grand Cru 501726 [XD] 750 mL $128
TASTING NOTE: Aromas of black-
berry, licorice and smoke follow
through to a medium-bodied palate,
with soft tannins and a fruity finish.
Best after 2011. Score: 89. (James
Suckling, www.winespectator.com,
March 31, 2008)
689810 [XD] 1500 mL $79
VINTAGES 13
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
FRANCE – BORDEAUX CHÂTEAU GRAND-PUY-LACOSTE CHÂTEAU HAUT-BAILLY 2005
2005 AC Pessac-Léognan, Cru Classé
AC Pauillac, 5e Cru TASTING NOTE: Haut-Bailly’s
RED WINE TASTING NOTE: The brilliant 2005 American proprietor, Robert Wilmers,
Grand-Puy-Lacoste exhibits classic backed up by the brilliant Veronique
CHÂTEAU DUCRU-BEAUCAILLOU Pauillac aromas and flavors of creme Sanders, continues to go from strength
2005 de cassis along with stony/floral to strength. A fabulous example of
AC St-Julien, 2e Cru notes. Proprietor Xavier Borie has this estate, the 2005 is an ethereal,
TASTING NOTE: ... It is an excep- created a wine that should rival the delicate, finesse-styled offering with
tionally powerful wine with a dense brilliant 1982, 1990, 1996, and intensity as well as richness. It has all
purple color, superb intensity, and a 2000. Full-bodied with sweet tannin the concentration one could want, but
beautiful, sweet nose of spring flowers, and superb length (a 40+ second it comes across as gorgeously elegant
raspberries, blueberries, graphite, and finish), the purity of this beauty’s black and sublime because of its combina-
creme de cassis. Full-bodied with fab- currant fruit is something to behold. tion of delicacy, power, and depth.
ulous concentration, exceptionally Anticipated maturity: 2013-2030. Beautiful raspberry, black cherry, cur-
high tannin, good acidity, and massive Score: 95. (Robert Parker Jr., www.er- rant, graphite, and scorched earth
layers of richness that build incremen- obertparker.com, April 2008) notes are subtle, but provocative. In the
tally on the palate, this monumental mouth, there is good acidity, medium
effort is more structured than their 689349 [XD] 1500 mL $265 body, ripe tannin, and terrific length.
outstanding 2003. It may be the finest This is a beauty of haute couture from
wine produced at this estate since the Pessac-Leognan. Anticipated maturity:
1982 and 1961 Ducrus. Anticipated CHÂTEAU GRUAUD-LAROSE 2005 2015-2035. Score: 95. (Robert
maturity: 2018-2050. Score: 97. AC St-Julien, 2e Cru Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com,
(Robert Parker Jr., www.erobertpark- TASTING NOTE: This tastes of great April 2008)
er.com, April 2008) Cabernet Sauvignon, with its black
currant, cedar and herbs and fresh, 689364 [XD] 1500 mL $365
689471 [XD] 1500 mL $649 juicy acidity. It is as fresh as it is rich,
but it has a structure of dense tannins
that balances the wine. This is one CHÂTEAU LA COUSPAUDE 2005
of the best wines from Gruaud-Larose AC St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé
for several years. Score: 94. (Roger TASTING NOTE: Very concentrated,
Voss, Wine Enthusiast, June 2008) with blackberry, coffee bean and
vanilla. Full-bodied, with lots of pretty
502567 [XD] 750 mL $95 fruit, velvety tannins and a long, rich
689232 [XD] 1500 mL $195 finish. Slightly pushed, but this should
come together with bottle age. A
powerful young red. Best after 2013.
Score: 92. (James Suckling, www.wi-
nespectator.com, March 31, 2008)
504902 [XD] 750 mL $108
14 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
CHÂTEAU LA PROVIDENCE 2005 CHÂTEAU LE GAY 2005 CHÂTEAU MONBOUSQUET 2005
AC Pomerol AC Pomerol AC St-Émilion Grand Cru
TASTING NOTE: Beautiful aromas TASTING NOTE: The finest Le Gay pro- TASTING NOTE: From a less than noble
of crushed berry, chocolate and duced since the post World War II era, terroir in Saint-Sulpice de Faleyrens,
licorice, with hints of toasty oak, follow the 2005 even eclipses the fabulous Gerard Perse has accomplished
through to a full-bodied palate, with 1982 and 1989. This inky/purple-hued miraculous things at Monbousquet.
velvety tannins and a rich, wonderful effort reflects the commitment of pro- Prior to his acquisition of this property
finish. This is generous and balanced. prietress Catherine Pere-Verge. An in the mid-nineties, this wine tasted
Best after 2017. Score: 95. (James extraordinary perfume of blueberries, like watered-down Beaujolais, but Perse
Suckling, www.winespectator.com, blackberries, flowers, truffles, and a has turned it into one of the more
March 31, 2008) touch of steely minerality is followed stunning, modern-styled wines of
by a massive wine of exceptional con- Bordeaux. A blend of approximately
501262 [XD] 750 mL $135 centration, a multilayered texture, two-thirds Merlot, one-third Cabernet
phenomenal purity, and a finish that Franc and 8-10% Cabernet Sauvignon,
lasts for nearly a minute. It is a mas- the 2005 exhibits plenty of toasty
CHÂTEAU LAFON-ROCHET 2005 sive, old style, pure, rich Pomerol that oak, roasted herb, meat juice, black-
AC St-Estèphe, 4e Cru should only be purchased by patient berry, cherry, and spice characteristics
TASTING NOTE: Has notes of black- connoisseurs as gratification will need along with a touch of incense. Full-
berry, with Indian spices and green to be deferred for at least a decade. bodied and opulent, with an atypically
tea. Full-bodied, with velvety tannins, Anticipated maturity: 2018-2040+. rigid structure, this is a remarkable
a silky texture and a medium finish. Score: 95+. (Robert Parker Jr., achievement for such a humble terroir.
Balanced and very refined. A beautiful www.erobertparker.com, April 2008) It admirably reflects Gerard Perse’s
young wine. Best after 2011. Score: 90. obsessive commitment to excellence.
(James Suckling, www.winespecta- 502229 [XD] 750 mL $198 Look for this 2005 to hit its stride in
tor.com, March 31, 2008) 7-8 years, and last for 15-20. Score: 95.
(Robert Parker Jr., www.erobertpark-
689265 [XD] 1500 mL $145 CHÂTEAU LÉOVILLE BARTON 2005 er.com, April 2008)
AC St-Julien, 2e Cru
TASTING NOTE: Delivers breathtaking 689455 [XD] 1500 mL $195
aromas of blackberry, currant, licorice
and flowers. Full-bodied, with a solid
core of fruit and supersilky tannins. Dark
chocolate, currant, berry and licorice
follow through. This is racy and beauti-
ful. Best after 2015. Score: 96.
(James Suckling, www.winespecta-
tor.com, March 31, 2008)
567693 [XD] 750 mL $309
VINTAGES 15
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
FRANCE – BORDEAUX CHÂTEAU PALMER 2005 CHÂTEAU PICHON-LONGUEVILLE
AC Margaux, 3e Cru COMTESSE DE LALANDE 2005
TASTING NOTE: This spectacular AC Pauillac, 2e Cru
RED WINE offering should continue to improve, TASTING NOTE: Beautiful currant,
and may merit an even higher score berry and licorice aromas follow
CHÂTEAU MOULIN-ST-GEORGES after additional aging. Stunningly rich through to a full body, with tar and
2005 and powerful, the dark purple-tinged berry character, fine tannins and
AC St-Émilion Grand Cru 2005 Palmer is a blend of 53% Caber- a long finish. I was expecting a little
TASTING NOTE: Deep, dark ruby in net Sauvignon, 40% Merlot, and more from this, but it’s still out-
color. Superconcentrated aromas 7% Petit Verdot. Aromas of incense, standing. Best after 2013. Score: 93.
of crushed blackberry, black licorice, burning embers, black currants, (James Suckling, www.winespecta-
espresso and leather follow through plums, licorice, and flowers are followed tor.com, March 31, 2008)
to a full body, with ultrafine tannins and by a full-bodied Margaux with more
loads of coffee and fruit flavors. Very weight and power even than its nearby 504068 [XD] 750 mL $215
long. Best after 2016. Score: 92. first-growth rival, Chateau Margaux.
(James Suckling, www.winespecta- The abundant acidity and tannins are
tor.com, March 31, 2008) beautifully coated by the wine’s excep- CHÂTEAU PICHON-LONGUEVILLE-
tional fruit extract and overall harmony BARON 2005
510602 [XD] 1500 mL $184 and richness. It is so concentrated AC Pauillac, 2e Cru
that one is hard pressed to find even TASTING NOTE: Offers crushed currant
a hint of new oak. Anticipated maturity: and blackberry on the nose, turning
CHÂTEAU MOUTON ROTHSCHILD 2017-2045+. Score: 97. (Robert to tar and licorice. Full-bodied, with
2005 Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com, a solid core of ripe fruit and seamless
AC Pauillac, 1er Cru April 2008) tannins. Goes on and on. Very, very
TASTING NOTE: A blend of 85% beautiful. A cross between the 2000
Cabernet Sauvignon and the rest 510503 [XD] 1500 mL $899 and fabulous 2003. Best after 2013.
mostly Merlot, the dark purple-hued Score: 94. (James Suckling, www.wi-
2005 exhibits a restrained but pro- nespectator.com, March 31, 2008)
mising nose of cedar, tobacco leaf,
creme de cassis, and toasty oak. 689315 [XD] 1500 mL $450
Full-bodied, tannic, and extremely
backward, with the vintage’s tell-tale
acidity, it appears to be even more
closed in the bottle than it was from
barrel. It does possess a long finish
and multilayered mouthfeel. This is an
undeniably outstanding, yet restrained,
shy wine for a Mouton Rothschild.
Anticipated maturity: 2018-2040+.
Score: 96. (Robert Parker Jr.,
www.erobertparker.com, April 2008)
506311 [XD] 750 mL $995
689638 [XD] 1500 mL $2045
689281 [XD] 3000 mL $4145
16 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
CHÂTEAU SMITH-HAUT-LAFITTE CHÂTEAU VALANDRAUD 2005 DOMAINE DE CHEVALIER 2005
2005 AC St-Émilion Grand Cru AC Pessac-Léognan, Cru Classé
AC Pessac-Léognan, Cru Classé TASTING NOTE: This is one of the TASTING NOTE: Displays floral, black-
TASTING NOTE: One can’t say most riveting examples of Valandraud berry and mineral aromas, with a
enough about the accomplishments Jean-Luc Thunevin has made over hint of fresh tobacco. Full-bodied, with
the Cathiards have achieved at this the last fifteen years. Thunevin and his supersilky tannins and a long, caressing
property since 1990. Prior to their partner, Murielle Andraud (who has finish. Has a fine, polished texture.
purchase of the property, appallingly much of the responsibility for their This is a class act – the best since 1998
diluted, vegetal, fruitless, charmless brilliant Margaux, Marojallia), exhibit for the red. Best after 2012. Score: 93.
wines were produced, but they have impeccable attention to detail, resulting (James Suckling, www.winespecta-
turned Smith-Haut-Lafitte into a in an inky/blue/purple-colored 2005 tor.com, March 31, 2008)
showcase Pessac-Leognan. The inky/ Valandraud boasting a sweet nose of
blue/purple-tinged 2005’s extraordinary melted chocolate, licorice, graphite, 689430 [XD] 1500 mL $189
nose reeks of charcoal, incense, espresso roast, and copious quantities
scorched earth, abundant blackberry, of black cherries and blackberries.
blueberry, and cherry fruit, toast, Pure, layered, and full-bodied, with LE PETIT MOUTON 2005
and spice. Good acidity, huge but gorgeous integration of acidity, tan- AC Pauillac, Second Wine of
sweet tannin, and fabulous precision nin, alcohol, and wood, this stunning Château Mouton-Rothschild
as well as definition characterize effort will be drinkable in 7-8 years, TASTING NOTE: Licorice, mineral
this full-bodied, super-concentrated and should keep for three decades. and currant aromas follow through
effort. It should prove to be among Score: 95. (Robert Parker Jr., to a medium-to-full body, with fine
the longest-lived wines yet made by www.erobertparker.com, April 2008) tannins and a mineral and currant
the Cathiards. Anticipated maturity: aftertaste. Quite chewy. Best after 2011.
2015-2030+. Score: 95. (Robert 506287 [XD] 750 mL $545 Score: 89. (James Suckling, www.wi-
Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com, nespectator.com, March 31, 2008)
April 2008)
506121 [XD] 750 mL $139
510495 [XD] 1500 mL $255 689620 [XD] 1500 mL $289
VINTAGES 17
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
FRANCE – BORDEAUX DOMAINE ANTONIN GUYON CÔTE DE BEAUNE
CORTON-BRESSANDES GRAND WHITE WINE
CRU 2007
RED WINE AC BOUCHARD PÈRE & FILS
TASTING NOTE: As one would reason- CORTON-CHARLEMAGNE GRAND
CHÂTEAU COS D’ESTOURNEL ably expect, this is more elegant and CRU 2007
2004 finer though not necessarily more AC
AC St-Estèphe, 2e Cru complex with more obvious mineral TASTING NOTE: Bouchard’s 2007
TASTING NOTE: Loads of currant nuances to the fresh, cool, airy and Corton-Charlemagne – the last wine
and blackberry, with hints of Indian even lacy red pinot fruit aromas that they picked – offers another of those
spices. Full-bodied, with velvety introduce classy, pure, balanced and occasions for reflecting on a bit of
tannins and a long, caressing finish. impressively energetic flavors that pos- Burgundian craziness: a grand cru
Round and generous for the vintage. sess plenty of underlying tension on wine presented last in a stellar line-up,
Best after 2011. Score: 94. (James the palate staining and lingering finish. yet that costs on-half to one-third that
Suckling, www.winespectator.com, Excellent if not truly sensational quality. of the other grand cru bottlings that
March 31, 2007) Drink [from] 2015+. Score: 90-93. preceded it. A striking and intensely
(Allen Meadows, www.burghound.com, pungent aroma of holly berry, fresh
670927 [XD] 750 mL $145 April 2009) ginger, and lime zest leads to a viva-
cious, silken-textured, chalky, saline,
73668 [XD] 750 mL $95 crustacean palate. For all of this
FRANCE – BURGUNDY wine’s sheer intensity and palpable
sense of underlying extract, it shares
lift, buoyancy, and overall elegance
CÔTE DE BEAUNE with its Chevalier-Montrachet counter-
RED WINE parts and preserves the energy and
primary, juicy refreshment that goes
ALBERT MOROT LES TEURONS with its vintage. The diversity and
BEAUNE 1er CRU 2007 persistence of mineral elements here
AC are memorable. It’s the hundredth
TASTING NOTE: A more typical nose anniversary of this Bouchard parcel
of red and blue pinot fruit laced with (characterized by all-day luminosity),
plenty of floral influence, particularly and a happy birthday indeed! Those
violets, slides gracefully into textured, lucky enough to acquire some of this
vibrant and very precise medium- should anticipate more than a decade
bodied flavors that are supported by of pleasure, but I would estimate that
ripe structural elements and a firmer as re-visiting the wine in 2-3 years would
well as mouth coating finish. Excellent. be rewarding both sensually and in
Drink [from] 2014+. Score: 90-92. terms of estimating its further evolution.
(Allen Meadows, www.burghound.com, Score: 96. (David Schildknecht,
April 2009) www.erobertparker.com, Dec. 2009)
902833 [XD] 750 mL $55 172460 [XD] 750 mL $189
18 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
FRANCE – RHÔNE E. GUIGAL CHÂTEAU D’AMPUIS NORTHERN RHÔNE
CÔTE-RÔTIE 2005 WHITE WINE
AC
NORTHERN RHÔNE TASTING NOTE: If the 2006 represents FRANÇOIS VILLARD LE GRAND
RED WINE a 1991-ish feminine offering, the VALLON CONDRIEU 2007
2005 Cote Rotie Chateau d’Ampuis AC
DOMAINE COURBIS LES EYGATS is a macho, masculine-styled effort. TASTING NOTE: Really ripe and
CORNAS 2007 Dense, concentrated, and powerful, rounded, this is packed with papaya,
AC with gamy black currant, spice box, mango, green fig and green tea
TASTING NOTE: Exhibiting a denser bacon fat, and herb notes, this chewy, notes that cascade over one another,
purple color as well as more blackberry, tannic, enormously promising [wine] while fresh floral and mineral hints
coffee, tar, fig, and forest floor notes requires 3-4 years of cellaring, and pierce the lengthy finish. Drink now
is the 2007 Cornas Les Eygats. It is should drink well over the following through 2011. Score: 93. (James
a denser effort with more floral notes, two decades or more. Score: (94-96). Molesworth, www.winespectator.com,
blacker fruit, and a more brooding (Robert Parker Jr., www.erobertpar- Dec. 15, 2009)
personality. Score: (90-92). (Robert ker.com, April 2009)
Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com, 171603 [XD] 750 mL $69
April 2009) 741983 [XD] 750 mL $149
719385 [XD] 750 mL $59 E. GUIGAL HERMITAGE BLANC
E. GUIGAL HERMITAGE 2003 2006
AC AC
DOMAINE DU TUNNEL STÉPHANE TASTING NOTE: One of the finest TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Hermitage
ROBERT VIN NOIR CORNAS 2007 cuvees of regular Hermitage Guigal has blanc exhibits classic aromas of flowers,
AC ever produced is the 2003 Hermitage. white currants, licorice, hazelnuts,
TASTING NOTE: The black-hued Copiously fruity with a blackberry/cassis and truffles. It, too, is a full-bodied,
2007 Cornas Vin Noir clearly merits liqueur note, huge, flowery, almost powerful white loaded with glycerin
its names. Full-bodied, massive, chocolatey richness with superb fresh- as well as acidity. Drink this broad,
and highly extracted, this huge Cornas ness, purity, and a stunning thick- impressively-endowed 2006 over
saturates the palate and stains the ness and opulence, this is spectacular the next 10-20 years. Score: (93-95).
teeth. Give it 3-4 years of cellaring, and Hermitage that should drink well (Robert Parker Jr., www.erobertpar-
drink it over the following two decades. for 30+ years. Score: 94. (Robert ker.com, April 2009)
Score: (92-94). (Robert Parker Jr., Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com,
www.erobertparker.com, April 2009) April 2007) 125567 [XD] 750 mL $65
168146 [XD] 750 mL $79 707372 [XD] 750 mL $99
VINTAGES 19
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
FRANCE – RHÔNE CHÂTEAU DE VAUDIEU VAL DE DOMAINE DE LA CHARBONNIÈRE
DIEU CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE LES HAUTES BRUSQUIÈRES
2007 CUVÉE SPÉCIALE CHÂTEAUNEUF-
SOUTHERN RHÔNE AC DU-PAPE 2007
RED WINE TASTING NOTE: This carries the lush AC
raspberry, boysenberry and kirsch TASTING NOTE: This wine is composed
CHÂTEAU DE VAUDIEU fruit notes of the vintage, but keeps of a selection the Maret family makes
CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE 2007 them razor sharp, with gorgeous from their holdings in one of the great
AC spice, incense and black tea notes sites in all of Chateauneuf du Pape,
(Famille Brécht) adding a sense of elegance, despite the lieux-dit known as La Crau. The
TASTING NOTE: The 2007 its weight. The long, perfumy finish 2007 Chateauneuf du Pape Les
Chateauneuf du Pape is a full-bodied, drips with fruit, while minerality Hautes Brusquieres Cuvee Speciale
exceptionally aromatic effort displaying ripples underneath. Drink now through is a blend of 60% Grenache and
plenty of sweet black cherry, licorice, 2024. Score: 94. (James Molesworth, 40% Syrah. The Grenache is aged
garrigue, and earth as well as a www.winespectator.com, Nov. 15, 2009) in large oak foudres and most of the
subtle note of oak in a full-bodied, Syrah in smaller barrels. This fabulous,
opulent style. As the wine sits in 168872 [XD] 750 mL $95 inky/ruby/purple-tinged wine offers up
the glass, whiffs of raspberries and sweet, jammy aromas of black rasp-
figs also emerge from this substantial, berries, licorice, truffles, underbrush,
fleshy, irresistible Chateauneuf du Pape. DOMAINE BOIS DE BOURSAN and Provencal herbs. It is the deepest
Enjoy it over the next 10-15 years. CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE 2007 colored of these four wines, and is
Score: 92. (Robert Parker Jr., www.ero- AC also profoundly rich and layered, with
bertparker.com, Oct. 2009) (Jean et Jean-Paul Versino, Vign.) sweet tannins as well as refreshing
TASTING NOTE: The brilliant 2007 vibrancy and acidity. This stunner
164871 [XD] 750 mL $49 Chateauneuf du Pape offers classic should hit its peak in 3-4 years, and
Provencal aromas of garrigue (that last for two decades. Score: 95+.
roasted herb, windswept smell of (Robert Parker Jr., www.erobertpark-
Provence), truffles, ground pepper, er.com, Oct. 2009)
and kirsch. This full-bodied, rich,
fleshy, complex wine is already drinking 579581 [XD] 750 mL $59
well. It should evolve nicely for
10-15 years. Score: 90. (Robert
Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com,
Oct. 2009)
728014 [XD] 750 mL $45
20 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
DOMAINE DE VILLENEUVE LES DOMAINE DU GRAND TINEL DOMAINE DU PEGAU CUVÉE
VIEILLES VIGNES CHÂTEAUNEUF- CUVÉE ALEXIS ESTABLET LAURENCE CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-
DU-PAPE 2007 CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE 2007 PAPE 2005
AC AC AC
TASTING NOTE: This estate did not TASTING NOTE: The brilliant 2007 (Paul Feraud & Fille, Prop.-Récolt.)
offer their 2008 for tasting, but they Chateauneuf du Pape Cuvee Alexis TASTING NOTE: The 2005
have hit the bull’s eye with their bril- Establet (100% Grenache from Chateauneuf du Pape Cuvee Laurence
liant 2007 Chateauneuf du Pape. 100-year-old vines from a parcel appears to be the finest example of
Aged 80% in tank and 20% in old situated in the northern end of this wine since the 1998. Wonderfully
barrels, this blend of 70% Grenache, Chateauneuf du Pape known as La rich, concentrated notes of roasted
16% Mourvedre, and the rest Syrah, Gardiole) is one of the finest wines Provencal herbs, jammy black cherries,
Cinsault, and the white grape this estate has ever made. A saturated new saddle leather, and loamy soil
Clairette is made from vines that ruby/purple color (surprising given are present in this stunningly rich, full-
average 65 years of age (some the fact that the 100% Grenache was bodied wine. With excellent concen-
are over 100 years). This dense ruby/ aged primarily in small oak) is followed tration, moderate tannin, and fabulous
purple-hued offering smells like the by fabulous levels of concentration, length as well as intensity, it should
essence of raspberry jam intermixed rich, ripe fruit, good freshness and be released in 2009-2010, and will
with boysenberries and blueberries. vibrancy (because of the lack of any keep for 20-25 years. Score: (95-97).
Exceptionally pure, with a layered excessive heat during the growing (Robert Parker Jr., www.erobertpar-
mouthfeel and sweet tannin, this season), plenty of pepper, licorice, ker.com, Oct. 2008)
is undeniably the finest wine made grilled Provencal herbs, and exceptional
by Proprietor Stanislas Wallut since levels of red and black fruits. The 168161 [XD] 750 mL $175
he purchased Domaine de Villeneuve tannins are silky, the wine is broad
in 1992. The great oenologist Philippe and savory, and the finish lasts nearly
Cambie consults at this biodynami- a minute. Drink this super wine over SOUTHERN RHÔNE
cally farmed property (over 75% of the next 15-20 years. Score: 94. WHITE WINE
Cambie’s Chateauneuf du Pape clients (Robert Parker Jr., www.erobertpark-
are biodynamically farmed vineyards – er.com, Oct. 2009) DOMAINE DU VIEUX TÉLÉGRAPHE
an impressive statistic). This 2007, LA CRAU CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE
which was bottled unfiltered, should 982017 [XD] 750 mL $59 BLANC 2008
drink beautifully for 15-20 years. It is AC
undeniably a big-time sleeper of the TASTING NOTE: A ripe, honeyed
vintage. Score: 94. (Robert Parker Jr., style, with grilled hazelnut and heath
www.erobertparker.com, Oct. 2009) notes up front, followed by bitter
orange, nectarine and lemon zest. This
163089 [XD] 750 mL $54 has nice length and drive. Drink now
through 2010. Score: 92. (James
Molesworth, www.winespectator.com,
Dec. 31, 2009)
736462 [XD] 750 mL $59
VINTAGES 21
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
FRANCE – RHÔNE FRANCE – ALSACE FRANCE – CHAMPAGNE
SOUTHERN RHÔNE WHITE WINE GUY CHARLEMAGNE BRUT ROSÉ
WHITE WINE CHAMPAGNE
RENÉ MURÉ CLOS ST. LANDELIN AC
CHÂTEAU DE BEAUCASTEL VORBOURG SÉLECTION DE GRAINS TASTING NOTE: The NV Brut Rose is
VIEILLES VIGNES CHÂTEAUNEUF- NOBLES PINOT GRIS 2007 a relatively round, supple Champagne
DU-PAPE BLANC 2007 AC Alsace Grand Cru with an attractive core of fruit. The wine
AC TASTING NOTE: This silky, mouth- offers excellent length and lovely over-
TASTING NOTE: The 2007 coating version is deeply hued, almost all balance, if not quite the pedigree
Chateauneuf du Pape Blanc Vieilles a burnished amber, and exhibits of the house’s finest wines. Disgorged:
Vignes (100% Roussanne) could be lots of tangy acidity to support the lush February, 2009, (not indicated on the
called the “Montrachet of southern peach pie, quince paste, smoky label). The NV Brut Rose is also pro-
France.” A wine of great intensity, it minerality, mushroom, cumin and duced from vineyards in the Sezanne,
boasts thrilling aromas of orange mar- white pepper. A rich and energetic with 60% Pinot Noir vinified saignee-
malade, nectarine liqueur, honey- wine, with a long life ahead of it. Drink style and 40% Chardonnay. Anticipated
suckle, peaches, and apricots. Stun- now through 2030. Score: 97. maturity: 2009-2012. Score: 89.
ningly rich with full body, terrific acidity, (Alison Napjus, www.winespectat- (Antonio Galloni, www.erobertpark-
and a finish that lasts 45+ seconds, or.com, Nov. 15, 2009) er.com, Dec. 2009)
this is an amazing achievement. It
should drink well for 7-8 years, shut 163139 [MD] 500 mL $65 143271 [XD] 750 mL $55
down or become oxidized, then, hope-
fully, re-emerge at around age 12-15,
and drink in a completely different RENÉ MURÉ CLOS
fashion for several decades there- ST. LANDELIN VORBOURG
after. Score: 97. (Robert Parker Jr., VENDANGES TARDIVES
www.erobertparker.com, Oct. 2009) GEWÜRZTRAMINER 2007
AC Alsace Grand Cru
73692 [XD] 750 mL $149 TASTING NOTE: Shows textbook
Gewürztraminer flavors of lychee,
white pepper, rose petal, cream and
candied orange peel. Lively acidity
plays off of the honeyed notes, and
a smoky thread runs below the
surface and along the lingering finish.
Drink now through 2025. Score: 93.
(Alison Napjus, www.winespectat-
or.com, Nov. 15, 2009)
163147 [MD] 500 mL $42
22 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
H. BILLIOT & FILS GRAND CRU DEUTZ BRUT CHAMPAGNE 2005 GUY CHARLEMAGNE LA CUVÉE
BRUT RÉSERVE CHAMPAGNE AC MESNILLÉSIME BLANC DE
AC TASTING NOTE: The 2005 Brut BLANCS GRAND CRU BRUT
TASTING NOTE: The NV Brut Grand opens with a wonderfully expressive, CHAMPAGNE 2002
Cru Reserve is a rich, boisterous wine sweet bouquet that melds into an AC
that showcases incredible intensity in expressive core of fruit. The wine The prestigious French publication,
its fruit. The fat, rich style completely possesses a crystalline purity I find Le Guide Hachette des Vins (2010),
covers every inch of the palate and especially appealing, along with pretty awarded this Champagne its highest
a sweet, perfumed finish reminiscent notes of mint, minerals and red honour – the Coup de Cœur – and
of ethereal plums and kirsch offers berries that linger on the close. This was a jury favourite.
final notes of elegance. The Grand bottle was disgorged on April 22,
Cru Reserve is 80% Pinot Noir and 2009. Anticipated maturity: 2011- TASTING NOTE: This wine really
20% Chardonnay (all Ambonnay). 2021. Score: 91. (Antonio Galloni, needs some coaxing to bring the
The base vintage is 2006, with equal www.erobertparker.com, Dec. 2009) aromas forward, revealing only subtle
parts 2004 and 2003 that round out sniffs of buttered croissant, fresh
the blend. Disgorged: June 24, 2009. 167486 [XD] 750 mL $69 limes and grapefruit plus a hint of
Anticipated maturity: 2010-2015. wet pebbles. The palate is very tightly
Score: 90+. (Antonio Galloni, www.er- knit but fine indeed, providing a great
obertparker.com, Dec. 2009) DEUTZ BRUT ROSÉ CHAMPAGNE intensity of green apple and citrus
2005 fruit flavours complimented by fresh
124537 [XD] 750 mL $55 AC bread and lots of minerals. Crisp
TASTING NOTE: Following the elegant acidity and very fine bubbles. Long
Deutz tradition, this wine has a finish. Needs a further 6-18 months
JEAN MILAN BLANC DE BLANCS character that is light as a feather, in bottle but should develop into some-
GRAND CRU BRUT SPÉCIAL but still anchored into vivid red thing truly special. Tasted March
CHAMPAGNE fruits and tight acidity, leavened by 2009. Score: 93. (Lisa Perrotti-Brown,
AC a softness. The final taste is soft, www.erobertparker.com, July 2009)
TASTING NOTE: A warm, inviting blanc but well integrated. Score: 90. (Roger
de blancs, full of baking bread, honey Voss, Wine Enthusiast, Oct. 14, 2009) 163360 [XD] 750 mL $85
and coffee tones. Rich, yet not soft,
with a nice mineral accent and a 167734 [XD] 750 mL $75
roasted almond note on the lingering
aftertaste. Drink now. Score: 91.
(Bruce Sanderson, www.winespecta-
tor.com, Oct. 31, 2009)
143602 [XD] 750 mL $59
VINTAGES 23
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
FRANCE – CHAMPAGNE FRANCE – MIDI ITALY – ABRUZZO
JACQUESSON AVIZE GRAND CRU RED WINE RED WINE
BRUT CHAMPAGNE 2000
AC MAS DU SOLEILLA LES LA VALENTINA BELLOVEDERE
TASTING NOTE: This dry Champagne BARTELLES LA CLAPE 2007 MONTEPULCIANO D’ABRUZZO
is more on the yeast, grain and mineral AC Coteaux du Languedoc 2005
side of the flavor spectrum than on This wine was #86 on Wine DOC
the fruit side, yet there’s a hint of Spectator’s Top 100 list of 2009. TASTING NOTE: The 2005
cherry. Picks up a ginger note and Montepulciano d’Abruzzo Bellovedere
leaves a mouthwatering impression TASTING NOTE: A big, rich and ripe is a drop-dead gorgeous wine that
on the finish. Drink now through red, with a meaty aroma that leads achieves a rare level of brilliance in
2018. Score: 89. (Bruce Sanderson, to intense mocha and dark chocolate a combination of ripeness in a poised,
www.winespectator.com, Nov. 30, notes. Hints of cream, dark cherry mid-weight style of notable clarity that
2009) and spice complete the package. recalls a great Burgundy or Barolo.
Finishes with intense beefy notes. This sensual, elegant red flows with red
163352 [XD] 750 mL $95 Drink now through 2014. Score: 92. cherries, sweet spices, tobacco and
(Kim Marcus, www.winespectator.com, leather, showing superb delineation
Nov. 15, 2009) and balance. The finish is long, sweet
and incredibly pure. La Valentina is
167841 [D] 750 mL $35 aged partly in cask and partly in small
French oak barrels. Simply put La
Valentina’s Bellovedere sets a new
DOMAINE GARDIÉS LA TORRE standard for Montepulciano. It is not
2006 to be missed. Anticipated maturity:
AC Côtes de Roussillon-Villages 2009-2015. Score: 94. (Antonio
(Jean Gardiés, Vign.) Galloni, www.erobertparker.com,
TASTING NOTE: Luscious, rich and April 2009)
ripe, with concentrated flavors of
dark plum, blackberry and kirsch 167445 [XD] 750 mL $69
that are supported by fine-grained
tannins and powerful structure. The
long finish is filled with dark choco-
late and mocha. Score: 93. (Kim
Marcus, www.winespectator.com,
Oct. 31, 2008)
163055 [XD] 750 mL $49
24 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
ITALY – CAMPANIA ITALY – FRIULI ITALY – PIEDMONT
RED WINE WHITE WINE RED WINE
TERREDORA CAMPORE TAURASI VINTAGE TUNINA 2007 FALLETTO DI BRUNO GIACOSA
RISERVA 2003 IGT Venezia Giulia BAROLO 2005
DOCG (Jermann) DOCG
TASTING NOTE: The 2003 Taurasi TASTING NOTE: Shows a lovely TASTING NOTE: The 2005 Barolo
Campore is a big, opulent wine balance of dried apricot, pineapple Falletto offers up a gorgeous bouquet
endowed with masses of dark fruit. and honey, with traces of violet and of red cherries, flowers, spices and
A harmonious, beautifully- balanced mineral. Full-bodied, with powerful menthol. This is a relatively delicate,
Taurasi, the Campore reveals terrific balance and intense fruit on the elegant Barolo Falletto yet it offers
density and purity in a seamless, finish. Almost late-harvest in style. gorgeous balance, tons of inner per-
generous style. Dark fruit, leather, Drink now. Score: 92. (James fume and a long, refined finish. It
grilled herbs and roasted coffee Suckling, www.winespectator.com, is one of the overachievers in 2005.
beans are some of the nuances to Aug. 31, 2009) Anticipated maturity: 2015-2025.
be found in this polished, elegant Score: 94. (Antonio Galloni, www.erob-
wine. Taurasi is rarely this rewarding 964825 [XD] 750 mL $59 ertparker.com, April 2009)
at this early stage, but Terredora
has succeeded in producing a highly 92130 [XD] 750 mL $199
pleasing wine that is already a pure W ... DREAMS ... 2007
joy to drink. Anticipated maturity: 2009- IGT Venezia Giulia
2018. Score: 92. (Antonio Galloni, (Jermann)
www.erobertparker.com, April 2009) TASTING NOTE: This has a lovely
golden color, with aromas of apple tart
93070 [XD] 750 mL $44 and notes of sultana and spices. Full-
bodied, with a lemony acidity that gives
a fresh attack. Hints of vanilla cream
latch on and provide a lingering apple
pie finish. Layered, long and finely
crafted. Rich and wonderful. Drink now.
Score: 93. (James Suckling, www.wi-
nespectator.com, Aug. 31, 2009)
51524 [D] 750 mL $59
VINTAGES 25
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
ITALY – PIEDMONT PARUSSO 35 ANNATA BAROLO PIO CESARE IL BRICCO
2005 BARBARESCO 2005
DOCG DOCG
RED WINE TASTING NOTE: Aromas of blackberry, TASTING NOTE: Shows pure plum
tea and Indian spices follow through on the nose, with a combination of
MARCARINI BRUNATE BAROLO to a medium body, with fine tannins violet and smoke. Full-bodied, with
2005 and a fruity, caressing-textured finish. layers of ultrafine tannins and a
DOCG Very pretty and refined. This is a special very long finish. Caresses the palate.
TASTING NOTE: Readers who want to blend to commemorate the 35th A wine of strength and elegance.
understand why Brunate is considered anniversary of the estate, using grapes Best after 2012. Score: 95. (James
one of Piedmont’s great vineyards from the Mariondino, Bussia Le Coste Suckling, www.winespectator.com,
should check out Marcarini 2005 Barolo and Mosconi vineyards. Best from 2011 Sept. 30, 2009)
Brunate. The wine reveals another through 2016. Score: 92. (James
dimension of density and richness vis- Suckling, www.winespectator.com, 730275 [XD] 750 mL $99
a-vis the La Serra, with subtle balsamic July 31, 2009)
notes that gradually emerge to round
out the dark red fruit. Everything about 163345 [XD] 750 mL $69 PIO CESARE ORNATO BAROLO
this wine is beautifully balanced. The 2005
wine gains power on the close, where DOCG
the strong, muscular finish sees PIO CESARE BAROLO 2005 TASTING NOTE: Very pretty aromas
notes of dark fruits, and spices make DOCG of sweet strawberry pie, with hints
a second appearance. The tannins TASTING NOTE: Very ripe fruit aromas, of plum and flowers. Full-bodied, with
could use another year or two in bottle with sultana, prune and dried flowers. polished yet chewy tannins and bright
to soften, but this remains an out- Full-bodied, with seamless yet chewy acidity. A big, juicy wine. A Barolo for
standing Barolo in a very tricky vintage. tannins and a long finish. Lasts a the cellar. Best after 2013. Score: 95.
To be sure, the style is relatively sub- long time. Best after 2012. Score: 93. (James Suckling, www.winespecta-
dued, as is the case with virtually all (James Suckling, www.winespecta- tor.com, Sept. 30, 2009)
Barolos in 2005, yet this wine offers tor.com, Sept. 30, 2009)
commendable harmony. Brunate is 974956 [XD] 750 mL $99
simply Brunate, and that’s all there is 736587 [XD] 750 mL $75
to it. Anticipated maturity: 2010-
2025. Score: 92. (Antonio Galloni,
www.erobertparker.com, April 2009)
167494 [XD] 750 mL $59
MARCHESI DI BAROLO CANNUBI
BAROLO 2005
DOCG
TASTING NOTE: Blackberry and
green tobacco aromas follow through
to a full-bodied palate, with a firm,
tight tannin structure and a fresh finish.
Needs time to soften and open up.
Best after 2012. Score: 91. (James
Suckling, www.winespectator.com,
Aug. 31, 2009)
980912 [XD] 750 mL $55
26 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
CASTELLO DI VERDUNO MASSARA MARCHESI DI GRÉSY CAMP GROS ITALY – SICILY
BAROLO 2004 MARTINENGA BARBARESCO 2004
DOCG DOCG
TASTING NOTE: Aromatic, complex, TASTING NOTE: The 2004 RED WINE
pronounced truffles, red and black Barbaresco Camp Gros Martinenga is
fruits. Wonderful structure and elegance a much larger-scaled wine than the PASSOPISCIARO 2007
that will replay cellaring. Lots of fruit, Gaiun. This fresh, vibrant Barbaresco IGT Sicilia
rich and smoky with well-integrated explodes from the glass with a gorgeous TASTING NOTE: The just-bottled
tannins. Very good effort – lovely array of macerated dark cherries, 2007 Passopisciaro is a weightless yet
balance. From 2010. Score: ##### spices, menthol, pine, minerals and powerful wine redolent of sweet
(out of 5). (Michael Palij, MW, toasted oak. The wine reveals superb candied cherries, flowers, herbs and
Decanter, May 2009) depth and clarity, with awesome finesse. minerals. The wine reveals lovely
This is the finest wine I can recall density and purity, even if a few days
163204 [XD] 750 mL $65 tasting here in many a year. Camp Gros of rain towards the end of the growing
is made from a parcel adjacent to season in November robbed it of the
Rabaja. Anticipated maturity: 2010- intensity that informs the very finest
FONTANABIANCA SORÍ BURDIN 2022. Score: 94. (Antonio Galloni, vintages. Still, there is gorgeous
BARBARESCO 2004 www.erobertparker.com, Oct. 2008) purity to the fruit that insures this will
DOCG be fascinating wine to follow over
TASTING NOTE: I remember visiting 172510 [XD] 750 mL $89 the coming years. Anticipated maturity:
Fontanabianca and proprietor Aldo 2009-2021. Score: 92. (Antonio
Pola as his 2004 Barbarescos were Galloni, www.erobertparker.com,
fermenting right after the harvest. TRAVAGLINI TRE VIGNE April 2009)
The perfumes emanating from the GATTINARA 2004
winery were heavenly. Pola’s 2004 DOCG 169078 [XD] 750 mL $49
Barbaresco Sori Burdin has turned TASTING NOTE: The estate deservedly
out beautifully. It is a big, authoritative returns to Three Glass status with
Barbaresco loaded with super-ripe the spectacular Tre Vigne ‘04, which
red fruit, macerated cherries, menthol, combines an elegant nose of rhubarb
minerals, flowers and spices. Endowed and dried flowers with a juicy, well-
with notable weight and a layered balanced palate and fine-grained
texture, it offers outstanding concentra- tannins. Score: ggg (out of 3).
tion and fine, well-integrated tannins. (Gambero Rosso Italian Wines, 2009)
This is a terrific effort from Fontana-
bianca. Anticipated maturity: 2009- 35329 [XD] 750 mL $45
2019. Score: 92. (Antonio Galloni,
www.erobertparker.com, Oct. 2007)
83667 [XD] 750 mL $55
VINTAGES 27
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
ITALY – SICILY ITALY – TUSCANY CARNASCIALE 2006
IGT Toscana
(Podere Il Carnasciale)
RED WINE RED WINE TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Carnasciale
is insanely beautiful in this vintage.
TERRE NERE CALDERARA TENUTA DI TRINORO LE CUPOLE The bouquet alone is extraordinary.
SOTTANA 2006 TRINORO 2007 Scents of tar, smoke, grilled herbs,
DOC Etna Rosso IGT Rosso Toscana French oak and coffee beans seam-
TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Calderara TASTING NOTE: The 2007 Le Cupole lessly meld into an expressive core
Sottana, once the estate’s entry-level di Trinoro is superb. This impeccable, of perfumed dark fruit. This opulent
wine, is now itself a selection of the best pedigreed Tuscan red flows seamlessly wine possesses exceptional balance
fruit and oldest vines from the heart onto the palate with layers of perfumed, and poise, with persistent notes of
of the Calderara vineyard, while the rest silky fruit that carry through all the way minerality that provide balance and
of the fruit from Calderara now goes to the long, polished close. The 2007 proportion. Though not inexpensive
into the Rosso. This utterly engaging is an incredibly harmonious and well- by any means, the 2006 Carnasciale
wine offers up dark cherries, spices balanced Le Cupole that is sure to offers outstanding relative value.
and sweet herbs in a style that brings deliver much pleasure … Simply put, Fans of Il Carnasciale won’t want to
to mind the Nebbiolos of northern the 2007 Le Cupole di Trinoro is not miss this beauty. Anticipated maturity:
Piedmont. There is a lovely density to be missed! In 2007 Le Cupole 2009-2021. Score: 93. (Robert
here despite the wine’s medium- di Trinoro is 40% Cabernet Franc, Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com,
bodied frame. Anticipated maturity: 22% Cabernet Sauvignon, 30% Merlot Aug. 2009)
2009-2019. Score: 92. (Antonio and 8% Petit Verdot. Anticipated
Galloni, www.erobertparker.com, maturity: 2009-2015. Score: 92. 167288 [XD] 750 mL $79
April 2009) (Antonio Galloni, www.erobertpar-
ker.com, Aug. 2009)
163881 [XD] 750 mL $55
30361 [XD] 750 mL $45
VALLE DELL’ACATE TANÉ 2004
IGT Sicilia
TASTING NOTE: The 2004 Tane
is 80% Nero d’Avola and 20% Syrah
made in a dark, powerful style.
Scorched earth, black olives, herbs,
plums, dark cherries and melted
road tar are just some of the nuances
that emerge from this dark, brooding
wine. Despite the Tane’s hulking per-
sonality, there is also remarkable
clarity and definition in the aromas and
flavors, something that is quite rare
in many Sicilian wines made in this
style. The wine’s full-throttle intensity
might not be for everyone, but I loved
this bold, unique red. Anticipated
maturity: 2010-2019. Score: 92.
(Antonio Galloni, www.erobertpark-
er.com, April 2009)
169086 [XD] 750 mL $55
28 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
CASTELLARE DI CASTELLINA CASTELLO DI AMA CASTELLO DI AMA
VIGNA IL POGGIALE CHIANTI VIGNETO BELLAVISTA VIGNETO LA CASUCCIA
CLASSICO RISERVA 2006 CHIANTI CLASSICO 2006 CHIANTI CLASSICO 2006
DOCG DOCG DOCG
TASTING NOTE: Blackberry, plum TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Chianti TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Chianti
and milk chocolate on the nose. Full- Classico Vigneto Bellavista Sangiovese, Classico Vigneto La Casuccia
bodied, with soft, round tannins. Malvasia Nera is incredibly tight and (Sangiovese, Merlot) reveals stunning
Caresses the palate. Juicy, fruity and backward. This masculine, authoritative clarity and freshness in its black
delicious. Best after 2010. Score: 91. wine shows little aromatic complexity cherries, violets, minerals and sweet
(James Suckling, www.winespecta- today, instead it’s all about purity of spices. This dense, richly-textured
tor.com, Oct. 15, 2009) fruit and structure, both of which wine possesses staggering richness
the Bellavista has in spades. The style and elegance along with breathtaking
606947 [XD] 750 mL $39 is more intense and powerful than clarity and precision. Notes of leather,
the Casuccia; and even a touch more smoke, tar and licorice linger on the
refined, as hard as that may seem to long, intense finish. Anticipated
CASTELLO DI AMA L’APPARITA 2006 believe. The firm tannins need time to maturity: 2012-2026. Score: 96.
IGT Toscana soften, but this is a dramatic, sweeping (Antonio Galloni, www.erobertpar-
TASTING NOTE: The 2006 L’Apparita wine of the highest level that only ker.com, Aug. 2009)
(Merlot) reveals gorgeous clarity and needs patience. Sweet balsamic tones
precision. It is another large-scaled, make an appearance on the finish, 979278 [XD] 750 mL $169
dramatic wine, rich in baritone notes hinting at the direction the wine is
of dark fruit, menthol, herbs, licorice heading. Anticipated maturity: 2016-
and new leather. The tannins build 2031. Score: 96. (Antonio Galloni, FATTORIA LE PUPILLE
mightily on the vibrant finish, yet this www.erobertparker.com, Aug. 2009) SAFFREDI 2006
remains an impeccable, polished IGT Maremma Toscana,
wine of remarkable beauty. I only hope 163337 [XD] 750 mL $165 Elisabetta Geppetti
to have a chance to taste the wine TASTING NOTE: [Proprietor Elisabetta]
again in the future – amazingly today Geppetti has produced another gem
it tastes just like it did from tank in in her 2006 Saffredi, a French-oak aged
November 2006! Anticipated maturity: blend of Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot
2016-2022. Score: 95. (Antonio and Alicante. This textured, explosive
Galloni, www.erobertparker.com, wine boasts considerable depth
Aug. 2009) and richness in its dark fruit, flowers,
minerals and graphite. The wine
39776 [XD] 750 mL $159 remains extremely primary and in
need of considerable bottle age in
order to offer its best drinking but it
is unquestionably formidable. The
style combines elements of power and
elegance, achieving a level rarely
seen in these parts. Simply put, this
is stunning juice. Anticipated maturity:
2014-2026. Score: 96. (Antonio
Galloni, www.erobertparker.com,
Aug. 2009)
74435 [XD] 750 mL $109
VINTAGES 29
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
ITALY – TUSCANY IL CABERLOT 2006 ISOLE E OLENA CEPPARELLO
IGT Toscana 2006
(Podere Il Carnasciale) IGT Toscana
RED WINE Until the 2001 vintage, this wine was TASTING NOTE: Isole e Olena’s
exclusively sold in magnum bottles to 2006 Cepparello (100% Sangiovese)
FATTORIA NITTARDI NECTAR DEI restaurants in Tuscany. It is still only reveals superb density and richness
2006 available in magnums, but now a few in a surprisingly medium-bodied style
IGT Maremma Toscana ‘escape’ overseas and into your hands. for this vintage. Candied red fruit,
TASTING NOTE: Complex aromas of flowers, menthol and sweet herbs
blackberry, blueberry, currant and TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Il Caberlot emerge from the glass with almost
licorice. Full-bodied, with silky tannins comes across as very shut down and liqueur-like sweetness. The wine
and toasted oak that turns to vanilla intensely tannic at this early stage. With possesses outstanding balance and
and coffee. Rich and wonderful. Nectar. some coaxing the fruit gradually a long, sweet finish, with subtle
Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Syrah emerges, and sweet, mentholated, notes of tar, licorice and herbs that
and Petit Verdot. Best after 2012. balsamic notes appear, yet this make an appearance on the close.
Score: 94. (James Suckling, www.wi- remains a reticent wine. Today there This is an elegant Cepparello that com-
nespectator.com, Web Only, 2009) is little aromatic development, but bines the ripeness of the vintage in a
that will come with time. Underneath mid-weight, ethereal style. Anticipated
163311 [XD] 750 mL $69 the tannins lurks a wine of exceptional maturity: 2009-2019. Score: 93.
balance. Like a shy teenager, the (Antonio Galloni, www.erobertpark-
2006 Caberlot needs some time to er.com, Aug. 2009)
FONTODI FLACCIANELLO DELLA overcome its awkwardness. The
PIEVE 2006 wine’s length and polish are superb. 25650 [XD] 750 mL $75
IGT Colli Toscana Centrale I sampled the 2006 Caberlot from
This wine was honoured with the a 750 mL tasting bottle, but the wine
#8 spot on Wine Spectator’s Top 100 is commercially only available in MILLEPASSI BOLGHERI
list of 2009. magnums, and in that format is likely SUPERIORE 2006
to be even more backward than DOC
TASTING NOTE: Shows excellent this tasting note suggests! Anticipated (Donna Olimpia 1898)
color and richness for a Sangiovese, maturity: 2016-2026. Score: 95. TASTING NOTE: Blackberry and
with aromas of sultana, coffee, toasty (Antonio Galloni, www.erobertpar- cherry aromas follow through to a full
oak and vanilla bean. Full-bodied, with ker.com, Aug. 2009) body, with supersilky tannins and
masses of fruit and chewy tannins. a long, flavorful finish. A racy and
The concentration and depth of fruit 167296 [XD] 1500 mL $375 polished red. Cabernet Sauvignon,
and layers of tannins are breathtaking. Merlot and Petit Verdot. Best after
A blockbuster. Best after 2014. Highly 2011. Score: 94. (James Suckling,
Recommended. Score: 99. (James www.winespectator.com, Oct. 31, 2009)
Suckling, www.winespectator.com,
Oct. 31, 2009) 163840 [XD] 750 mL $59
963744 [XD] 750 mL $85
30 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
MONTEVERTINE 2006 RICCARDO BARACCHI ARDITO VIGNAMAGGIO CASTELLO DI
IGT Toscana 2006 MONNA LISA CHIANTI CLASSICO
TASTING NOTE: Grace, elegance, IGT Toscana RISERVA 2006
poise. These are just some of the TASTING NOTE: Dark in color, with DOCG
descriptors that come to mind impressive aromas of licorice, pepper, TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Chianti
as the sublime 2006 Montevertine currant and berries. Full-bodied, Classico Riserva Castello di Monna
(Sangiovese, Canaiolo, Colorino) with supersilky, powerful tannins, yet Lisa is a big, dramatic wine bursting
opens up in the glass. This ethereal, reserved and balanced. Very harmo- with sweet black cherries, licorice,
mid-weight wine possesses striking nious, with a long finish. Cabernet menthol and sweet scents of French
inner perfume of sweet red fruit, Sauvignon and Syrah. Best after oak. This is a fairly rich, structured
flowers and licorice. Were it not for 2011. Score: 95. (James Suckling, style of Chianti. As good as the Monna
the tell-tale Sangiovese acidity, the www.winespectator.com, Oct. 31, 2009) Lisa is, I had a slight preference for
2006 Montevertine might easily be some of the lesser-oaked wines, as the
mistaken for Pinot Noir. There is 163717 [XD] 750 mL $55 wood tannins add a touch of astrin-
remarkable purity and integrity to gency. Anticipated maturity: 2012-2021.
the wine, not to mention stunning Score: 90. (Antonio Galloni, www.er-
clarity and finessed yet firm tannins SAVIGNOLA PAOLINA CHIANTI obertparker.com, Aug. 2009)
that hold everything together all the CLASSICO RISERVA 2006
way through to the long, finessed finish. DOCG 930651 [XD] 750 mL $35
This exemplary Montevertine is not TASTING NOTE: Bright and perfumed,
to be missed. Readers who want to with mineral, floral and light cream
enjoy the 2006 for its primary beauty aromas. Full-bodied, with firm tannins
can drink the wine today, but it and a long, fruity finish. A Burgundian
is sure to acquire plenty of tertiary style. Best after 2010. Score: 92.
complexity in bottle as well. This (James Suckling, www.winespecta-
is Lot L 1408. Anticipated maturity: tor.com, Oct. 15, 2009)
2012-2026. Score: 93. (Antonio
Galloni, www.erobertparker.com, 163659 [XD] 750 mL $35
Aug. 2009)
167742 [XD] 750 mL $49
VITICCIO MONILE 2006
IGT Toscana
TASTING NOTE: Offers currant, berries,
light toasty oak and light coffee. Full-
bodied, with ripe fruit, soft, silky tannins
and a rich finish. Ripe and beauti-
ful, with a lovely texture. Cabernet
Sauvignon and Merlot. Best after
2012. Score: 94. (James Suckling,
www.winespectator.com, Oct. 31, 2009)
163279 [XD] 750 mL $54
VINTAGES 31
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
ITALY – TUSCANY LA TOGATA BRUNELLO DI QUINTARELLI AMARONE DELLA
MONTALCINO 2004 VALPOLICELLA CLASSICO 2000
DOCG DOC
RED WINE (Tenuta Carlina) TASTING NOTE: The 2000 Amarone
TASTING NOTE: Dark ruby in color, della Valpolicella Classico is a thing
POGGIOMANDORLO 2005 showing beautiful aromas of crushed of beauty. This mid-weight, delicate red
IGT Maremma Toscana berries, with hints of sultana, raisin offers up a gorgeous array of crushed
TASTING NOTE: Very fresh, with a and spices. Full-bodied, with a super- flowers, red berries and sweet spices
focused blackberry and mineral char- rich, powerful palate. This has layers in an ethereal style. As it sits in the
acter. Full-bodied, with a wonderful of fruit and a fabulous finish. Decadent glass the wine acquires concentration
core of ripe fruit and a silky, soft texture. and delicious. Best after 2011. Highly and richness. The wine possesses
Balanced and complex. Merlot and Recommended. Score: 95. (James the grace of a ballerina, phenomenal
Cabernet Franc. Best after 2011. Suckling, www.winespectator.com, balance and impeccable pedigree.
Score: 94. (James Suckling, www.wi- Sept. 30, 2009) In this vintage the Amarone shows sug-
nespectator.com, Oct. 15, 2008) gestions of slightly newer barrels,
168153 [XD] 750 mL $69 and that may be why this is the first
163329 [XD] 750 mL $79 non-Riserva Amarone I can recall in
at least a few years that doesn’t show
ITALY – VENETO the excess volatile acidity that has
marred some previous wines. To be
sure, this is a super-traditional, cask-
RED WINE aged Amarone, and it may not appeal
to all palates, but readers in search
TENUTA SANT’ANTONIO CAMPO of fine old-school Amarone won’t find
DEI GIGLI AMARONE DELLA a better wine among this year’s new
VALPOLICELLA 2004 releases. In time this score may very
DOC well go up...quite a bit. Anticipated
TASTING NOTE: The Amarone Campo maturity: 2010-2020. Score: 96+.
dei Gigli 2004 shows its usual exu- (Antonio Galloni, www.erobertpark-
CASALOSTE INVERSUS 2004 berant but supple personality, lifted er.com, Oct. 2009)
IGT Toscana by complex aromas. This combination
TASTING NOTE: A little raisiny, with won it Three authoritative Glasses. 986109 [XD] 750 mL $399
blackberry, licorice and just a hint Score: ggg (out of 3). (Gambero
of tar. Full-bodied, with soft, velvety Rosso Italian Wines, 2009)
tannins and a wild richness on the
finish. This is a winery making things 681627 [XD] 750 mL $79
happen in Panzano. Merlot and
Sangiovese. Best after 2011. Score: 94.
(James Suckling, www.winespecta-
tor.com, Oct. 31, 2009)
163295 [XD] 750 mL $55
32 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
QUINTARELLI ROSSO DEL BEPI QUINTARELLI RECIOTO DELLA RAMOS PINTO DUAS QUINTAS
1999 VALPOLICELLA CLASSICO 1997 RESERVA 2006
IGT Veneto DOCG DOC Douro
TASTING NOTE: Quintarelli’s deeply- TASTING NOTE: The 1997 Recioto TASTING NOTE: A concentrated and
colored 1999 Rosso del Bepi offers della Valpolicella Classico is a vibrant red, with intense flavors of
an explosion of super-ripe sweet fruit gorgeous, refined wine with layers raspberry, blueberry and dark cherry.
on the nose. Lush and generous on of sweet, perfumed fruit that flow The long, rich finish oozes dark
the palate, it displays superb length gracefully from its medium-bodied chocolate and spice. This has plenty
and a glorious, primary expression frame. The 1997 Recioto isn’t quite of grip. Drink now through 2013.
of fruit even if it clearly doesn’t have as extroverted as the profound Score: 92. (Kim Marcus, www.win-
the structure of his more important 1995, but it does offer impeccable espectator.com, Oct. 31, 2008)
wines. Quintarelli declassifies his balance in a relatively understated,
Amarone to Rosso del Bepi in vintages slender style for this house. Sweet 951301 [D] 750 mL $39
he doesn’t feel merit the Amarone spices, licorice, leather and incense
designation. Anticipated maturity: 2007- linger on the long and immensely
2014. Score: 92. (Antonio Galloni, satisfying finish. I tasted the 1997 CALLABRIGA RESERVA 2004
www.erobertparker.com, Oct. 2007) Recioto from both 375 mL and DOC Alentejo
750 mL bottles and found the wine (Sogrape Vinhos)
991356 [XD] 750 mL $199 consistently superb. Anticipated TASTING NOTE: With two years of
maturity: 2009-2019. Score: 94. barrel and bottle aging, this wine
(Antonio Galloni, www.erobertpar- is maturing attractively. The tannins
QUINTARELLI ALZERO 1998 ker.com, Oct. 2009) remain firm, but the taste is broad,
IGT Veneto rich, a fine combination of solid black
TASTING NOTE: Quintarelli’s Alzero is 932343 [MD] 375 mL $189 plums and wood spice, with a tight
one of Italy’s most unique, compelling edge of acidity. Big, with bold brush
wines, particularly in top vintages, in strokes of flavor, but worth aging
which it can be utterly mind-blowing. PORTUGAL another two years. Score: 92. (Roger
Alzero is mostly Cabernet Franc, with Voss, Wine Enthusiast, Nov. 2009)
a dollop of Merlot, made Amarone-
style. The 1998 reveals compelling RED WINE 163287 [XD] 750 mL $29
layers of ripe dark fruit, sweet herbs,
chocolate and spices that gradually EVEL GRANDE RESERVA 2007
unfurl in the glass. The wine pos- DOC Douro
sesses gorgeous length and balance, (Real Companhia Velha)
but not the sheer opulence of the TASTING NOTE: One of the best
profound 1997. Aged in cask, this wines to come out of the Real
traditionally made, hand-crafted Companhia, this finely structured
wine shows more volatile acidity than wine shows distinct austerity and
many wines these days, yet it also minerality as well as dark, young
offers a totally unique drinking expe- tannins and packed black fruits.
rience. Anticipated maturity: 2008- The balance is all there, a wine that
2028. Score: 92. (Antonio Galloni, keeps the wood in check, allowing
www.erobertparker.com, Oct. 2008) the great fruits to come through.
Score: 91. (Roger Voss, Wine
716423 [XD] 750 mL $499 Enthusiast, Nov. 2009)
163253 [XD] 750 mL $32
VINTAGES 33
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
SPAIN CASA DE ILLANA SELECCIÓN 2006 PALOMERO 2005
DO Ribera del Júcar DO Ribera del Duero
TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Casa de (Bodegas Uvaguilera)
RED WINE Illana Seleccion is a blend of 50% Petit TASTING NOTE: The 2005 Palomero
Verdot and 50% Syrah aged for is 100% Tinta Fino sourced from
AALTO 2006 18 months in 300-liter French oak. a single vineyard with vines over
DO Ribera del Duero It exhibits a smoky, toasty, blackberry, 80 years of age. It was aged for
TASTING NOTE: The opaque purple and blueberry bouquet leading to 23 months in new French oak before
2006 Aalto offers up a brooding a ripe, sweet, layered, pleasure-bent bottling without fining or filtration.
bouquet of wood smoke, graphite, wine. Dense, concentrated, and Opaque purple-colored, it offers an
espresso, leather, blueberry, and easy-to-understand, this forward effort excellent nose of toasty new oak,
blackberry liqueur. This leads to a full- is for hedonists only. Enjoy it over mineral, and black fruits. On the
bodied, dense, layered, extracted the next six years. Score: 92. (Jay palate, the wine is tightly wound,
wine with loads of fruit and the structure Miller, www.erobertparker.com, brooding, and tannic. There is plenty
to match. Impeccably balanced and June 2009) of fruit but whether it will come
exceptionally long in the finish, this into balance or stay hard and austere
large-scaled effort will benefit from 168781 [XD] 750 mL $35 remains to be seen. This is not a
5-7 years of additional cellaring and wine for the risk-averse. Score: 92+?.
provide a drinking window extending (Jay Miller, www.erobertparker.com,
from 2016 to 2036. Bodegas y Feb. 2008)
Vinedos Aalto is the estate of the
renowned Mariano Garcia, former 167460 [XD] 750 mL $59
winemaker at Vega Sicilia. Score: 94.
(Jay Miller, www.erobertparker.com,
June 2009) HERETAT MONTRUBI GAINTUS
2004
120436 [XD] 750 mL $55 TASTING NOTE: The 2004 Gaintus
is 100% Sumoll aged in French
oak for 14 months. Dark ruby-colored,
it has an enticing bouquet of cedar,
smoke, clove, cinnamon, violet, cherry,
and black raspberry. Medium-bodied,
the wine is already revealing some
complexity. Ripe, balanced, and long,
it should blossom for another 3-5 years
and show at its best through 2020.
Score: 92. (Jay Miller, www.erober-
tparker.com, Feb. 2008)
163261 [XD] 750 mL $59
34 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
O. FOURNIER SPIGA 2004 MIGUEL TORRES MAS LA PLANA BALBAS GRAN RESERVA 1996
DO Ribera del Duero CABERNET SAUVIGNON 1997 DO Ribera del Duero
TASTING NOTE: The 2004 Spiga DO Penedès TASTING NOTE: Still vibrant, this red
underwent malolactic fermentation TASTING NOTE: Ripe blackberry and shows balance and structure, with
in new barrels and was aged for cherry fruit and classy oak team up to plum, cassis, floral, chocolate and
13 months in French and American deliver the goods in this palate-pleasing light earthy flavors over firm, well-
oak before being bottled unfiltered. Cabernet Sauvignon. There’s plenty integrated tannins. Complex and
Opaque purple in color, the wine of tobacco and earth, and in style and expressive, with a long, spicy finish.
exhibits expressive aromas of mineral, weight it’s somewhere between Drink now through 2016. Score: 94.
tobacco, scorched earth, black currant Bordeaux and California, with a heavier (Thomas Matthews, www.winespe-
and blackberry jam. Medium-bodied, nod to the former. Already delicious, ctator.com, Dec. 15, 2007)
the wine offers intense, spicy, black this will hold well through the decade,
fruit flavors, layers of fruit, and a long maybe longer. It is an apt demonstra- 85373 [XD] 750 mL $95
finish. It should continue to evolve with tion of why weight and density are less
2-3 years in the cellar and drink well important than flavor, texture and
through 2024. Score: 91. (Jay Miller, balance. Take that, extraction junkies. AUSTRALIA
www.erobertparker.com, Feb. 2007) Drink now through 2008 and beyond.
Score: 92. (Michael McNeil, Wine
74740 [XD] 750 mL $35 Enthusiast, April 2002) RED WINE
70433 [XD] 750 mL $49 MITOLO REIVER SHIRAZ 2007
PALOMERO 2001 Barossa Valley, South Australia
DO Ribera del Duero TASTING NOTE: The 2007 Reiver
(Bodegas Uvaguilera) Shiraz is opaque purple-colored with
TASTING NOTE: The profound 2001 legs that ooze down the glass. Aromas
Palomero boasts an opaque of cedar, spice box, mineral, espresso,
ruby/purple color as well as an and wild blueberry are followed by
extraordinary perfume of sweet sad- an intense, sweetly fruited, lengthy
dle leather, smoke, herbs, blackber- wine that is just a bit more narrow
ries, creme de cassis, truffles, and than the superb vintages of 2004,
graphite. One of the most prodigious 2005, and 2006. Score: 92. (Jay Miller,
Ribera del Dueros I have tasted, it www.erobertparker.com, Feb. 2009)
offers great precision, fabulous con-
centration, and a long, 40+ second 41145 [D] 750 mL $49
finish. Anticipated maturity: now-
2016. Score: 96. (Robert Parker Jr.,
www.erobertparker.com, June 2005)
74559 [XD] 750 mL $65
VINTAGES 35
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
AUSTRALIA CLARENDON HILLS BROOKMAN CLARENDON HILLS ONKAPARINGA
CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2006 SYRAH 2006
Clarendon, South Australia Clarendon, South Australia
RED WINE TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Cabernet TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Syrah
Sauvignon Brookman Vineyard is Onkaparinga was reviewed as a barrel
MITOLO SAVITAR SHIRAZ 2007 a fleshy effort with gobs of flavor. It, sample in Issue 173. From a better
McLaren Vale, South Australia too, will be approachable young vintage, it is a fragrant, relatively
TASTING NOTE: The saturated purple but should drink well through 2026. forward, spicy, layered and friendly
2007 Savitar Shiraz delivers scents Score: 93. (Jay Miller, www.erobe- Syrah that will evolve for another
of underbrush, plum, and black fruits. rtparker.com, Feb. 2009) 4-6 years. Score: 94. (Jay Miller,
Opulent, layered, and dense, this www.erobertparker.com, Dec. 2009)
rich, succulent Shiraz will evolve for 64196 [XD] 750 mL $69
several years and offer prime drinking 64154 [XD] 750 mL $99
from 2011 to 2020. Score: 93.
(Jay Miller, www.erobertparker.com, CLARENDON HILLS
Feb. 2009) HICKINBOTHAM GRENACHE 2006 CLARENDON HILLS ROMAS
Clarendon, South Australia GRENACHE 2006
659581 [D] 750 mL $55 TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Grenache Clarendon, South Australia
Hickinbotham Vineyard offers more TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Grenache
aromatic complexity as well as several Romas Vineyard is the tightest and
CLARENDON HILLS BAKERS years of aging potential. Score: 94. most structured of the Grenaches.
GULLY SHIRAZ 2006 (Jay Miller, www.erobertparker.com, Impeccably balanced, it should
Clarendon, South Australia Feb. 2009) evolve for 8-10 years and drink well
TASTING NOTE: Big, supple and through 2030. Score: 95. (Jay Miller,
remarkably graceful for its size, with 928143 [XD] 750 mL $74 www.erobertparker.com, Feb. 2009)
hints of cream, cedar and clove
around a core of blackberry and 963686 [XD] 750 mL $99
pomegranate flavors, all coming
together on a seamless finish. Has
impressive length. Drink now
through 2020. Score: 94. (Harvey
Steiman, www.winespectator.com,
Oct. 15, 2008)
64147 [XD] 750 mL $74
36 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
HENSCHKE MOUNT EDELSTONE SOUTH AFRICA CATENA ZAPATA ARGENTINO
VINEYARD SHIRAZ 2005 MALBEC 2006
Eden Valley, South Australia Mendoza
TASTING NOTE: The 2005 Mount RED WINE TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Malbec
Edelstone is a 100% Shiraz cuvee Argentino is a blend of the Nicasia and
sourced from a vineyard planted in SADIE FAMILY COLUMELLA Adrianna Vineyards with the same
1912. Yields are a meager 0.3 to SHIRAZ 2006 elevage. As so often happens, the com-
0.5 tons of fruit per acre. In combi- WO Swartland bination is better than either of the
nation with a near ideal growing TASTING NOTE: Dark and alluring, individual components. It is more com-
season, this has resulted in a great with currant paste, fig sauce and plex aromatically, seems more opulent,
edition of Mount Edelstone, one dark plum notes that glide over rich has tons of flavor, and a lengthy,
of South Australia’s iconic wines. but fine-grained tannins. Hints of 60-second finish. Score: 96. (Jay Miller,
Purple-colored, the nose gives up mesquite, melted licorice and bitter- www.erobertparker.com, Aug. 2009)
notes of mocha, chocolate, smoked sweet ganache fill out the finish.
meat, pepper, leather, blueberry, Has plenty of length and concentration. 170035 [XD] 750 mL $89
and blackberry. Elegant, already This should fill out with moderate
complex, layered, and thoroughly cellaring. Syrah and Mourvèdre. Best
satisfying, this superb Shiraz has from 2009 through 2015. Score: 94. CATENA ZAPATA NICASIA VINEYARD
enough baby fat to be enjoyed now (James Molesworth, www.winespec- MALBEC 2006
but will amply reward 5-7 years tator.com, July 31, 2008) Altamira, Mendoza
of cellaring. It will drink beautifully TASTING NOTE: Dense and layered,
through 2025. Score: 97. (Jay Miller, 166785 [D] 750 mL $90 with loads of braised fig, currant
www.erobertparker.com, Feb. 2009) paste, crushed plum and macerated
blackberry fruit laced with licorice
718601 [XD] 750 mL $119 ARGENTINA snap, black tea and spice notes. The
long, broad finish has superb acidity
buried deep, letting a floral hint skitter
RED WINE in the background. Shows impressive
depth and range. Best from 2013 ...
CATENA ZAPATA ADRIANNA Score: 95. (James Molesworth, www.wi-
VINEYARD MALBEC 2006 nespectator.com, Oct. 31, 2009)
Gualtallary, Mendoza
TASTING NOTE: The 2006 Malbec 170043 [XD] 750 mL $69
Adrianna Vineyard received the
identical elevage as the Nicasia cuvee.
It has a racier personality with a silky
palate feel, sweet flavors, and excep-
tional length. It, too, merits 6-8 years
of cellaring and will present a drinking
window extending from 2013 to 2026.
Score: 95. (Jay Miller, www.erobertp-
arker.com, Aug. 2009)
170027 [XD] 750 mL $69
VINTAGES 37
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
ARGENTINA CHILE USA – CALIFORNIA
RED WINE RED WINE RED WINE
LUCA BESO DE DANTE 2006 ALTAÏR 2004 CHAPPELLET SIGNATURE
Mendoza Cachapoal Valley CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2007
TASTING NOTE: Very dark, with fig, TASTING NOTE: The 2004 Altair offers Napa Valley
cocoa and ganache notes backed a much more saturated purple color “Brilliant wines have emerged from
by coffee, black licorice and loam. Long and more complex perfume than the this showcase estate high on Pritchard
and rich through the finish, with 2003. Scorched earth, graphite, black Hill, which is producing some of the
raspberry and linzer torte notes echoing, currant, and blackberry liqueur aromas most exciting Cabernets coming out
but well-rounded, with enough fresh- make an appearance. The wine is of Napa.” (Robert Parker Jr., www.ero-
ness for balance. Should age nicely. more mouth-filling than its sibling as bertparker.com, Dec. 2009) The
Malbec, Cabernet Sauvignon, and well as more structured. Ripe black Chappellet family have been growing
Petit Verdot. Drink now through 2013. fruits persist through the pure finish. and crafting wines in Napa since
Score: 93. (James Molesworth, Cellar this beauty for 6-8 years and 1967, and the Signature Cabernet has
www.winespectator.com, Oct. 31, 2008) drink it through 2030. Score: 94. been their flagship bottling for over
(Jay Miller, www.erobertparker.com, three decades. Their guiding principle
167361 [XD] 750 mL $38 June 2007) is simple: to create great sensory
enjoyment in the finished wine. The
38430 [XD] 750 mL $59 2007 vintage of this Cabernet has
LUCA NICO BY LUCA MALBEC not yet been reviewed, though great
2005 things can be anticipated as the ‘06
Uco Valley, Mendoza was ranked #6 on Wine Spectator’s
TASTING NOTE: The 100% Malbec Top 100 list of 2009.
2005 Nico by Luca was aged for
12 months in 100% new French oak. 704254 [D] 750 mL $69
Dense purple-colored, it offers a
splendid nose of pain grille, mineral,
spice box, black cherry, and black-
berry liqueur. This leads to a full-bodied,
opulent wine with gobs of savory
fruit, outstanding balance, and serious
aging potential. Give it 4-6 years in
the cellar and drink it from 2012 to
2030 ... Luca is the personal project
of Laura Catena, M.D., daughter of
Nicolas Catena, the founder of Catena-
Zapata. Score: 95. (Jay Miller,
www.erobertparker.com, Dec. 2008)
167320 [XD] 750 mL $99
38 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
DREW FAMILY CELLARS WEIR RIDGE VINEYARDS MONTE BELLO HIGHLAND ESTATES HAWKEYE
VINEYARD PINOT NOIR 2007 2007 MOUNTAIN CABERNET
Yorkville Highlands, Mendocino Santa Cruz Mountains, Central Coast SAUVIGNON 2005
County Ridge Vineyards’ Monte Bello, a Alexander Valley, Sonoma County
TASTING NOTE: Pure, vivid wild berry Cabernet-dominant Bordeaux blend, TASTING NOTE: One of the riper of the
and blackberry fruit is both supple has accrued such a strong following Highland Estate’s current crop of
and tightly focused. Medium-bodied, that the winery offers it through a Cabernets, the Hawkeye Mountain
long and persistent on the finish, futures program to meet local demand. shows intense varietal character.
where this picks up a pleasant spicy, Expect the newly arrived 2007 vintage It’s rich in black currants and cedar,
earthy edge. Drink now through 2013. to be true to form: complex, nuanced, with a tangy minerality and firm but
Score: 92. (James Laube, www.win- generously ripe, embellished with pliant tannins. A beautiful Cabernet,
espectator.com, Aug. 31, 2009) intriguing floral and spice notes, and at its best now and through 2015.
showing ample structure to evolve Score: 93. (Steve Heimoff, Wine
176974 [D] 750 mL $49 over the next 10+ years. Enthusiast, July 2008)
711085 [XD] 750 mL $149 52266 [D] 750 mL $67
L’AVENTURE OPTIMUS 2007
Paso Robles
TASTING NOTE: The sexiest offering RUBICON 2005
at present is the 2007 Optimus Napa Valley
Proprietary red, a blend of 45% Syrah, (Rubicon Estate)
40% Cabernet Sauvignon, and TASTING NOTE: Unquestionably the
15% Petit Verdot. More fruit-forward finest wine I have ever tasted from
than the 2006, the 2007 gushes this estate owned by well-known movie
with blackberry and cassis fruit, smoky, director Francis Ford-Coppola, the
burning embers, charcoal, and toasty dense ruby/purple-colored 2005
new oak. Full-bodied and powerful Rubicon possesses wonderfully sweet
with supple tannins, decent acids, and cassis and black cherry fruit inter-
an overall impression of voluptuous- VIADER ESTATE RED 2006 woven with dusty, loamy soil, licorice,
ness as well as extravagant fruit and Napa Valley and spice box notes. Opulent and
opulence, it should drink beautifully TASTING NOTE: Bordeaux-like in its full-bodied with abundant but sweet,
for a decade. Score: (93-95). (Robert mix of flavors and structure, offering velvety tannins, this 2005 is just
Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com, loamy earth, dried currant and berry, beginning to develop its secondary
Aug. 2009) with touches of anise, sage and nuances, and should evolve for
mineral. Ends with firm, dry tannins. 2-3 decades. Kudos, this is a superb
683409 [D] 750 mL $59 Cabernet Sauvignon and Cabernet achievement! Score: 95. (Robert
Franc. Best from 2010 through 2016. Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com,
Score: 90. (James Laube, www.wi- Dec. 2009)
nespectator.com, Nov. 15, 2009)
703967 [XD] 750 mL $199
994004 [XD] 750 mL $109
VINTAGES 39
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
USA – CALIFORNIA FORTIFIED WINE QUINTA DO VALE MEÃO VINTAGE
PORT 2007
DOC Douro
RED WINE PORT (F. Olazabal & Filhos)
TASTING NOTE: Intense aromas of
SHAFER HILLSIDE SELECT DELAFORCE VINTAGE PORT 1994 crème de cassis, blackberry and wet
CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2005 DOC Douro earth. Full-bodied, with medium sweet-
Stags Leap District, Napa Valley (Quinta and Vineyard Bottlers Vinhos) ness and a solid core of dense,
TASTING NOTE: The 2005 Cabernet “1994 was a stellar vintage, one of polished tannins. It goes on for minutes.
Sauvignon Hillside Select continues to the best ever, and deserves star billing. Structure with harmony. A very
put on weight, and displays a Bordeaux- With firm chocolate on the nose, serious effort from this mighty wine
like personality because of the vin- leathery notes and intense ripe black estate. Score: 93-96. (James
tage’s cool growing season. A black berry fruits. Delicious, although Suckling, www.winespectator.com,
purple color, stunningly sweet fruit, [Taylor Fladgate Yeatman’s] Huyshe Web Only, 2009)
and a gorgeous bouquet of underbrush, Bower suggests waiting another
forest floor, creme de cassis, lead 15 years before it reaches its peak.” 164897 [MS] 750 mL $69
pencil shavings, and toasty barrique (Tim Pawsey, The Vancouver Courier,
are found in this ripe, full-bodied, deep, Nov. 2003)
stunningly well-balanced, substantial
wine with undeniable complexity as TASTING NOTE: Most of the fruit
well as richness. It is approachable for this wine came from 1994’s low-
now, but promises to evolve for 25 or yielding vines at Quinta do Corte
more years. Score: 97. (Robert which is one of the very fine yet little
Parker Jr., www.erobertparker.com, known gems in the Douro. Purplish-
Dec. 2008) ruby and just less than opaque.
Aggressive dried rose petals, raisinous
735712 [XD] 750 mL $259 and possessing black olive aromas.
Still very young and in need of LOTS
of time to enjoy this infant. Chunky
STONESTREET CABERNET fruit that tends toward rich, ripe
SAUVIGNON 2005 blackberry with light mocha and a hint
Alexander Valley, Sonoma County of vanilla extract. Big tannins await
TASTING NOTE: Although the 2005 you and this ‘tooth stainer’ just might
Cabernet Sauvignon is a softer wine, be the best Delaforce since 1963 ...
it still begs for additional bottle age. Score: 91. (Roy Hersh, www.forth-
A blend of 95% Cabernet Sauvignon eloveofport.com, June 4, 2002)
and 5% Cabernet Franc, it offers
graphite, blackberry, cassis, toasty oak, 163063 [MS] 750 mL $72
and earth notes in a full-bodied, rich
style with slightly less tannin and con-
centration than its monster sibling.
Score: 91. (Robert Parker Jr., www.ero-
bertparker.com, Dec. 2008)
4002 [D] 750 mL $49
40 VINTAGES
PRODUCT SUMMARY
SIZE PRODUCT PRICE OPENING
PRODUCT (mL) NUMBER (per btl.) SCORE INVENTORY (btls.)
FRANCE – BURGUNDY – CHABLIS WHITE WINE
DOMAINE CHRISTIAN MOREAU PÈRE & FILS
LES CLOS CHABLIS GRAND CRU 2007 750 168658 $65 BH 93 300
DOMAINE CHRISTIAN MOREAU PÈRE & FILS
VALMUR CHABLIS GRAND CRU 2007 750 641944 $59 BH 91-94 240
DOMAINE LOUIS MICHEL & FILS VAUDÉSIR CHABLIS GRAND CRU 2007 750 172569 $65 RP (92-93) 84
JEAN-CLAUDE BESSIN LA FOURCHAUME CHABLIS 1er CRU 2007 750 43497 $32 BH 91 540
JEAN-CLAUDE BESSIN LA FOURCHAUME LA PIÈCE AU COMTE CHABLIS
1er CRU 2007 750 167452 $35 BH 92 300
JEAN-CLAUDE BESSIN VALMUR CHABLIS GRAND CRU 2007 750 43513 $55 BH 93 204
LA CHABLISIENNE MONTÉE DE TONNERRE CHABLIS 1er CRU 2007 750 163303 $34 BH 91 180
CAVES DUPLESSIS MONTÉE DE TONNERRE CHABLIS 1er CRU 2006 750 168120 $33 BH 89-91 408
LA CHABLISIENNE BLANCHOT CHABLIS GRAND CRU 2006 750 581686 $59 BH 92 120
CAVES DUPLESSIS LES CLOS CHABLIS GRAND CRU 2005 750 168104 $59 BH 90-92 144
FRANCE – BORDEAUX RED WINE
CHÂTEAU BELLEVUE 2006 750 564435 $75 JR 17 197
(OUT OF 20)
CHÂTEAU CLINET 2006 750 564575 $99 RP 90+ 186
CHÂTEAU CLOS FOURTET 2006 750 563775 $85 RP 91 184
CHÂTEAU DE SALES 2006 750 565424 $34 WS 87 125
CHÂTEAU DUHART-MILON-ROTHSCHILD 2006 750 564351 $62 RP 92 374
CHÂTEAU FIGEAC 2006 750 566257 $129 WS 91 87
CHÂTEAU GAZIN 2006 750 565309 $84 WS 93 108
CHÂTEAU LA MISSION HAUT-BRION 2006 750 567164 $799 RP 95 11
CHÂTEAU LA SERRE 2006 750 565325 $52 JR 16+ 292
(OUT OF 20)
CHÂTEAU LANGOA-BARTON 2006 750 563726 $79 WS 91 647
CHÂTEAU L’ÉVANGILE 2006 750 564682 $245 RP 93 68
CHÂTEAU LUCIA 2006 750 563742 $68 JR 17 209
(OUT OF 20)
CHÂTEAU RAUZAN-SÉGLA 2006 750 564070 $104 RP 93 281
CHÂTEAU ANGÉLUS 2005 750 506071 $450 RP 98 153
CHÂTEAU ANGÉLUS 2005 1500 510545 $950 RP 98 25
CHÂTEAU BEAU-SÉJOUR BÉCOT 2005 1500 689174 $279 RP 94 112
CHÂTEAU CERTAN-MARZELLE 2005 750 501239 $79 RP 89 435
CHÂTEAU CLARKE 2005 1500 510529 $79 WS 89 277
SCORES We have included scores from the following sources:
BH www.burghound.com RH Roy Hersh, www.fortheloveofport.com
DEC www.decanter.com RP Wine Advocate, www.erobertparker.com
GR Gambero Rosso Italian Wines WE Wine Enthusiast
JR www.jancisrobinson.com WS www.winespectator.com
Due to circumstances beyond our control, opening inventory quantities are subject to change without notice.
VINTAGES 41
PRODUCT SUMMARY
SIZE PRODUCT PRICE OPENING
PRODUCT (mL) NUMBER (per btl.) SCORE INVENTORY (btls.)
FRANCE – BORDEAUX RED WINE
CHÂTEAU CÔTE DE BALEAU 2005 1500 689810 $79 WS 89 82
CHÂTEAU CROIX DE LABRIE 2005 750 501726 $128 RP 94 95
CHÂTEAU DU TERTRE 2005 750 502831 $83 RP 90 213
CHÂTEAU DUCRU-BEAUCAILLOU 2005 1500 689471 $649 RP 97 70
CHÂTEAU GRAND-PUY-LACOSTE 2005 1500 689349 $265 RP 95 88
CHÂTEAU GRUAUD-LAROSE 2005 750 502567 $95 WE 94 147
CHÂTEAU GRUAUD-LAROSE 2005 1500 689232 $195 WE 94 260
CHÂTEAU HAUT-BAILLY 2005 1500 689364 $365 RP 95 77
CHÂTEAU LA COUSPAUDE 2005 750 504902 $108 WS 92 125
CHÂTEAU LA PROVIDENCE 2005 750 501262 $135 WS 95 191
CHÂTEAU LAFON-ROCHET 2005 1500 689265 $145 WS 90 233
CHÂTEAU LE GAY 2005 750 502229 $198 RP 95+ 223
CHÂTEAU LÉOVILLE BARTON 2005 750 567693 $309 WS 96 94
CHÂTEAU MONBOUSQUET 2005 1500 689455 $195 RP 95 119
CHÂTEAU MOULIN-ST-GEORGES 2005 1500 510602 $184 WS 92 103
CHÂTEAU MOUTON ROTHSCHILD 2005 750 506311 $995 RP 96 146
CHÂTEAU MOUTON ROTHSCHILD 2005 1500 689638 $2045 RP 96 76
CHÂTEAU MOUTON ROTHSCHILD 2005 3000 689281 $4145 RP 96 4
CHÂTEAU PALMER 2005 1500 510503 $899 RP 97 116
CHÂTEAU PICHON-LONGUEVILLE COMTESSE DE LALANDE 2005 750 504068 $215 WS 93 129
CHÂTEAU PICHON-LONGUEVILLE-BARON 2005 1500 689315 $450 WS 94 131
CHÂTEAU SMITH-HAUT-LAFITTE 2005 1500 510495 $255 RP 95 94
CHÂTEAU VALANDRAUD 2005 750 506287 $545 RP 95 86
DOMAINE DE CHEVALIER 2005 1500 689430 $189 WS 93 102
LE PETIT MOUTON 2005 750 506121 $139 WS 89 44
LE PETIT MOUTON 2005 1500 689620 $289 WS 89 97
CHÂTEAU COS D’ESTOURNEL 2004 750 670927 $145 WS 94 129
FRANCE – BURGUNDY – CÔTE DE BEAUNE RED WINE
ALBERT MOROT LES TEURONS BEAUNE 1er CRU 2007 750 902833 $55 BH 90-92 228
DOMAINE ANTONIN GUYON CORTON-BRESSANDES GRAND CRU 2007 750 73668 $95 BH 90-93 228
FRANCE – BURGUNDY – CÔTE DE BEAUNE WHITE WINE
BOUCHARD PÈRE & FILS CORTON-CHARLEMAGNE GRAND CRU 2007 750 172460 $189 RP 96 108
FRANCE – RHÔNE – NORTHERN RHÔNE RED WINE
DOMAINE COURBIS LES EYGATS CORNAS 2007 750 719385 $59 RP (90-92) 168
DOMAINE DU TUNNEL STÉPHANE ROBERT VIN NOIR CORNAS 2007 750 168146 $79 RP (92-94) 120
E. GUIGAL CHÂTEAU D’AMPUIS CÔTE-RÔTIE 2005 750 741983 $149 RP (94-96) 468
E. GUIGAL HERMITAGE 2003 750 707372 $99 RP 94 240
42 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
SIZE PRODUCT PRICE OPENING
PRODUCT (mL) NUMBER (per btl.) SCORE INVENTORY (btls.)
FRANCE – RHÔNE – NORTHERN RHÔNE WHITE WINE
FRANÇOIS VILLARD LE GRAND VALLON CONDRIEU 2007 750 171603 $69 WS 93 168
E. GUIGAL HERMITAGE BLANC 2006 750 125567 $65 RP (93-95) 168
FRANCE – RHÔNE – SOUTHERN RHÔNE RED WINE
CHÂTEAU DE VAUDIEU CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE 2007 750 164871 $49 RP 92 288
CHÂTEAU DE VAUDIEU VAL DE DIEU CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE 2007 750 168872 $95 WS 94 240
DOMAINE BOIS DE BOURSAN CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE 2007 750 728014 $45 RP 90 360
DOMAINE DE LA CHARBONNIÈRE LES HAUTES BRUSQUIÈRES
CUVÉE SPÉCIALE CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE 2007 750 579581 $59 RP 95+ 600
DOMAINE DE VILLENEUVE LES VIEILLES VIGNES
CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE 2007 750 163089 $54 RP 94 300
DOMAINE DU GRAND TINEL CUVÉE ALEXIS ESTABLET
CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE 2007 750 982017 $59 RP 94 408
DOMAINE DU PEGAU CUVÉE LAURENCE CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE 2005 750 168161 $175 RP (95-97) 168
FRANCE – RHÔNE – SOUTHERN RHÔNE WHITE WINE
DOMAINE DU VIEUX TÉLÉGRAPHE LA CRAU
CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE BLANC 2008 750 736462 $59 WS 92 240
CHÂTEAU DE BEAUCASTEL VIEILLES VIGNES
CHÂTEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE BLANC 2007 750 73692 $149 RP 97 180
FRANCE – ALSACE WHITE WINE
RENÉ MURÉ CLOS ST. LANDELIN VORBOURG
SÉLECTION DE GRAINS NOBLES PINOT GRIS 2007 500 163139 $65 WS 97 60
RENÉ MURÉ CLOS ST. LANDELIN VORBOURG VENDANGES TARDIVES
GEWÜRZTRAMINER 2007 500 163147 $42 WS 93 72
FRANCE – CHAMPAGNE CHAMPAGNE
GUY CHARLEMAGNE BRUT ROSÉ CHAMPAGNE 750 143271 $55 RP 89 120
H. BILLIOT & FILS GRAND CRU BRUT RÉSERVE CHAMPAGNE 750 124537 $55 RP 90+ 150
JEAN MILAN BLANC DE BLANCS GRAND CRU BRUT SPÉCIAL CHAMPAGNE 750 143602 $59 WS 91 150
DEUTZ BRUT CHAMPAGNE 2005 750 167486 $69 RP 91 138
DEUTZ BRUT ROSÉ CHAMPAGNE 2005 750 167734 $75 WE 90 108
GUY CHARLEMAGNE LA CUVÉE MESNILLÉSIME
BLANC DE BLANCS GRAND CRU BRUT CHAMPAGNE 2002 750 163360 $85 RP 93 120
JACQUESSON AVIZE GRAND CRU BRUT CHAMPAGNE 2000 750 163352 $95 WS 89 108
FRANCE – MIDI RED WINE
MAS DU SOLEILLA LES BARTELLES LA CLAPE 2007 750 167841 $35 WS 92 348
DOMAINE GARDIÉS LA TORRE 2006 750 163055 $49 WS 93 120
ITALY – ABRUZZO RED WINE
LA VALENTINA BELLOVEDERE MONTEPULCIANO D’ABRUZZO 2005 750 167445 $69 RP 94 138
ITALY – CAMPANIA RED WINE
TERREDORA CAMPORE TAURASI RISERVA 2003 750 93070 $44 RP 92 180
VINTAGES 43
PRODUCT SUMMARY
SIZE PRODUCT PRICE OPENING
PRODUCT (mL) NUMBER (per btl.) SCORE INVENTORY (btls.)
ITALY – FRIULI WHITE WINE
VINTAGE TUNINA 2007 750 964825 $59 WS 92 120
W ... DREAMS ... 2007 750 51524 $59 WS 93 120
ITALY – PIEDMONT RED WINE
FALLETTO DI BRUNO GIACOSA BAROLO 2005 750 92130 $199 RP 94 78
MARCARINI BRUNATE BAROLO 2005 750 167494 $59 RP 92 240
MARCHESI DI BAROLO CANNUBI BAROLO 2005 750 980912 $55 WS 91 240
PARUSSO 35 ANNATA BAROLO 2005 750 163345 $69 WS 92 90
PIO CESARE BAROLO 2005 750 736587 $75 WS 93 300
PIO CESARE IL BRICCO BARBARESCO 2005 750 730275 $99 WS 95 240
PIO CESARE ORNATO BAROLO 2005 750 974956 $99 WS 95 360
CASTELLO DI VERDUNO MASSARA BAROLO 2004 750 163204 $65 DEC ##### 144
(OUT OF 5)
FONTANABIANCA SORÍ BURDIN BARBARESCO 2004 750 83667 $55 RP 92 180
MARCHESI DI GRÉSY CAMP GROS MARTINENGA BARBARESCO 2004 750 172510 $89 RP 94 108
TRAVAGLINI TRE VIGNE GATTINARA 2004 750 35329 $45 GR ggg 180
(OUT OF 3)
ITALY – SICILY RED WINE
PASSOPISCIARO 2007 750 169078 $49 RP 92 180
TERRE NERE CALDERARA SOTTANA 2006 750 163881 $55 RP 92 138
VALLE DELL’ACATE TANÉ 2004 750 169086 $55 RP 92 138
ITALY – TUSCANY RED WINE
TENUTA DI TRINORO LE CUPOLE TRINORO 2007 750 30361 $45 RP 92 240
CARNASCIALE 2006 750 167288 $79 RP 93 150
CASTELLARE DI CASTELLINA VIGNA IL POGGIALE
CHIANTI CLASSICO RISERVA 2006 750 606947 $39 WS 91 288
CASTELLO DI AMA L’APPARITA 2006 750 39776 $159 RP 95 120
CASTELLO DI AMA VIGNETO BELLAVISTA CHIANTI CLASSICO 2006 750 163337 $165 RP 96 108
CASTELLO DI AMA VIGNETO LA CASUCCIA CHIANTI CLASSICO 2006 750 979278 $169 RP 96 120
FATTORIA LE PUPILLE SAFFREDI 2006 750 74435 $109 RP 96 708
FATTORIA NITTARDI NECTAR DEI 2006 750 163311 $69 WS 94 120
FONTODI FLACCIANELLO DELLA PIEVE 2006 750 963744 $85 WS 99 300
IL CABERLOT 2006 1500 167296 $375 RP 95 48
ISOLE E OLENA CEPPARELLO 2006 750 25650 $75 RP 93 240
MILLEPASSI BOLGHERI SUPERIORE 2006 750 163840 $59 WS 94 298
MONTEVERTINE 2006 750 167742 $49 RP 93 240
RICCARDO BARACCHI ARDITO 2006 750 163717 $55 WS 95 408
SAVIGNOLA PAOLINA CHIANTI CLASSICO RISERVA 2006 750 163659 $35 WS 92 180
VIGNAMAGGIO CASTELLO DI MONNA LISA CHIANTI CLASSICO RISERVA 2006 750 930651 $35 RP 90 240
VITICCIO MONILE 2006 750 163279 $54 WS 94 180
44 VINTAGES
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
SIZE PRODUCT PRICE OPENING
PRODUCT (mL) NUMBER (per btl.) SCORE INVENTORY (btls.)
POGGIOMANDORLO 2005 750 163329 $79 WS 94 120
CASALOSTE INVERSUS 2004 750 163295 $55 WS 94 210
LA TOGATA BRUNELLO DI MONTALCINO 2004 750 168153 $69 WS 95 468
ITALY – VENETO RED WINE
TENUTA SANT’ANTONIO CAMPO DEI GIGLI 750 681627 $79 GR ggg 138
AMARONE DELLA VALPOLICELLA 2004 (OUT OF 3)
QUINTARELLI AMARONE DELLA VALPOLICELLA CLASSICO 2000 750 986109 $399 RP 96+ 360
QUINTARELLI ROSSO DEL BEPI 1999 750 991356 $199 RP 92 468
QUINTARELLI ALZERO 1998 750 716423 $499 RP 92 180
QUINTARELLI RECIOTO DELLA VALPOLICELLA CLASSICO 1997 375 932343 $189 RP 94 120
PORTUGAL RED WINE
EVEL GRANDE RESERVA 2007 750 163253 $32 WE 91 180
RAMOS PINTO DUAS QUINTAS RESERVA 2006 750 951301 $39 WS 92 138
CALLABRIGA RESERVA 2004 750 163287 $29 WE 92 180
SPAIN RED WINE
AALTO 2006 750 120436 $55 RP 94 240
CASA DE ILLANA SELECCIÓN 2006 750 168781 $35 RP 92 180
PALOMERO 2005 750 167460 $59 RP 92+? 180
HERETAT MONTRUBI GAINTUS 2004 750 163261 $59 RP 92 120
O. FOURNIER SPIGA 2004 750 74740 $35 RP 91 360
PALOMERO 2001 750 74559 $65 RP 96 348
MIGUEL TORRES MAS LA PLANA CABERNET SAUVIGNON 1997 750 70433 $49 WE 92 240
BALBAS GRAN RESERVA 1996 750 85373 $95 WS 94 108
AUSTRALIA RED WINE
MITOLO REIVER SHIRAZ 2007 750 41145 $49 RP 92 360
MITOLO SAVITAR SHIRAZ 2007 750 659581 $55 RP 93 360
CLARENDON HILLS BAKERS GULLY SHIRAZ 2006 750 64147 $74 WS 94 300
CLARENDON HILLS BROOKMAN CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2006 750 64196 $69 RP 93 588
CLARENDON HILLS HICKINBOTHAM GRENACHE 2006 750 928143 $74 RP 94 348
CLARENDON HILLS ONKAPARINGA SYRAH 2006 750 64154 $99 RP 94 300
CLARENDON HILLS ROMAS GRENACHE 2006 750 963686 $99 RP 95 360
HENSCHKE MOUNT EDELSTONE VINEYARD SHIRAZ 2005 750 718601 $119 RP 97 348
SOUTH AFRICA RED WINE
SADIE FAMILY COLUMELLA SHIRAZ 2006 750 166785 $90 WS 94 138
VINTAGES 45
PRODUCT SUMMARY
SIZE PRODUCT PRICE OPENING
PRODUCT (mL) NUMBER (per btl.) SCORE INVENTORY (btls.)
ARGENTINA RED WINE
CATENA ZAPATA ADRIANNA VINEYARD MALBEC 2006 750 170027 $69 RP 95 180
CATENA ZAPATA ARGENTINO MALBEC 2006 750 170035 $89 RP 96 168
CATENA ZAPATA NICASIA VINEYARD MALBEC 2006 750 170043 $69 WS 95 168
LUCA BESO DE DANTE 2006 750 167361 $38 WS 93 888
LUCA NICO BY LUCA MALBEC 2005 750 167320 $99 RP 95 30
CHILE RED WINE
ALTAÏR 2004 750 38430 $59 RP 94 480
USA – CALIFORNIA RED WINE
CHAPPELLET SIGNATURE CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2007 750 704254 $69 144
DREW FAMILY CELLARS WEIR VINEYARD PINOT NOIR 2007 750 176974 $49 WS 92 288
L’AVENTURE OPTIMUS 2007 750 683409 $59 RP (93-95) 240
RIDGE VINEYARDS MONTE BELLO 2007 750 711085 $149 450
VIADER ESTATE RED 2006 750 994004 $109 WS 90 324
HIGHLAND ESTATES HAWKEYE MOUNTAIN CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2005 750 52266 $67 WE 93 120
RUBICON 2005 750 703967 $199 RP 95 120
SHAFER HILLSIDE SELECT CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2005 750 735712 $259 RP 97 210
STONESTREET CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2005 750 4002 $49 RP 91 240
FORTIFIED WINE PORT
DELAFORCE VINTAGE PORT 1994 750 163063 $72 RH 91 108
QUINTA DO VALE MEÃO VINTAGE PORT 2007 750 164897 $69 WS 93-96 298
46 VINTAGES
VINTAGES PRESENTS
TASTE 0NTARIO!
Wine country comes to
Ottawa one night only.
Discover why premium Ontario wines are
causing such a stir. Meet some of Ontario’s
most talented and passionate winemakers.
Monday May 10, 6:30 pm – 9:00 pm
National Gallery of Canada, Ottawa
$45 per person
Visit vintages.com for full event details.
Order your tickets today.
Call 416-365-5767 or 1-800-266-4764
Monday to Saturday, 9 am to 6 pm
In partnership with
Wines poured at this event will be measured and some wines may run out. Due to
printing lead time, we cannot guarantee tickets will be available. All ticket sales are final.
TORONTO
Wednesday, June 9, 2010
Vintages presents Artscape Wychwood Barns,
601 Christie St.
best of Walk-around Tasting
6:30 pm – 9:00 pm
Braai the OTTAWA
Thursday, June 10, 2010
Brookstreet Hotel,
525 Legget Dr.
Walk-around Tasting
6:30 pm – 9:00 pm
South African $75 per person
Wine Tasting Visit vintages.com for more information
& Barbeque
Order your tickets today
Call 416 - 365 - 5767 or
There’s never been a more 1- 800 - 266 - 4764
perfect time to explore
South African flavour. Taste Monday to Saturday,
over 80 premium wines 9 am to 6 pm
from this up-and-coming Wines poured at this event will be measured and some
wines may run out. Due to printing lead time, we
wine region. cannot guarantee tickets will be available. All ticket
sales are final.
Explore wines from
V I N TA G E S P R E S E N T S iconic Italian regions,
and meet principals from
17 famed estates.
GrandiGMarchi
TAS T I N E V E N T
Monday, May 3, 2010
Le Méridien King Edward
37 King St. East, Toronto
Walk-around Tasting
6:30 p.m. – 9:00 p.m.
Great Italian wines from $95 per person
great Italian families.
Visit vintages.com for more info.
Order your tickets today.
Call 416-365-5767 or 1-800-266-4764
Monday to Saturday, 9 am to 6 pm.
Wines poured at this event will be measured and some
wines may run out. Due to printing lead time, we cannot
9822
guarantee tickets will be available. All ticket sales are final.
VINTAGES Sample over 50 wines
from the May 2010 collection including
CLASSICS highlights of the Rhône, treasures from
Tuscany and chart-topping New World
wines. All featured wines are available
TASTE & BUY for ordering on-site.*
Monday, April 26, 2010
Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto
100 Queen’s Park
6:30 pm – 9:00 pm
$95 per person
Visit vintages.com for more info.
Order your tickets today.
Call 416-365-5767 or 1-800-266-4764
Monday to Saturday, 9 am to 6 pm.
*Featured wines only will be available for ordering at the event. VINTAGES
reserves the right to limit quantities; only a portion of overall allocation is
available for sale at the event, and some may sell out. All products are
allocated randomly by our order-taking system.
Due to printing lead time, we cannot guarantee tickets will be available.
All ticket sales are final.
9803
calling all
consigners!
It’s that time of year again.
Time to take a look at the gems
you have stored in your wine cellar
and consider what you’d like to sell
at auction in order to make good
on your liquid investment.
Last year, our auction realized
$2 million in sales.
We invite you to bring out your
best wines and consign them to
the VINTAGES Fall 2010 Auction
to be held in Toronto.
Consignments from the public will be
accepted until July 15, 2010
Please direct your inquiries or information
on your cellar inventories to:
John Yoxall,
Vintages Auction Coordinator, LCBO
Tel: 416-864-6890
Fax: 416-864-2476
Email: john.yoxall@lcbo.com
DON’T MISS OUT!
ORDER BORDEAUX FUTURES NOW AND BEAT THE IN-STORE RUSH.
One of the biggest stories of the 2008 Bordeaux Futures campaign is the affordable price
tags of these exciting wines—this is one of the most extraordinary buying opportunities
in recent memory. There’s lots of choice now, but when this vintage hits store shelves
in late 2011, the selection will be limited and prices could be higher—so order now.
Visit www.vintages.com/futures for ordering information and a complete list of available
*
products plus tasting notes and scores.
insider
picks
Here are a few offerings from the 2008 Bordeaux
Haut-Bailly
(Pessac-Léognan/Graves)
136895
Price/Bottle $95
Price/Lot $285
Futures, chosen by VINTAGES buyer Greg Dunlop.
But remember, this is just a sampling of our
favourites—there’s lots more available to order.
Visit www.vintages.com/futures for details.
Pontet-Canet
(Pauillac)
La Confession
(Saint-Émilion)
‘‘ Delivers quality approaching
the best of Bordeaux,
at a fraction of the cost.
Cos d’Estournel
(Saint-Estèphe)
’’
137315 136440 136564
Price/Bottle $125 Price/Bottle $49 Price/Bottle $169
Price/Lot $375 Price/Lot $147 Price/Lot $507
‘‘
Here’s a candidate
for wine of the vintage.
Run, don’t walk.
The new, ultra-modern cellars
at Château Cos d’Estournel.
’’ ‘‘ A hot property with a loyal
following—the winery is
co-owned by Canadian wine
impresario John Howard.
’’ ‘‘
A Bordeaux icon and
undisputed King of
Saint-Estèphe.
’’
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION • MAY 2010
HOW TO ORDER
FAX AND MAIL ORDERING DEADLINE – IMPORTANT PAYMENT INFORMATION –
6:00 pm, Tuesday, May 11, 2010 PLEASE READ
Per-Customer Limits
ORDERING DETAILS We do our best to secure enough stock to satisfy all customer
Faxed and mailed orders received any time before Tuesday, orders. We regret that sometimes customer demand may
May 11, 6:00 pm EST will be processed before telephone exceed supply. In order to distribute the products more
ordering begins on Friday, May 21. equitably throughout customer orders, all products in this offer
are subject to per-customer limits. To ensure adherence to
VINTAGES will continue to accept orders after 6:00 pm on Tuesday, per-customer limits and maximize distribution of limited products
May 11, however, priority will be given to those orders received to our customers, individual credit cards may only be applied
by the deadline. to one order.
We will confirm your order by phone.
ORDER PROCESSING
FAX Due to the limited nature of Classics Collection products, all
Complete the order form provided and fax it to us at: products in this program are allocated randomly by our order-
416 365-5777 or toll-free 1 800 282-2197. taking system. Any over-sold products are subject to per-customer
Tip: if sending your order by fax, always retain your successful limits, with 2 bottles generally being the minimum for 750 mL
fax transmission report. bottles. We regret that some products are so highly requested that
our supply may reach zero before all orders receive an allocation.
MAIL Prices are subject to change without notice.
Complete an order form and mail or courier it to us at the
address below. DELIVERY
VINTAGES CLASSICS COLLECTION Upon confirmation and payment of your order, please allow
11th Floor, Suite 1100, 1 Yonge St. 4-6 weeks for delivery to the LCBO store of your choice. A store
Toronto, ON representative will contact you when your order is ready for
M5E 1E5 pick up. Please take along your final receipt as proof of purchase
upon pick up. Orders must be picked up within 30 days
of notification.
Visit www.vintages.com/classics
for more ordering options.
POUR RECEVOIR CE CATALOGUE EN FRANÇAIS.
TELEPHONE ORDERING – Tél. : 416-365-5767
Sans frais : 1-800-266-4764
Starting 9:00 am, Friday, May 21, 2010
After initial processing of fax and mail orders, telephone
ordering begins at 9:00 am, Friday, May 21, 2010.
Remember, not all products will be available by the time
telephone ordering begins! Phone orders are filled on a THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATRONAGE
first-come, first-served basis.
Call VINTAGES at 416-365-5767 or
toll-free at 1-800-266-4764.
NOTE OUR NEW HOURS OF OPERATION:
For your added convenience, our sales centre is now
open Monday to Saturday, from 9 am until 6 pm.
VINTAGES CLASSICS ORDER FORM MAY 2010
FAX: 416-365-5777 OR TOLL-FREE 1-800-282-2197
ORDERING DEADLINE: 6 PM, TUESDAY, MAY 11, 2010
Company Name (if applicable) Licensee Number (if applicable)
Name Day Phone Number
Address Evening Phone Number
Suite City Province Postal Code
Air Miles Card Number
TM
Check here if above address is new.
The personal information on this form is collected under the authority of the Liquor Control Act, Sec. 3(N), R.S.O. 1990 Cl.18 for the purpose of processing your order and
providing future CLASSICS mailings. Should you have any questions regarding the collection and/or use of this information, please contact: vintages@lcbo.com.
A VINTAGES REPRESENTATIVE WILL CONTACT YOU TO OBTAIN PAYMENT INFORMATION.
Ship to Store Location: Store Number:
PRODUCT # QTY PRODUCT NAME PAGE # PRICE AMOUNT
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
TOTAL $
Visit www.vintages.com/classics for more ordering options. PAGE OF
VINTAGES reserves the right to limit quantities on any products in the interest of overall customer demand. To ensure adherence to per-customer
limits and maximize distribution of limited products to our customers, individual credit cards may only be applied to one order.
VINTAGE CHART
1971 – 2008
Pull-out
THE CLASSICS COLLECTION
Department #907
55 Lake Shore Blvd. East
Toronto, Ontario
M5E 1A4
VINTAGE CHART
This Vintage Chart is provided as a guide for you. Vintage charts are always approximations. First, the regions invite the broadest
KEY
of generalizations. Second, the best wine growers can often deliver little gems when the rest produce less than stellar wines.
As with vintage charts, the maturity advisor (see key at far right) is only a guide. Again, we are making the broadest generalizations. 10 Exceptional A Should be aged more
Different wine lovers have different expectations: some want more fruit, some more complexity. Also, bottles from older vintages
can be highly variable due to cellaring differences and other circumstances. As always, we urge you to taste for yourself, keep 8–9 Excellent B Already good, better examples can improve further
an open mind and trust your own palate. 7 Very Good C Ready to drink
5–6 Good D Danger that many wines are becoming too old
The following keys are used to evaluate the vintages and their maturity:
0–4 Fair to Poor – Not Rated
1971
1972
1973
1974
1975
1976
1977
1978
1979
1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
YEAR 7D 3D 5D 4D 9D 7D 4D 7C 7C 5D 7C 10 B 8B 4D 9B 9B 6C 8B 9B 10 B 5C 5C 6B 7B 9B 8B 6B 8A 7B 10 A 8A 7A 9A 8A 10 A 8B 7B 8A
Bordeaux Red
Sauternes 6D 3D 6D 4D 9C 7C 3D 7D 6C 7C 7C 6C 9B 4C 7B 9B 6C 10 B 10 B 10 B 5C 5C 5C 5C 7B 8B 9B 7A 6B 6A 10 A 7A 8A 7A 9A 8A 9A 7B
Burgundy Red 7D 8D 6D 7D 5D 9D 5D 9C 7D 6D 7D 5D 8C 6D 6C 6C 7C 9B 9C 10 B 7C 6C 9B 7C 8B 9B 8C 7C 9B 7B 8B 9B 8B 7B 10 A 8A 7B _
Burgundy White 7D 7D 8D 7D 6D 8D 6D 8D 7D 6D 7D 7D 7C 6D 9C 8C 6D 7B 9B 9C 5C 8B 6C 8C 10 B 9B 9B 7C 9B 7A 7B 9A 7A 6A 9A 9A 8A –
FRANCE Alsace 9C 6D 8D 6D 8D 10 C 7D 9D 8D 7D 7D 8D 10 C 6D 9B 7C 7C 9B 9B 9B 6D 7C 8B 9B 9B 9B 9B 9B 8B 8B 9B 9A 6A 8A 9A 7B 9B _
Northern Rhône 7D 7D 7D 7D 6D 8D 5D 8C 6D 8D 7C 7C 8B 7D 9B 7C 7C 9B 9B 9B 9B 5C 4C 8B 9B 8B 7B 9B 10 A 9A 9A 7B 9A 8A 9A 9A 8A 7B
Southern Rhône 7D 7D 7D 7D 6D 8D 5D 8C 6D 8D 7C 7C 8B 7D 7C 7C 6C 9B 9B 10 B 5C 4C 4C 7B 9B 7B 8B 10 B 9B 9A 9A 5B 9A 9A 10 A 9A 10 A 7B
Loire 9C 2D 6D 5D 7D 8C 2D 8D 6D 5D 6D 8D 9C 7D 7C 7C 7C 8C 9C 10 C 5D 6C 7C 8C 8C 9C 10 C 8C 7C 8C 8C 9B 9B 8B 9B 6B 8B 7B
Champagne 8D 4D 8D 5D 9C 8C 3D 7D 8C 7D 8D 9C 7C 4D 9B 7C 5D 9B 8B 10 B 6C 7B 8B 7B 9A 10 A 7B 7B 8A 8A 6B 9A 7A 8A 7A _ _ _
Rhine 10 C 5D 6D 6D 8D 9C 4D 6D 7D 6D 7D 6D 9B 6D 7B 6C 6C 9B 9B 10 B 6C 7B 6B 6B 7B 8B 8B 9B 9B 9A 9A 8A 8A 9A 9A 8B 8B 8B
GERMANY
Mosel 10 D 6D 6D 6D 9C 9C 5D 6D 7D 7D 7D 7D 9B 6D 7B 6C 6C 9B 9B 10 B 6C 7B 8B 8B 9B 8B 8B 9B 10 C 9A 9A 8A 8A 9A 10 A 8B 9A 8A
Piedmont 10 C 2D 6D 9C 5D 5D 6D 9C 8C 5D 6D 9B 5D 6D 9B 8C 7C 8B 10 B 10 B 5C 5C 8B 7B 9B 10 A 9B 9A 9A 9B 9A 7B 8A 10 A 8A 9A _ _
Tuscany 10 C 5D 5D 9D 9C 6D 9C 10 C 8C 5D 6D 7C 7C 6D 9C 8C 7C 10 B 6C 10 B 6C 6C 7B 7B 9B 8B 9B 9B 9B 9A 9B 7B 8A 9A 8A 10 A 9A _
ITALY
Veneto 9C 8D 8C 7D 8D 6D 8C 6C 8C 7C 7C 8B 7B 6D 8B 8C 8C 9B 8B 9A 6B 6B 8B 8B 8B 8B 9B 9A 8A 8A 8A 7B 9A 9A 8A 8A _ _
Friuli 8D 7D 7D 6D 5D 8D 6D 8D 9C 5D 7C 9B 8C 6D 8B 9B 7C 7C 9B 9B 6B 6B 5B 6B 7B _ 9B 9B 8B 8B 7B 7B 9A 8A 8A 8B _ _
Port _ _ _ _ 7C _ 10 B 7C _ 6B _ 7B 8B _ 9C _ 8B _ _ _ 9A 9A _ 10 A 9A _ 10 A _ _ 10 A 8B _ 10 A 9A 8B _ 10 A _
PORTUGAL
Douro Red _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 9B 7B 5B 8B 8B 8B _ _ _
Rioja 4D 4D 7C 7C 9C 7C 5D 9B 6C 7C 9C 10 B 7C 6C 7C 7C 9B 7B 7B 8B 5C 6C 6C 8B 9B 7B 8B 8B 8B 7B 9B 6B 8B 9B 9B 8B 8B –
SPAIN Ribera del Duero _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 8B 9B 9B 9B 8B 8B 9B 7B 9B 6B 8B 9B 6C 8B 9B 8B 8A 8B –
Priorat _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 8B 8B 9B 9B 10 B 8B 8B 8B –
CANADA Niagara Peninsula – – – – – – – – – 8D 3D 6D 7D 4D 9C 4D 7C 9C 6C 9B 5B 8B 8B 7B 9B 8B 9B 8B 8B 7B 8A 8A 6B 8A 9A 8A 9A 8B
South Australia 5D 7D 10 C 3D 7D 10 C 7D 7D 8D 7C 4D 8C 4D 10 B 9B 7C 8C 9B 9B 9B 9B 7C 8C 9B 7B 9B 8B 10 B 8B 7B 9A 9A 8A 9A 10 A 7A 8A 9B
AUSTRALIA
Western Australia _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 8B 9B 8B 8B 9A 9A 8A 8A 9A 7B 8B 9A 8B 8B –
California Cabernet 8D 6D 7D 9C 7D 8D 7D 9C 8D 7C 8C 6D 7C 9B 9B 9C 9C 6C 6C 10 B 9B 8B 8B 10 B 9B 9B 10 B 7B 9A 7B 9A 9A 8A 8A 9A 8B 9B 8B
UNITED STATES
California Chardonnay 7D 6D 7D 8D 9D 8D 8D 8D 7D 7D 7D 7D 8D 8D 9D 8D 7D 7D 6D 8C 8C 9C 9B 7B 10 B 9B 10 B 8B 9B 8A 7B 9B 9A 9A 8A 8B 9B –
CHILE Red _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 8B 7C 9B 8B 9B 8B 9A 8A 9A 8A 9A 8A 8A 8B 8B 9A
ARGENTINA Mendoza Red _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ – 8C 7C 9B 8B 8B 9A 9A 9A 10 A 9A 8A 8A 9A 8A 8A
SOUTH AFRICA Red – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – 8B 9B 9B 8B 9A 8A 6A 10 A 8A 7A 8B 8B 7A
www.vintages.com
CLASSICS COLLECTION 3096149
Department #907
55 Lake Shore Blvd. East
Toronto, Ontario
M5E 1A4
9831